Why do you think Ishwari is unable to accept any girl in Dev's life? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.5k

Users

15

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

Aazeen02 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: sjain

I personally cannot think of any other reason other then .."change" ..she is not able to accept change in her life ..and since her world revolves around her son ..so any change in his life will lead to disturbance so may be this could be the reason ..but I would really like to know the real reason :)

Change.. Yes, may be she's resistant to change to some extent.
But not fully...
She accepted some changes eventually... She accepted a change of someone ruling her eating habits, she accepted the change of her diet, she even accepted someone correcting her children's diets, until she suspected of Sona's relationship with her son... She accepted the change in her house after her brother and his family came, she accepted changes in Neha's life... She was accepting almost a lot of things...
Until it came to Dev... Though again, she accepted her son's busyness if it was work... She never minded if he ate outside if he had a meeting, she never minded if her son was giving more and more time to his work.. Until it came down to love...
This is what is gnawing inside me... Why is this change being so hard on her... And that Is what I want to learn about...
Edited by Aazeen02 - 8 years ago
Ammuty thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Aazeen02

Hahaha... Funny... Waise, I was thinking, how come Ishwari has no relatives from her Sasural? I mean even at her husband's death, it was Maamaji who did the rites of the body...
Can it really be that Ishwari snatched her hubby away from his family?

Koi toh logic hoga... I trust the writers to not close Ishwari's behavior on any stupid note... She's one lead of the show...


Oh yes that is also true.. we haven't find any relatives from her husband's side. The only thing viewers know is that there was a mother in law which also shown in promo only... lets wait n watch what the cv's have in store for us..
OmNaMaSteOm thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Aazeen02

This partner thing toh I too have analyzed multiple times, and feel it to be 100% true... No doubt...

But how do you think she will realize this? Introspection or Confrontation with Dev? What's your say?


I am good at analyzing the problem, not solving it. 😃

I am not married yet or seen such cases but I asked my mother and she said its normal to an extent, the show went over board.
Ishwari will NEVER confront Dev regarding this since she herself does not know, may be does not want to accept. Ishwari's introspections are the convenient kind if you notice so I doubt that would help either.

my guesses are :
b) Dev needs a huge mental shake that he has to choose between Sonakshi and Ishwari - that will result it the understanding that Sonakshi is fine with Ishwari but not the other way around. Through Dev's actions not communication he shows Ishwari that her insecurities are pointless. I dont think Dev and Ishwari will ever talk about this even upon realization!

This Ritwick track is one of the way to provide mental shake. This shake is also for Ishwari that her son is not fine.

a) Ishwari and Dev need a third person interference because both are too involved in themselves. Neha, Mamaji etc will show both the light.

Apart from this no clue how to deal since I have not been in this situation. Any thing drastic one does it might lead to serious mental problems, physical body is different from mental. No clue how emotions will react.
spacenoxx thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: OmNaMaSteOm

She subconsciously thinks Dev is her husband and she Dev's wife. She is stuck in the illusion that Dev is young and she is running in the home in poverty. Ishwari has not come out of it. On the outer side she knows Dev is her Son, but she has somehow replaced the son as husband that is where the problem arises. Ishwari herself does not know she thinks like that.


Additionally Dev has nurtured this mis - understanding unintentionally, he does not even know he is doing what he did. He has no idea that his mother thinks like that.

Her actions clearly indicate what I said above. Its not from Dev's side, he thinks normal.


That's an interesting contradiction you have there. Either she considers him her husband or he us a child.

Let me try to put your point in a different way.

She was probably used to being the most important in her husbands life and after his death, she found that in Dev. Having depended on that bond for so long she now is scared of not being the most important person in Devs life anymore.
OmNaMaSteOm thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: spacenoxx


That's an interesting contradiction you have there. Either she considers him her husband or he us a child.

Let me try to put your point in a different way.

She was probably used to being the most important in her husbands life and after his death, she found that in Dev. Having depended on that bond for so long she now is scared of not being the most important person in Devs life anymore.


Mentally she thinks Dev is young, age wise, her subconscious is still in the past like that. Ishwari considers Dev as her husband from the time Dev was young since then. Dev is 27 and Ishwari feels he is still not ready for marriage that indicates that Ishwari feels that Dev is still 8 years old. Her subconscious has never passed Dev's childhood. The young Dev's promises of being with all her life are stuck with her.

It sounds like contradiction but that is how Ishwari's subconscious is. Her conscious and subconscious are not on the same track. I hope I am not sounding confusing. I dont know how else to explain my point. I would say child husband - Ishwari is stuck there.
pams309 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Aazeen02

I do feel your point to be highly valid... But the thing is, what's the solution? A smart son if in case, how does he solve this? To seek treatment, the basic rule is the willingness to get treated...
In the case of hiring a nutritionist, it was for the sake of her son and the hefty amount he had paid, Ishwari finally gave in... it was not for herself but for the love of her son...
But to seek a psychiatric treatment, when you realize that your son is doing this to live a peaceful life, would Ishwari be willing to be treated?


Solution for this problem is so tricky and is difficult too.

prob 1. first of all neither son nor the mother will be in a position to accept the fact.
prob 2. nobody dares to explain the problem to the mother n son duo, because they can get offended.
prob3: Denial, they outrightly deny any such thing. Son sometimes might realize the problem, but its highly unlikely the mother to do the same. She will go into defensive mode.

Solution is someone should be smart enough and bold enough to understand the problem and tell the mother , son duo frankly.
A daughter can do this job well, if she is willing to.

Son should be strong and practical enough to accept the situation, and send the mother for counselling or therapy.
Or simply get her married again.. lol

reachanupama thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17
Well I can only say Ishwari needs some kind of counselling. She needs to be told that a mother has a unique place in her child's life and vice-versa. She needs to come out of her insecurity and accept that she is important and needed by Dev and he will always be there with her.
piyu008 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
I agree with all above responses.
Only thing i am worry about they both are never going to talk about anything in near future.

Ishwari apart from all those things you mentioned - she think whatever she is doing is all right, she always have made right decisions for Dev. N yes she herself even considers GOD to Dev.(Sub consciously)

N Dev would never question her or even accept that his GOD needs physiological treatment .The possibilities are negligible - Its like going in to lion den and coming out with lion as best buddies.

I really don't know what will shake these two out of their imaginary world. But i think its something to do with current track.





adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#19
there is nothing to reveal about ishwari's characters...such mothers exist in real life who want that they will be the only women in their son's lives...
they cant tolerate if they sons gv importance to any other woman...
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#20
All she wants is to cook for dev, wash his clothes, after washing press it etc. Dont want another woman to do that. If that's the cse, they can fire kichu kaka and ishu mama can happily take his place.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".