Arjun Singhania X factor(changed title)

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Over weekend i got to watch a few episodes of KMH1 -some of the best episodes (thanks to my Purani jeans topic)
One thing i observed is Arjun Punj has a X factor that i feel is somehow not there or not being felt in Arjun Singhania. I know majority of the KMHians may not agree but to put across my point let me give few examples
1) Arjun Punj-DK Punj relationship
I have not watched many scenes but just three between them but i really felt a real father-son scene is going on.
The first one was when Arjun angry at his dad giving job to Arohi refuses to have food and sleep and his dad explains him his reasons for his action. Reminded me of my childhood days when my dad would come and explain to me when i was angry on any of his decisions
Second scene i am not sure when i took place but Arjun Punj and his dad DK sitting on a bench outside and DK gives him bag of clothes, shaving set, car keys and Arjun refuses to take. But finally takes shaving set and his dad upset at him not coming back home cannot control his emotions. Arjun first holds DK hand to try and console his dad but when his dad is not able to control his emotions neither can he and hugs him and says i love you dad and i will always love you. That was superb i mean usually they never show father son showing so openly about their emotions in indian soaps its a rarity
This scene is also good because Arjun knows because of his father he lost Arohi's trust but Arjun Punj love for his father or his relationship never changes. Secondly, his father stopped his bank account- some money he earned working in DK office for 6 years. In real life you may have had a son listing out all his fathers faulty action because of which he had to leave him but Arjun knows his father will get hurt or he is a good human at heart and has forgiven his father. Thats surely an X factor in todays times
Last scene again DK teaching Arjun salsa. Such a cute scene. I really liked that father son bond.
I mean in front of the world you may be a business tycoon but Arjun Punj was always a child in front of his dad- usually sons have this kind of relationship with their mother but here you felt that when DK-Arjun Punj interacted it was more a mother cum father-son talking. Liked it that they showed such a relationship on KMH1
This type of real bonding is missing between RPS and Arjun. I mean they rarely look like father son and more like some business associates in many scenes. The only scene where there was real father son bonding was after Rashi fall. For TRPs to improve i feel more bonding between father and son is a must
2) Suspense and sacrifice
I think biggest factor of KMH1 is suspense and sacrifice
Arjun is in jail . But there is a certain mystery why he went to jail etc, why he does not want to be freed? When Arohi will come to know how much he sacrificed for her etc
The sacrifice part is from Arjun who leaves a luxurious life and a father he loves very much without whom he has not known any life- mind you like in RPS case DK is not that bad a father he is just over possessive and that type of possesiveness is there from parents when you are an only child. In this case his father does not have his wife also so he is more possessive about his son. I do not think he is pure evil evil like Rudra. And him making all those sacrifices without Arohi knowing it its somewhat surreal........in todays commercial world you never find a person like Arjun punj. So aautomatically audience get attracted to this larger than life character because somewhere everyone wishes they had a Arjun Punj to protect them, take care of them etc gaurdian angel types.
3) Character Graph of Arjun Punj
Arjun initially goes from women hater, to a lover and then a person willing to sacrifice everything for one person whom he knows for only 6-8 months. There is so many shades in Arjun Punj that is not there is Arjun Singhania. You know for sure how Arjun Singhania may behave in a certain scene but Arjun Punj was a bit of mystery with ever changing character. He is also scared of cockroach so human- usually boys do not admit it openly but every man is scared of something which only his close family will know.
4) Villans
There must be pre determined villans for any hero to become a great hero.
Arjun Punj had karan, arohi's father etc and mind you these people are not his family members
Arjun Singhania main villans are his family RPS, Micahel, Kumud but honestly whether you are own child, adopted child whatever a family can never be main villans in shows especially when Arjun loves them so much. You know at end of show they will accept arjun as their family. You require real strong villans to keep focus on the hero not family or dhondu,chikus etc
And they could have given some clue of Arjun's real family like RPS or dadi or orphanage personnel knowing something but not revealed till almost end. That would be a real mystery
5) Superb scene visualization
KMH1 had great scene visualization by creatives. Not a minute do you feel why is this scene there.
6) Great friends
He has good friend scenes with his extended family like salil(not sure his name) and his faily friends children- more like Arjun Singhanai with Romit, Billu and Makrand has tit but they are half baked scenes
Lastly great emotional acting by Karan Kundra. In starting scenes i must admit Karan was akward while expressing emotions but in last few scenes he is just superb. You feel like he is really crying or feeling that emotion.
Ex when Arohi calls him after realizing how good he is and says she wants to meet him right now the expressions he gives while brushing her off saying he is in club with girls etc while in reality he is at sea shore. Great emotional acting by both but your full attention is on Karan rather than kritika for this scene to know how he will really react to her call
But one thing after watching a few episodes of KMH1 i would admit is Karan Kundra's acting is excellent in KMH2 from word go. In KMH1 he took a few months to get into groove and show those emotions. KMH2 does not require dialogues to know Arjun Singhania's thoughts its there on his face, eyes. Arjun Punj started showing those brillaint expressions only after a few months i think in june-july.
And Kritika is good in KMH1 and KMH2 but here her role is more childish.
Lastly eveybody is grey no one is pure white or black except Arjun Punj(who i think was always white character although he was just showing off to outside wold that he was black to supress his emotional turmoil of his mom leaving him as a kid) in this story.
Karan is also grey so you can never hate him.
I think i only disliked Arohi father's character----too typical hindi movie role villan to the hero without any valid reasons.
And last not sure but out of 10-15 episodes i viewed why is everyone slapping Arjun Punj- right from Arohi, Arohi's dad etc? I did not like those scenes without major reason you misbehave with a person
Edited by myviewprem - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2k

Users

11

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

--priyal-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
i agreed wid ur all points thts d main difference
or can say d story has changed so this is important we can't set tht 2 new season but yaah tht scenes create magic after watching it for d 1000 times
-Olly- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
well ppl have diff views! but both the characters of arjun are diff..!

in kmh 1 arjun was brought up as a child with much care by his dad..but here arjun was orphan from the begining he hardly had seen love and his dad hardly showed affection so how can u expect simialr scenes as kmh 1?

secondly the sacrifice ya it was the higgh point of kmh 1 but here the scenario is diff..still arjun did give up his dad's business but the result was nil!...

bonding with friends!..he hardly has friends here ..there is no one like salil in kmh 2..so u cant get it!..

in short arjun singhania is a mixture of gray shades and goodness!..he is a hero and a human!
and arjun punj was diff he was a child who everyone wanted to protect!..

as for aroi 's character yes its diff but very good and we like this one rather than stubbborn arohi sharma!..this arohi fights for her rites!..and i love it!
-Olly- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
i am loving arjun singhania!!😉
priyanka94 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
u noe guys .. i think ... we should not compare .. as both the characters are different and they have different traits ...i mean when we compare we should have a common criteria which we ca base our comparison on ... but here ....there is nothing common apart from the name .. i dunno ... this is my opinion ... im not bashing .. or trying to impose my view upon any of you .. just my POV😛.>>> and yeah .. im LOVING ARJUN SINGHANIA AS WELL !!!!😳
-Olly- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
@priyanka94 exactly ..both are diff and both are brilliant and strong characters!
roshaniD thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
hey nice post... but i agree with Olly n priyanka94... comparisons shouldn't be made as the dramas are worlds apart.... and so are the characters....

i loved Arjun Punjj and am loving Arjun Singhania more..😉 either way Karan Kundra rocks my world on a daily basis.....🤣

peace out...😉

rosh
shibz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
X-factor is in Karan Kundra!!!! wherever he goes it follows!!! ha ha..

alright!!! loved your right up about KMH1...glad to know that u understand KMH1 soo well despite not catchin the show on the whole but just the "best" epis..absolutely agree with whatever u said about KMH1 from the angel Arjun Punj to DK Punj to Mr.Hariprasad(Arohi's Dad) to the suspense & sacrifice in the story, to scene visualization..

BUT!!! Dont u think u are mixing the two seasons?!!😕 That was Arjun Punj & his emotions... This is Arjun Singhania & the path that he traces from a criminal to whatever may be the result of this..we need to look forward to!!

Is it intelligent to compare the two seasons & the characters?!! Arjun Singhania's character is no comparison to Arjun Punj's or are u expecting season 2 to have Arjun Punj? That would be same & boring isnt it? Besides KMH2 as a story on the whole is not unfolded yet where as wen u saw KMH1 it was a completed book...we dont know what is in the coming pages of KMH2...how the characters will grow, what they will do & how the story will go ahead...in KMH1 there was suspense cause the whole story was happening in the flashback... & how can u expect AP-DK relationship between AS-RPS here?!😕 also DK is not equivalent to RPS...u also agree on that then how could such scenes be possible?!! salil in KMH1 gave Arjun a warmth of Friendship...agreed but in the end he also betrayed Arjun dint he? where as here i'm not sure about Makrand but Billu would never leave Arjun.. so which friendship do u value the most? the one dat is with u during happy times or the one during your bad times? Salil could never see love in Arjun's eyes for Arohi but here Billu & Makrand see it even before Arjun accepted it...

AP-DK scenes in KMH1 were one of the many reasons that made KMH unique, beautiful & special...the warmth that comes along that way was pleasing... BUT, DK was the main villian in their life whether u agree or not... DK is personally my favorite character after AP in KMH1 & all of us know that he did it as a possessive father ...so who is more evil? DK who loved his Son more than anythin & coz of the same love he loses him too Or RPS & his family that does not love Arjun at all? isnt that justified? Or is it Mr.Hariprasad(cant stand him😡 😆) that bashed AP openly?

So yeah! i disagree with your analysis not because i am one of the majority of KMHians but because i see the two shows from different perspectives & they look beautiful to me in their respective angles..
Lastly!! Comparison of Two shows is not allowed!! KMH1 & KMH2 are totally different shows..cant be compared on the basis of the title... its like comparing a movie & a TV show having the same title...
desigrl05 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
you detailed these points really well and I agree with you
Arjun Punj's arrogant character and his self evovlement was somethign watch worthy although i must say karan's acting was not the best back then only got a litlle better towards the end but I loved the freshness that brought him and kritika to those scenes..now wheni watch arjun/arohi i feel like im watching an already comfortable kritika/karan playing out a role but back then it was really'arjun' and 'arohi'...im not sure i guess its b/c of their offscreen relationship.. but whatever the case i feel the comfort leve is much greater here than season one...
arohi's character i won't say is 'childish' but yes she acts unreasonably sometimes as to season 1... arohi from season 1 was much to idealistic to relate to hence i feel season2 arohi although a bit crazy is a little more relateable...
karan's acting mashallah has done leaps and bounds over the past year..he's become really good at giving off a vibe w/o saying a word... season1 i literally had to hear their dialouges to know what they were feeling but this one can go w/o words and we can feel the storyline
the character of arjun itself i like in season2 (as far as the crude/badass man goes...) but i dont like it how arjun all of a sudden changed around.. i wish they would have taken more steps to show how a singhania bad boy falls for a girl and then reinvents himself to win over her love... i dont know..i feel certain things in season 2 are very mcuh rushed...
yes and the mystery element is soo badd this season loll!! i wish they would've kept a secret going like they did w/ season1 and the jail and all... even right now they could tell why the dushmani between rps and ahluwalias but they never dive into that... and they never get into any other secrets of arjun's or arohis'...its very much taking on what the present is giving to us... i wish ekta woudl refer back to older episodes of something mentioned that plays significance to an episode right now so it would jsut tie things together
and anotehr thing:
i miss kmh1 songs!! i loved their bg tunes.. even just the sad humming or whatever..it was lovely! and they dont' have alot of 'thought thinking scenes' in this season where we see arjun somewhere sorting out hsi thoughts /or arohi.. they did that for a bit but now its gone away wiht..its just random thoughts rolled into one ...
and the relationship between rps and arjun is very conflicting b/c arjun loves hsi family deeplyl but is unwilling to leave them... this is a gangster for petes sake i feel they could've changed thsi track up a bit and really have a pure black villian besides a grey one.. but i gues they're tyring things differently??
oh and i want more emotional scenes rather than just getting close..you'd realize how much a beautiful woven dialouge could enhance a scene and make it look more passionate...
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

I have not seen entire KMH1 and hence not aware DK is the main villan or Salil betrayed Arjun. That's really bad if that happened in KMH1

Yeah but i really like Arjun Singhania as a character and want it to be potrayed more better by the CVs- i mean there are so many mysteries behind that character on why he behaves in certain manner like when rashi fell although he knows arohi is a good person he put blame on her not on gauri who was standing there along with arohi
Secondly after arohi did so much for rashi why he still wants to hurt her by saying he is marrying some london girl. Its just some actions are unexplained. But all of you are right i should not compare AP with AS because its a different story. I never wanted to compare just was analyzing the way story moved in kmh1 and kmh2.
Arjun Punj is an aspirational/inspirational character but Arjun Singhania is more real
And that story was very emotional and this story is very contemporary and modern.
All i can say i like Arjun character irrespective of whether its Punj or Singhania.
Edited by myviewprem - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".