All samajhdaar plz peep in - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

1.9k

Users

23

Likes

92

Frequent Posters

_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21
Usually wife sits with husband unless the father in law is also there. In that case men can sit in the front. When son's grow up they start claiming the front seat. This is a sort of unspoken understanding I have observed in almost all families.
Unless there are health, comfort or age issues involved in which case they automatically take precedence

But Ishwari's case is different as she has subconsciously assumed her son as her husband. Not in the physical sense but mentally she considers him her partner in bringing up their daughters. Mentally screwed but that is what Ishwari is.

diyah_us thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
you know what will happen?? I am sure sona would let eshwari sit in front seat
& she will go back. dev would feel very proud of sona & even though she is sitting
behind, dev would keep looking at her in the mirror & they will keep sharing eyelocks
& seeing all this eshwari would still get jealous even though she would be happy initially that
she won back her position in devs life & then she will instruct dev to look ahead
& drive carefully as she will get all irritated😆😆😆
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: randommusings

Who sits in the front car seat is a trivial issue, bigger problem is that Ishwari sees each situation like this as a test for Dev's love and devotion for his mother vs Dev's love for his wife. Ish is in a non-stop competition with Sona and she rakes even such small matters so seriously.


This. 😕 Her insecurity is of an unhealthy level and she should be taken to the doctor.

Ishwari's being concern for Dev-Sona or even Dev alone being thrown out at night 2:00 AM is not wrong, but her sitting up whole night and losing her sleep over it - Psychic problem.

Ishwari's feeling bad for Sona convincing Dev for sitting in the Puja when he never listened to her is not wrong, but overlooking the reason behind Dev's doing so and totally killing the feel-precious factor for jealousy and creating such huge drama for it - Psychic problem.

Ishwari's being worried to lose Dev after Dev's marriage is not wrong, but stopping Dev from even going to Honeymoon - Psychic problem indeed.

Ishwari's going to sit in the front seat with Dev is not wrong, but her hugely upset face and making everyone around her upset for this - Psychic problem.

I hope somebody tells the couple tomorrow that she didn't sleep whole night even after Neha informed her twice about Dev being late. 😕 Will Sona take Ishwari to psychiatrist or not is to see 😕
LiveLife321 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24
Thank you for this interesting topic. After a long time, i am thinking about ishwari's character since from long time i am completely ignoring her & her actions in the show for my own sanity. I respect her for the struggles she went through to bring up her kids in her difficult times but even after being a mother, i can never understand or connect or sympathize with her or her actions towards her kids. For me, she failed utterly as a parent and as a mother & a perfect guide book to know how a mother should not be.

Honestly speaking, if you consider a healthy family in terms of emotional relations for ex. like bose then sitting in the front seat next to dev or in the back seat doesn't matter at all. These are very petty and silly issues which we would have never considered in case of a normal family. I am sure for Sona also it doesn't matter whether she sits in the front seat or back seat because that's not going to change her place in Dev's life or Dev's love for her BUT here we are talking about ISHWARI whose insecurities are as big as a mountain & as deep as an ocean.

For Ishwari when it comes to Dev, everything is a competition and a test to Dev to prove his Love and devotion towards her. She never allowed his sisters also to reach him beyond a defined point by her. Esp when it comes to Sona, She is afraid of her impact on Dev which threatens her control on Dev directly.

Here the main issue is, Even though we all can see it as a clear obsession(for makers its just her insecurity) towards Dev and as a bigger problem where she clearly needs some help. What i understood is, Makers are not ready to address this PROBLEM as a PROBLEM and the most annoying thing is the way these people are justifying her abnormal behavior with some stupid explanations or never ending flash backs.

If we consider her pills drama, Its such an emotional blackmailing from a mother to a son which will leave permanent scars in his subconscious mind. They justified this case by making her say "I am a bad mother since i am not able to be happy with my son's happiness" and by pushing dev in to guilt mode.

If we consider Ritwik case, it clearly shows her manipulations to remove Sona completely from Dev's life. Its a wonderful chance to show Dev her human side, The way she sent that proposal, paying that agent secretly and hiding everything from Dev. The day he confronted his mother, We clearly saw from his expressions how hurt he was with her actions but in the next episode there is no affect of this scene and no thought process or realization, everything is back to square one.

Till the pills drama i was eagerly waiting to see how they are going to show her flawed human side to Dev. But after seeing the way they handled Ishwari-Dev confrontation scene in Ritwik case, I understood that these people dont have any plan to shed her holy mask. To resolve any problem first we need to address that as a problem which is clearly missing in Ishwari's case.
Edited by LiveLife321 - 8 years ago
siddhi.d123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: LiveLife321

Thank you for this interesting topic. After a long time, i am thinking about ishwari's character since from long time i am completely ignoring her & her actions in the show for my own sanity. I respect her for the struggles she went through to bring up her kids in her difficult times but even after being a mother, i can never understand or connect or sympathize with her or her actions towards her kids. For me, she failed utterly as a parent and as a mother & a perfect guide book to know how a mother should not be.


Honestly speaking, if you consider a healthy family in terms of emotional relations for ex. like bose then sitting in the front seat next to dev or in the back seat doesn't matter at all. These are very petty and silly issues which we would have never considered in case of a normal family. I am sure for Sona also it doesn't matter whether she sits in the front seat or back seat because that's not going to change her place in Dev's life or Dev's love for her BUT here we are talking about ISHWARI whose insecurities are as big as a mountain & as deep as an ocean.

For Ishwari when it comes to Dev, everything is a competition and a test to Dev to prove his Love and devotion towards her. She never allowed his sisters also to reach him beyond a defined point by her. Esp when it comes to Sona, She is afraid of her impact on Dev which threatens her control on Dev directly.

Here the main issue is, Even though we all can see it as a clear obsession(for makers its just her insecurity) towards Dev and as a bigger problem where she clearly needs some help. What i understood is, Makers are not ready to address this PROBLEM as a PROBLEM and the most annoying thing is the way these people are justifying her abnormal behavior with some stupid explanations or never ending flash backs.

If we consider her pills drama, Its such an emotional blackmailing from a mother to a son which will leave permanent scars in his subconscious mind. They justified this case by making her say "I am a bad mother since i am not able to be happy with my son's happiness" and by pushing dev in to guilt mode.

If we consider Ritwik case, it clearly shows her manipulations to remove Sona completely from Dev's life. Its a wonderful chance to show Dev her human side, The way she sent that proposal, paying that agent secretly and hiding everything from Dev. The day he confronted his mother, We clearly saw from his expressions how hurt he was with her actions but in the next episode there is no affect of this scene and no thought process or realization, everything is back to square one.

Till the pills drama i was eagerly waiting to see how they are going to show her flawed human side to Dev. But after seeing the way they handled Ishwari-Dev confrontation scene in Ritwik case, I understood that these people dont have any plan to shed her holy mask. To resolve any problem first we need to address that as a problem which is clearly missing in Ishwari's case.


I too feel they have messed up Ishwari's character to a large extent I am confused as to what the Cv's are trying to potray here because it's clearly not insecurity it's obsession and she needs help.Ishwari always gets her way by emotional torture on her son which is horrible and seriously the flashbacks are not working anymore.The makers have constantly told that Ishu is not a negative character but they are very well aware of the audiences reaction towards her and she seems to be hitting new low in every episode.I am yet to see any hope in Ishwari.
LiveLife321 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: siddhi.d123

I too feel they have messed up Ishwari's character to a large extent I am confused as to what the Cv's are trying to potray here because it's clearly not insecurity it's obsession and she needs help.Ishwari always gets her way by emotional torture on her son which is horrible and seriously the flashbacks are not working anymore.The makers have constantly told that Ishu is not a negative character but they are very well aware of the audiences reaction towards her and she seems to be hitting new low in every episode.I am yet to see any hope in Ishwari.


If a maker or writer is justifying by saying that viewers are misunderstanding their character then that itself is a big failure for them wrt to story execution and presentation. Writer should never justify this infact viewer should feel this.😊
srilotus thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
no idea
never come across such a situation
main hamesha front seat pe hi baithti hun if my hubby is driving...tab bhi agar koi humare saath ho...meri mil ko knees mein pain rehta hai toh woh hamesha back seat hi prefer karti hain.
ki fark painda hai...jaana hai aana hai...is mein respect kaha beech mein aya...bada confusing post hai😕
siddhi.d123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: LiveLife321



If a maker or writer is justifying by saying that viewers are misunderstanding their character then that itself is a big failure for them wrt to story execution and presentation. Writer should never justify this infact viewer should feel this.😊

Yes if the audience can't connect then the deal is lost.The show has brought many beautiful characters and moments but have messed up big time with Ishwari 🥱
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#29
It doesn't matter to me where i sit but i have been part of some ladies discussion forum where this was the hot topic .For many women( read wife as majority is DILs there) it mattered .
I remember just after my marriage i was going out with my MIL and husband for shopping .I went to sit in the backseat but my MIL insisted that i sit next to my husband as now i was will be the one who will be beside him for life .From then on till today they say the same .

But i usually leave the front seat for my FIL if more than 4 people are travelling because its uncomfortable for everyone in the backseat .There are some male relatives who prefer front seat and think they have more rights than a women to sit in the front seat ...i dont bother much and i amtotally ok to give up front seat cos it doesn't matter to me .I know my position in my husband's life and no one replace that .
saurdeep thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Rhy2015

So as the precap was over at the ?????
I would like to ask u all if this kind of situation was given to u all in ur life what would u do??

I know wife's right place is next to her husband...
But when it comes to giving front seat to someone why is it always considered as a question of respect?



I mean if a son is traveling with his parents n I think all u would agree with me that son n father will sit on front seats n Mother n wife at back.but when it comes it son,mom n wife,what should b done as shown in precap...
If wife sits at back,does that mean wife's place is always after parents..If yes,then same should be done with husbands too.I mean for a daughter too,her parents should come first then husband n then anyone else..then a damaad should always sit at back when a daughter is traveling with her parents..m I right?
Coz if u question this to someone..m sure they'll say it's just a way of giving respect..
My question is if damaad is at his sauraal n he should b given the least priority as well.
Bijoy n Asha gave their daamad their room but when Nikki slept in Dev's room.sonakshi was made to sleep in study not in Ishwari or anyone else's room.y???????!!
I Dnt understand this discrimination at all..
Respect has to b same for all..
It's a contradictory post ..I know but I personally had been through this..that's y asking u all..






To be honest,I don't understand the funda of sitting on front or back seat is so related to giving respect! I believe respect should be in the hearts for our In laws/Parents and it should not be judged with who is sitting at front or back seat.When I got married ,I used to sit on the front seat and whenever my in laws used to come home, I used to say my FIL that "Papa, please you sit on the front seat but he used to tell me to sit with hubby and they will sit on the back seat but after my son's birth,whenever they are home,I say him Papa please you sit on the front seat with my LO as he loves sitting on same with his Dadu. Sometimes I sit on the front seat with my son, sometimes my FIL but it was never made a issue of respect like why they are sitting on the back seat and all.
Ishwari is a highly insecure mother who doesn't want to loose her position any where be it her home or the front seat of his son's car so I think Sona is mature enough and she will offer her same as she noticed that Ishwari was also about to enter to sit on the front seat.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".