Why infertility treatment is considered as atyachar

Sargesh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
It's very painful treatment off course but sona was equally wanting her own child then why all the blame game on ishu or dev. Doesn't if ishu wudnt have told her to do so she could not having her treatment. I think everybody wants child in their life so why this treatment thing is considered as atyachaar. Every normal couple wud have gone through it.
But there comes ishwari ki khushi ke liye is having bad message they wud have gone through it for themselves not for anybody. But circumstances made her to do on ishu's instructions whatever either by ishu or herself she had to go through it. So why it is critisised. And sona also put a valid point of putting question of Being accepted. Abd ishu wud also maintain her godly image by accepting her.
That is all the politics ended of ishu but now also not sure abt their future.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

743

Users

11

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

Kaustuv thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
There is a word used in medicine called CONSENT. It means you go for treatment knowing all about it accepting everything positive or negative , you are ready for the treatment by your own free will. I would not have been bothered if the treatment was opted by Sona will. She has the right to decide. Here she dosenot know anything abt the treatment its success rate ,side effects and is wanted to be subjected just to please Ishwari. There r so many couples who stay childless because of their free will , some with infertile conditions opt for surrogacy . Despite all the trouble and pain infertility treatment is a tedious process amalgamation of numerous heartache and dosenot necessarily yield a positive outcome. So before opting for such procedures couple need to be emotionally, mentally ,economically in a stable . Support of the patient is paramount which is faltering even before starting.
Sona at this point of time is an emotional wreck, scared ,depressed and is in no conditions to go for such treatment. First let her comprehend, understand her options feel secured then let her decide. Any women in Sona present state of mind due to any reason excluding infertility would not be able to conceive.
BlueJayFire thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Undergoing trouble willingly is one thing and forcing is another. Here, they have taken having the baby to a different level which majority of us aren't able to accept.
I am not asking Sona to divorce Dev or anything..because separation is not the solution for everything..Having a child is something parents need to discuss first and yes, they are welcome to seek advice from in-laws or moms because they have seen the world farther than us. It should be accepted by everyone happily.

My parents are always open minded, so are my in-laws, when we hear about road accidents or child diagnosed with terminal illness, their recommendation is to adopt a child and provide a future..Everyone is supportive of it.

But here.. Ishu putting a condition on Dev is totally unacceptable.

Dev has hidden many facts from Sona (financial matters most husbands do), intend not being to hide, it just they feel not to disclose it to the wife and spread everywhere and give chance to others to speak about.

sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
undergoing infertility treatment or wanting to have own baby is fine n very much normal but here it is nt abt sona's desires or needs ...its abt ishwari n dere dey went wrong ..ishwari has literally blackmailed dev n sona for sona's treatment
cscs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Unfortunately Cvs didn't focus much on Sona wanting a child for herself. She has mentioned it once or twice but her dialogues somehow indicated that the child is like a way to create bond between her and ishwari. So, its all looking forced.
randommusings thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Yes Sona wud hv gone for the treatment even risky n painful procedure, with or without Ish's condition...coz tht wud be d most normal n rationale thing to do if they want to hav a child. N I hope Sona says d same to Ish n Dev...tht she wud undergo any treatment but its nt bcoz of Ish's tantrums but bcoz Sona wants to do it on her own or bcoz Sona knws hw Dev wants to hv kids.
Sona shud also Dev n Ish abt the timeframe for this condition coz as far as I know...it might takes multiple attempts to get a positive...I knw a couple who have waited for 16yrs to get a child.

Here the atyachar is Ish forcing them to hv a child. N openly axcepting that this is d only condition, otherwise she is nt ready to give due respect to Dev's wife. This is what used to happen in 1950s maybe..


reenarani thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Taking treatment...it is perfectly fine...But taking treatment as condition applied by Mother...That is wrong...
404_NotFound thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
There is nothing wrong in going for a treatment.Infact many bashed Dev for not getting her treated after truth was out .Its simple when you are sick or have some issues you always take medical help .Even pregnancy is painful and delivery is the most painful thing a women goes through yet women go through the pain as they want to have a child of their own when they have option of adopting .

Eventually Dev and Sona would have their kids even if Ishwari was against it or for it as they always wanted to have their own baby .Before marriage both had dreams of having their own kid .So even if Ishwari had not suggested for treatment one of them would have suggested.Nothing wrong in trying for your own kid when there is a chance .Its painful yes but as Asha said in the end it's worth all the pain .It would have been unfair if Sona didn't want a biological kid but here she wants one .

Whether it was formality or whatever people want to call it Sona was given a choice to go ahead with the treatment .If she wanted she could have said no but she agreed because deep down she wants to give birth to Dev's kid .

Since it was suggested by Ishwari it is made to look like some punishment.Usually in such situations elders advise younger ones to take medical help .I don't see anything wrong here .But problem with Ishwari is the way she behaved like a stubborn kid .It was irritating to see her blackmailing her son .She could have been more mature.

Coming Dev , he still supports his wife and even in his dream he won't think of leaving Sona .If he wanted to leave her he would not have married her ,lied to her and would not suffered so much for her .In yesterday's episode his focus was to bring his mom home and he did not find anything wrong with suggestion so he wanted to get Ish home and then think about the success n failure .I would say typical men behavior.They always want to solve problem at hand first but we women are far more sensible in understanding the situation.Thats why Sona asked right questions

Since it's Dev no one wants to understand his situation and they have free pass to bash him .Many are disappointed because they expect him to have a Ak47 and guard Sona all the time from all of taunts she is subjected to .They think Dev supporting her would shut everyone's mouth .How I wish this was true in real life .Let me tell you no one can help Sona but herself .She needs to learn to ignore certain comments and give a damn to people .Ignoring and silent treatment are more powerful than indulging in petty fights with people like RR whose only job is to poke their nose in others business .
Rhy2015 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Coz nobody is takin her concent for the treatment...
It's looks inhuman coz it should b Sona's choice to get the treatment not Ishwari's.
Drcs thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
@sargesh...agree with you completely...now-a-days due to lifestyle, mood swings and eating disorders many are facing infertility...it's not considered as a curse but as a normal situation and people go for treatment..all treatments are painful so too is infertility...the way it was portrayed by Bijoy it looked as if sona is asked to undergo the treatment on a gunpoint...agreed the way Ishwari demanded it looked very pettish and creepy..but you can't expect anything from her...I have failed to understand her and left it longback...no expectations so not heartbreak...unfortunately we do have such MILs all over the world...I hate when people say Indian MILs...MILs are MILs where ever they are...Queen Elizabeth had a tainted strained relation with Diana...same goes now with Camilla and Catherin...kitchen potilics led to the disintegration of many business empires in the world/India..so what we can say about Dixit house hold????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".