Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2k

Users

14

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: --Ruchi--

There comes a point when a son takes charge of all the decisions for the family and does not shares the problems,anxieties,fear of his own for the sake of their happiness.

This is same as parent not sharing problem with children when they are not grown up.
This is the fact.The person who holds the responsibilities tend to hold problems in his own. Ishwari should accept that she does not know Dev's problems and also that she should give him some space to live his own life.

She is hurt because Dev has not told her about his feelings for Sona which is understandable.As a mother she deserves to know but instead of sulking she should trust her son and wait for him to tell her about his decision.


Of course she deserves to know.. But remember Neha told the family when she was ready. Dev will when he ready.. The problem is not Dev not telling her ... The problem is Dev not telling her first ( I don't know how to interpret the first... does she expect he will tell before he confessed to the girl) Because anytime he would tell her after that... the reaction would have been the same.

Also it is not like he has eloped with her.. and Ishwari didn't know... He just hasn't told her as yet. But the environment was never conducive for Dev to share... If Ishwari had once mentioned to Dev... tu bahut khush lag raha hai... koi hai kya.. tu mujhse baat kar sakta hai...

Dev would definitely have shared.
_RS_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: fanktlk


So the theory that Dev is not sharing is hurting Ishwari doesn't actually hold water.

Perhaps yes. I mean it has become one of the reasons why Ishwari is hurt but it isn't sole reason why she is sulking.

Dev not telling about his love life, him hiding it from her is troubling her but more than that it is that Sona has made such a important part in Dev's life is threatening her more.

So basically, she herself doesn't know this thing.

She is saying that shez hurt bcoz Dev hid his relationship from her. But actually there is something else that is turning her like this, which is insecurity ofcourse. And that she'll understand later on.
Edited by _RS_ - 9 years ago
Suvika. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: fanktlk


Of course she deserves to know.. But remember Neha told the family when she was ready. Dev will when he ready.. The problem is not Dev not telling her ... The problem is Dev not telling her first ( I don't know how to interpret the first... does she expect he will tell before he confessed to the girl) Because anytime he would tell her after that... the reaction would have been the same.

Also it is not like he has eloped with her.. and Ishwari didn't know... He just hasn't told her as yet. But the environment was never conducive for Dev to share... If Ishwari had once mentioned to Dev... tu bahut khush lag raha hai... koi hai kya.. tu mujhse baat kar sakta hai...

Dev would definitely have shared.


@blue - I think yes. Her level of possessiveness is such that she wants his thoughts to practically go through her. If he has feelings for the girl, he should her tell first and then to the girl.

Even if we do assume that Ishwari wants to be the first to know AFTER he confesses his feelings to the girl, the delay is what would hurt her. Any time after confession doesn't work for most mothers. The more he delays, the more worked up she would get, especially if she already has an inkling. Why is he not saying anything? Why is he hesitating with me? Does he think I would object? Does he think I will stand in the way of his happiness? Logical aspects like - environment not conducive to share etc won't wash at that point.
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: JyotiBThakur

Exactly my point... It is not tat Dev tell everything to Ishwari... And whatever it is, he is not going to hide the relationship forever. He's just waiting for the right time. And if he wants to spend sometime with Sona before telling the family about them, i don't feel there's anything wrong in it.



Lovely post... Thank you so much for sharing.🤗👏


In that sense Mamaji had a better reaction.. He saw them together and yet he didn't create a ruckus. I believe he will give them time...
surbharati thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Kudos to the post...

Very true...once he took responsibilities...he just kept everything to himself and just gave happiness to his mother & sister
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Suvika.

You are right in one of your earlier posts. Ishwari is Dev's responsibility. The more I think about it, the more I realise how true that statement is. He has seen his mom struggle to take care of them / him when he'd been a child. He did whatever he could but the majority of the responsibility had rested on her shoulders.


Now he has grown up and taken over that from his mother. He wants her to relax. Not think or worry about anything. She's done that all these years and he doesn't want her to do it anymore. Maa tu chinta na kar. Mein sab sambhal loonga. Maa tu tension kyu leti hain. These are the most frequently used words to her.

So, he won't share his thoughts. Whatever they are. He will handle them as he sees it fit - be it Nikki's issues or Neha's or his own engagement with Natasha. Not sharing is a norm rather than an exception for Dev. And the exception is Sona. He sees her as his equal. His partner. He is learning to share his thoughts with her. He's still not completely used to it. Like he didn't tell her what's going on with the Gujral business deal due to the broken engagement etc. She came to know and asked. She is teaching him. Showing him that life can be easy / lighter that way. And he is learning. And relishing that feeling of unburdening himself in front of her - be it about his meeting or missing Neha or his mom's health.



Mein sab sambhal loonga . This tough exterior that he has projected.. that is getting difficult for him... causing him sleeplessness, causing him to take sleeping pills...

He doesn't sleep enough... We have heard this a number of times.. he has justified it saying mein dair se sota hoon... but the truth is he hardly gets sleep. With so much to worry about, no wonder he fell sick.. Because this matter of his mom thinking of Sona as a baharwali, pinched him... he tried to tell that to Sona.. but it would hurt her so he bottled it up and it has been eating him up.

No wonder he was edgy, reactive continuously trying to gauge Ishwari's reaction the last couple of episodes.

I wish when ever they decide to have the "parivartan" of Ishwari , she realizes that he is the son she the mother, he the provider, she a responsibility, he the parent, she the child.

But they were never friends !!
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: _RS_

Perhaps yes. I mean it has become one of the reasons why Ishwari is hurt but it isn't sole reason why she is sulking.

Dev not telling about his love life, him hiding it from her is troubling her but more than that it is that Sona has made such a important part in Dev's life is threatening her more.

So basically, she herself doesn't know this thing.

She is saying that shez hurt bcoz Dev hid his relationship from her. But actually there is something else that is turning her like this, which is insecurity ofcourse. And that she'll understand later on.


Even after her approval the constant comparison will start. Dev will share something with Sona and Ishwari won't have a clue.. That will fan her insecurities further.

Of course the insecurity is the reason.. but for her to get out that frenzy, she also needs to realize he doesn't owe it to her to tell her everything. He never did and he probably never will.

The day she realizes that is when the root problem will be addressed.
jimhawkins thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Agree with you, never thought of it though... But the difference is, if those things were hidden from Ishwari, they were hidden in the complete sense... It wasnt like they kept dropping hints of something being hidden from her... She came to know of it only after the issue was finished - for instance the neha ranveer thing... In this case, they are being caught time n again and it is more like they are pretending to hide their relation more than actually hiding it... They are egging her that look, we are upto something but wont share with you...
Edited by smallwonder - 9 years ago
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Suvika.


@blue - I think yes. Her level of possessiveness is such that she wants his thoughts to practically go through her. If he has feelings for the girl, he should her tell first and then to the girl.

Even if we do assume that Ishwari wants to be the first to know AFTER he confesses his feelings to the girl, the delay is what would hurt her. Any time after confession doesn't work for most mothers. The more he delays, the more worked up she would get, especially if she already has an inkling. Why is he not saying anything? Why is he hesitating with me? Does he think I would object? Does he think I will stand in the way of his happiness? Logical aspects like - environment not conducive to share etc won't wash at that point.


True... The questions you raised are valid. The reactions we get from Ishwari seem more from the realization that she doesn't know her son. He didn't have the confidence to share with her, not now not ever and yet she was blissfully unaware.

Any normal mother would dismiss it and give her son the benefit of doubt. But again... the insecurity is an issue.. That is the fundamental problem.

But for those who complained that Dev didn't share with Ishwari is the problem that is not true.
It is Ishwari's realization that she thought she knew him and in reality she realized only now that he doesn't share , he never did... What probably worries her is that he never will.


fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Agree with you, never thought of it though... But the difference is, if those things were hidden from Ishwari, they were hidden in the complete sense... It wasnt like they kept dropping hints of something being hidden from her... She came to know of it only after the issue was finished - for instance the neha ranveer thing... In this case, they are being caught time n again and it is more like they are pretending to hide their relation more than actually hiding it... They are egging her that look, we are upto something but wont share with you...


It seemed like that didn't it... that they were taunting her.. 😆 . But I guess they are in love.. A little crazines is expected.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".