Discuss the downfall of Sonakshi Bose..

Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
😃 Well honestly I know many of us have given up on Sonakshi Bose and her zero attempt to work on her dignity at her in-laws place. When we blame Dev primarily for failing to protect her honour, being today's woman I cannot stop holding Sonakshi responsible for this as well. When I see objectively, Dev becomes blind and numb when things come to Ishwari. He is yet to even THINK of start balancing things between mommy and wife. But Sonakshi is no different. The moment she left Rithwik and her parents in the engagement night, she chose her 'love' for Dev over her 26 yrs of upbringing. When we blame Dev for being obsessed with Ishwari to forget his own existence, we can blame Sonakshi equally to forget everything else in matters concerning Dev. Sona too needs to learn balancing between her parents' honor and dignity and her love for Dev. While Dev's obsession has made Sonakshi a victim, Sonakshi's obsession with Ishwari has made Bijoy-Asha victims of being in the receiving end of unnecessary allegations and taunts. Right after Ishwari had screamed at Bijoy in Bose house, Sonakshi wanted to have an ice-cream in the car 😕. GKB had many times told derogatory things about Bose parents in front of Sona, not ONCE Sona protested strongly not to badmouth her parents EVER. If my parents are today insulted at my in-laws place, I would hold MYSELF responsible for failing to protecting their respect at my new-found home my 'lau' has brought me in. If my family is against me marrying the guy I love and remain in constant fear that I am being harassed at my inlaws place, it's MY responsibility to ensure that I am not, my responsibility to take stand for myself and to make things right, so that my parents at their old age are in peace that I am in safe hands. Me not letting my education (given by them) gone to drain, not letting my dignity gone to drain is a small token of sense of assurance I can give my parents to stop their insecurity. Unfortunately, Sonakshi in her obsessive mission for Ishwari, has forgot all these responsibilities and reduced herself into a creature worth self-pity and empathy. How did she help Baba in assuring that she is fine at Dixits place and that no one can take advantage of her and that he need not worry so much about her ? She didn't. She surrendered herself in the hands of selfish Dixits to make Baba react even more in tracks like this infertility.


Just a thought, while discussing about her extreme low self-esteem, sense of self-respect and allowing her in-laws and husband to treat her like a baby making machine - I began to think when was the first time she created this downfall of hers, her position in her in-laws place that today she has to put the negotiation claws on the table to save her marriage (if I steal Tia's language).

For me, she started allowing the Dixits to walk all over her on the very next day during Tulsi Puja where Dadi Bua shouted at Sonakshi in front of Kichu Bhaiya, ignoring her and then asking Kichu Bhaiya to bring water to wash the mud created by her. An educated nutritionist/doctor is being insulted like that in the 2nd day of her in sasural in front of the maid. I am not demeaning anyone's profession here, but an outsider is an outsider. If I am at Sona's place, I would have definitely been HUGELY upset and made my point clear to my inlaws later that no one can insult me that way. 1 time is understood, but this better not to be repeated.


But Sona didn't. And ever since then the walkover began all over her. She failed to make people aware of her dignity. Now her infertility is being discussed in public, her MIL is accompanying her in the infertility treatment. I have no words to explain how cheap that makes me feel. But she is the creator of her own destiny.


Would like to know your point of view on this. 😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

4.5k

Users

21

Likes

142

Frequent Posters

Tinkerfairy thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Yup frankly she chose "lou" over her self respect and her parent's respect. Agar ab bhi she didn't wake up after her dad getting slapped than she's worse than dev .bose family doesn't deserve daughter like her.😕
...Doctor... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
For me Sonakshi's downfall started the day she accepted Dev's proposal for marriage. Day before that she was on the right track, asking Dev is he and his mom considered her as some kind of toy but something went totally wrong after that. The sudden realization of how much she loved Dev and her instant acceptance made no sense to me. She knew why he broke up with her, she knew about his stalking and spying, she knew how she had disappointed her parents because of the broken engagement, still she decided to trust Dev without asking him to earn her trust back. Bijoy suggested her to wait for some time, give Dixits some time to prove that they are good enough to accept her but she paid no heed.
After this 'did nothing, got it all' achievement, Dev and his family got all the rights in the world to insult/badmouth/taunt Sonakshi and her parents. Did she stand up for herself in the wedding? No.

Did she ever say a word to Mami for all the nonsense that she talked about Bijoy, Asha and Sonakshi? NO!

Did she ever tell Ishwari that she felt bad about the things she said/did to her? Never. Even when Ishwari foiled her plans on Dev's birthday, she behaved as if nothing happened and at the end of the day, Ishwari still taunted Sonakshi for snatching away her son.

Now when she found out about the infertility, the first person she thought about was Ishwari, her dreams of becoming a grandmother, her hopes, her expectations, her pain. Bullshit! And she agreed to go through the treatment for Ishwari. She is ready to do absolutely anything for that woman, who straightforward told her that she dislikes her. If this is not dumbness then what is.
Edited by ...Doctor... - 8 years ago
natasha_n thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
I agree
Sona earned this for herself...
1stly blind in love...when she was forgiving dev after breakup...she dint even ask him if same aituation arrives again what would be his action...

No self respect

I still remember the scene when muh dikhayi was happening
Mami taunts her about jwellery
That time she replies...i never thought that peoplw will come and see me and tell me what burai i have..something on that line

That was the only day after wedding she reacted like sona
After that she only only Mrs Dixit
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Tinkerfairy

Yup frankly she chose "lou" over her self respect and her parent's respect. Agar ab bhi she didn't wake up after her dad getting slapped than she's worse than dev .bose family doesn't deserve daughter like her.😕


True that. 😕 I still have 10% hope from Sona and Asha. If she isn't a good daughter, how would she be a good mother anyways .
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ...Doctor...

For me Sonakshi's downfall started the day she accepted Dev's proposal for marriage. Day before that she was on the right track, asking Dev is he and his mom considered her as some kind of toy but something went totally wrong after that. The sudden realization of how much she loved Dev and her instant acceptance made no sense to me. She knew why he broke up with her, she knew about his stalking and spying, she knew how she had disappointed her parents because of the broken engagement, still she decided to trust Dev without asking him to earn her trust back. Bijoy suggested her to wait for some time, give Dixits some time to prove that they are good enough to accept her but she paid no heed.

After this 'did nothing, got it all' achievement, Dev and his family got all the rights in the world to insult/badmouth/taunt Sonakshi and her parents. Did she stand up for herself in the wedding? No.

Did she ever say a word to Mami for all the nonsense that she talked about Bijoy, Asha and Sonakshi? NO!

Did she ever tell Ishwari that she felt bad about the things she said/did to her? Never. Even when Ishwari foiled her plans on Dev's birthday, she behaved as if nothing happened and at the end of the day, Ishwari still taunted Sonakshi for snatching away her son.

Now when she found out about the infertility, the first person she thought about was Ishwari, her dreams of becoming a grandmother, her hopes, her expectations, her pain. Bullshit! And she agreed to go through the treatment for Ishwari. She is ready to do absolutely anything for that woman, who straightforward told her that she dislikes her. If this is not dumbness then what is.



She wants to be a mother for all wrong reasons. This is what Dixits did to her, and she allowed it. Sonakshi as an educated woman has forgot where to draw boundaries etc. I hope tomorrow some DOCTOR in the show points that out to Ishwari that it never looks good to see an MIL accompanying her DIL on the infertility treatment and following up THIS crazily. 😕


Ishwari didn't even answer her question today, which, if you think, is actually an answer to her question. Wow one has to be really shallow and dumbhead to ignore the hints dropping all over the place 😕🥱
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ..natasha..

I agree

Sona earned this for herself...
1stly blind in love...when she was forgiving dev after breakup...she dint even ask him if same aituation arrives again what would be his action...

No self respect

I still remember the scene when muh dikhayi was happening
Mami taunts her about jwellery
That time she replies...i never thought that peoplw will come and see me and tell me what burai i have..something on that line

That was the only day after wedding she reacted like sona
After that she only only Mrs Dixit



😆 I know right, when I try to look at it, it looks like a distant dream. And it happened after Dev voiced his support for her. That was the last time I saw them working as a team.


Still, with or without Dev's support, it's my moral responsibility not to kill the person my parents have brought me unto. Such cases happen and NGOs are there to help such people out who lose their sense of respect and dignity by such emotional torture from their in-laws. Sonakshi atm needs help to regain herself, not to create another living being in such unhealthy environment.
Kaustuv thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Out of context but seeing Sonakshi I m forever reminded of my friend, who committed suicide. She was the brightest of our batch of doctors apple of her fathers eye .she was proud,confident, pretty sassy and able doctor. Despite reluctance from her educated working professional parents she went ahead and married this trainee surgeon , who was smart, mannered,handsome but brought up with family values in contrast to hers. In 6 months of her married life ,I saw her being reduced to a state just like Sonakshi .

These small issues abt choice of clothes, earning, constant taunts, reluctance from groom family to accept her as hers was love marriage, her husband being deaf and dumb in front of his family ladies all took toll on her.She was too proud to discuss her plight with her parents as they had apposed this match. We tried to intervene ,talking to her, but all in vain. When she asked to quit working and support her husband in his job. Her husband the educated matured surgeon also agreed to her quitting is what broke her.She committed suicide when she just could not take it, a life lost in vain.

I can see Sona in similar path to ruin and is way past her breaking point. Being a serial suicide will not happen ,I sure hope hope Sonakshi takes the path I so wanted my friend to take. Divorse that excuse of a husband and live a life which she deserve and is entitled . For all the ladies still seeing Dev Dixit love and debating whether the slap was accidental ,please realise your worth. No love is worth more than your self respect and use your brain before getting married.
kar08 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Going to read this later as Im rushing out but just wanted to say your post title reminded me of an Exam question :)) So everyone put your brains to work and lets see who comes up with the best answer!
randomramblings thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
To me sona brought about her own downfall even way before her being in love with Dev. I am not sure how many of you would agree with me but i will still continue my rant . lol.
On the day Ishwari threw the samosas and created a scene in front of GKB and Vicky instead of shedding out tears like an Abla naari, "IF " ever Dr.BOSE the so called best nutrition of Delhi could take a stand and tell ishwari on her face that she does not derive any pleasure is being a watch dog over Ishwari's food but just doing her duty as an nutritionist appointed by her son and if she ever has any issues, She is not liable to bend according her whims, i would have appreciated her. I would be the first one to jump on her team instead of vouching for Dev inspite of all his flaws.

As i had already replied to the Query from Tikerfairy, I will repeat again, at the very first instance when GKB ever uttered a negative word about her parents and upbringing "IF" sona would have replied back, there would never be such a day where her father receives a slap from her dear husband.

In this regard, i find Elena to be more vocal, even yesterday when GKB was in full steam and even though Elena is her bahu, she did not deter to remind GKB about the nonsense she is spouting. She might have eloped and married, had played with Asha- Bijoy's feeling and she may be the most selfish girl standing, but she never let anyone walk away by rubbing their choices on her.

Respecting elders can never equate to being mute. Dev too is never mute when someone insults his mom ( even though we dislike his selective hearing , but atleast he hears !!!!) on the other side we have Sona who takes all the shit spewed both against her and her parents with a crying face!!!!





Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".