Resigning to Fate or Surreal Love? What is it?

saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Hello All!
I am sure Yesterday's episode has been emotionally draining and very confusing for you as well.
Had it been full of loud emotions or big words, It would have been easier to understand what's going on in their minds, but because it was unexpectedly calm, subtle . .It was much more painful for us to see.
I think this show is still able to deliver the maturity it promised in the initial promos.

When I saw first saw the episode, It hit me hard with the way Dev was so open to the idea for second marriage. We all have grown up seeing and hearing about how love alone is sufficient to live through the life. Personally too, I believe being faithful is everything in a relationship and with Dev being so okay with marrying a random XYZ girl specially after confessing in his subconscious state that he was miserable without her, it seemed unreal and hurtful.

But I saw the episode again in peace today and saw it in a slightly different light.
The episode begins with Sonakshi promising her father
"Humare beech kuch nahi hai. Aur I am sure kuch ho bhi nahi sakta"
Sonakshi has entirely resigned to fate, given up on this relationship. She promises Baba because she knows it is her fate anyway, even if staying away from him would kill her, she knows they are never going to come back together happily.
Then, when Bijoy says "Ab mai nahi ja raha"
She says, "Mai apko jaane bhi nahi deti"
Whatever she had to do, she would have done it to keep Bijoy happy.

Here, Dev is restless to talk to Sonakshi. If you notice, what triggered Dev going to meet her at night was GKB saying Ishwari will talk to Sonakshi about the wish herself and it might also include the Bose family. This made Dev worried because obviously Ishwari herself talking to Sona about this would make things worse between them. Before GKB said this, Dev was very clear in his monologue as well as before gkb that he can't give what his mom wants.

When they finally meet, Dev is very hesitant to initiate the conversation and naturally so. What was worth noticing is how when Sonakshi makes him sit on the bumper when he feels dizzy, they share an eye lock. . Which lasted somewhat longer with Dev looking more intently at her and Sona breaking the eye contact.
He doesn't begin directly by saying what Ishwari said. He starts it in third person, "Kisi ne mujhse aisa kuch pucha..."

Sonakshi wonders how he is so sure about getting an answer from her. How Dev replied to this by saying "Kisi ko chhodne ke liye usse jaan na bohot zaruri hota hai" reflectance he still lives in the guilt of not being good enough for her.
I believe Dev came to Sonakshi, less for assessing her reactions (can't be ruled out completely) but more to know whether their relationship still stands a chance and to genuinely share his feelings about the situation and more importantly, know how she perceives it all.
When Sonakshi asks what he replied when Ishwari suggested their reconciliation (which was so calm, she did not overreact by questioning the absurdity of this question), he replies
"Pehle to maine mana kar diya par muje samaj nahi aa raha tha mai kya bol raha hu"
He was indirectly trying to say that he wasn't completely hopeless about being back with her.
What changed Sona's expressions was when Dev said , "Maa ko lagta hai mai akela hu". She understands Ishwari is wishing for this, not because of their eternal love or any such thing but because she feels he is alone and miserable.
Thus, it is followed by a question
"Kya tumhe lagta hai tumhe life partner ki zarurat hai?"
Dev admits he feels lonely and then tells her about Ishwari's suggestion for some other girl.

As soon as he said that, the tyre slipped from Sonakshi's hand.. and hurt her. I think it beautifully symbolized how terribly hurt she was. She pulls back her hand and Dev goes to her to ask "If she was hurt"
This was Dev trying to read her eyes by seeing if this talk hurt her like it hurt him. Sona out on her facade back by saying she was okay, Dev witnessed this change and que stions "Or mujhe dard ho raha hai uska kya?"
I think nothing else could symbolize how Sona was hurt and still remained calm and then Dev could see it all and thus questioned her about his pain. Me (Dev) marrying someone else could be okay for you (Sona) but what about my own pain? Notice how she went behind the car to regain her composure and only then could she calmly explain to Dev how they will always keep fighting every next day. .And it would affect Soha.
I believe it was all shallow explanations to escape the other odds in their lives. Dev was disappointed as he lowered his head to agree with her.
She says , "it would be a milestone for us"
"Us??"
Dev is perplexed because he cannot understand how him marrying someone else would mean a progress in their relationship!
Isnt it so ironic that even when they are talking about making space for another one in their lives, they are evaluating it all by its effect on their relationship.
Sonakshi brings it all to a closure for him, ready to erase everything from the past, wouldn't that mean erasing all the good memories as well?
As ashwathy di's post also said Sonakshi talking about being friends with him , with a fresh new beginning would mean taking away all his rights as her ex, as her love.
Obviously, if Dev marries someone else, it would eliminate their chances of coming back forever, with zilch hopes, that would mean no complexities, no doubts, no holding back! Hence a new beginning.
I see this track parallel to Natasha track where Dev was absolutely clueless about what to do, he just was going with the flow, it kept making him restless but he did not understand, he kept going to Sona again and again for solace, for advices as a 'friend' but he didn't realise it until the last day that It was her love without which he could not do.
Right now, while Sona has resigned to fate, Dev like the previous Sona has started believing in the concept of Surreal Love. He knows his love for her is intact and that is sufficient for him. For pleasing the world, he can do whatever his mom wishes him to.
(Edit- not to forget, how he concluded by saying "Agar tum khush ho, to its good" and when Sonakshi said She told bana nothing will happen he asks "How can you be so sure?")
Also, don't you think Dev evaluating this option of marrying someone else is hai last, very futile, attempt to escape the everyday pain of not being with her. What Sona tried with R, trying to fill that emptiness by putting someone else in Deb's place.
We all know what that resulted in.

Would love to read your views because I honestly don't know if I made sense or not😆


Edited by saumiee - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.4k

Users

8

Likes

129

Frequent Posters

melliflous thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Wonderfully deciphered all the conversation!
What was disturbing was their absolute calmness... it was very painful. Had it been outburst of emotions, we wouldn't have felt this way. But I guess, their emptiness and storm within is killing us
saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: melliflous

Wonderfully deciphered all the conversation!
What was disturbing was their absolute calmness... it was very painful. Had it been outburst of emotions, we wouldn't have felt this way. But I guess, their emptiness and storm within is killing us

Thank you😃
Absolutely! We know they are having a storm inside yet they are so calm..It was quite unexpected.
allizzwell thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Gkb and red plans r flop these days...truly hoping seeing someone else as life partner wont b easy for both Dev - Sona and no matter what comprises they plan for their respective families, their separation will make them realise their closeness even more...I was disappointed with the easeness with which Dev said he is told to settle with someone else if Sona refuses...keen to know how it goes from here.
saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: -allizwell-

Gkb and red plans r flop these days...truly hoping seeing someone else as life partner wont b easy for both Dev - Sona and no matter what comprises they plan for their respective families, their separation will make them realise their closeness even more...I was disappointed with the easeness with which Dev said he is told to settle with someone else if Sona refuses...keen to know how it goes from here.

Same here! I was disappointed too but I think we will know more about their thought process, specially Dev's on Monday.
If Dev actually agrees to marry someone so calmly without any realisation, I would think I invested in a wrong show. Which I am sure won't happen though.
allizzwell thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: saumiee

Same here! I was disappointed too but I think we will know more about their thought process, specially Dev's on Monday.
If Dev actually agrees to marry someone so calmly without any realisation, I would think I invested in a wrong show. Which I am sure won't happen though.

Exactly, I felt zoned out as Ishu too suggested a remarraige saying Soha will understand things once she grows up...how come she dint think Soha will definitely not agree to accepting someone else in Dev's life and it could b the end of a bond for her...How come Ishu is diverted more into marraige matters and not enjoying the grace week of Soha's stay with her...how come Dev is calm and considering a remarraige and not even thinking of Soha...this track if started to make Dev and Sona realise their OWN bonding then fine...else its all messed up with total ignorance to Soha.
asha2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Saumie...a very beautiful writeup on a heart breaking episode of my favourite serial these days...
I know most people would be very upset that how can Dev be so calm about moving on with someone else when he is so deeply in love with Sona as well witnessed when he confessed his love for her after having the truth serum.

After watching yesterdays episode i seriously believe that Dev is at crossroads... he is testing waters with Sona. She has told him that nothing else is possible between them. But now he is just using his mother's ultimatum as an excuse to force some reaction from Sona. Sona, is stoic and of late though she is cordial with him, doesnt talk much other than Khatri with him. He misses the old Sona whose presence ensured that his life was alright. Having Sona by his side made his feel more empowered. Remember the line he spoke the day after he proposed to her - zindagi mein pehli baar maine apne liye kuch chuna hai... it holds good true today also...

He is shocked at the end when Sona says that when he remarries they would become better friends alongwith co - parents. But at the same time she says their past together (good and bad) would be a closed chapter forever... Dev did not expect this end to the conversation. He wants her back desperately and he is willing to do any thing for it. He miscalculated as to how much Sona has changed in the last 7 years... the old Sona would have run into his arms without a second thought. This Sona is stoic... she has lost her smile... she is pragmatic and seems to have now friend zoned him forever...

Their love story now reminds me more and more of Mason Capwell and Julia Wainright...of the old American soap Santa Barbara. In that also Mason and Julia are absolutely different people madly in love with each other ... but not always together... Those who have seen the soap may understand what i am saying. Julia was the first person Mason would go to for everything ... even when married to someone else...

hmmm lets see how this works out...
gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Beautiful post Somu. Just finished watching the last three episode now. And I understood what DD meant that Dev and Sona are arrogant in their love. Sona said that she is happy for him,that he should listen to his mother and marry another girl with the arrogance of her superior love for him which she is sure no one can match upto. She is sure that he will never forget the kind of love she had for him and it is kind of immortal.
For Dev it was enough to know she will never reconsider marrying someone else even if her Baba asks her to. She is content with living a life with only his memories which is a testament of his superior love which he knows no one would be able to give her.
SammP thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Your post as always beautiful. I loved Dev and Sona's convo to a level that for me this is their best scene.
But believe me this time it is not about reunion of Dev- Sona. It is all about reunion of two families. Ishwari has to know that this time she is not bringing toy for his son. She is bringing companion for him. She still thinks that Sona is not right companion for Dev. She needs to know that its only Sonakshi who loves Dev more than her, who can keep Dev happy, who can keep their family united.
On other hand Bijoy still thinks that Dev cannot keep her daughter happy. He needs to know hat Dev is the only person who can do anything for Sona.
Though the track is surely going in that direction. Now I feel Monday's sequence it is not to be dream. It has to be real.

saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -allizwell-

Exactly, I felt zoned out as Ishu too suggested a remarraige saying Soha will understand things once she grows up...how come she dint think Soha will definitely not agree to accepting someone else in Dev's life and it could b the end of a bond for her...How come Ishu is diverted more into marraige matters and not enjoying the grace week of Soha's stay with her...how come Dev is calm and considering a remarraige and not even thinking of Soha...this track if started to make Dev and Sona realise their OWN bonding then fine...else its all messed up with total ignorance to Soha.

Exactly! I share the same feelings..It is slightly weird how Sona and Dev are considering how their coming together would impact Soha in a negative way but are not thinking how a new entry in his life will distance him from Soha, maybe forever.
Ishwari's love for Soha is definitely not as powerful as her affection for Dev though she keeps saying Asal se soot pyaara hota hai but if it comes to securing Deb's position, she will choose that over Soha any day!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".