Whose 1 min speech was better? Prem or SRK

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Soaps1

@Soaps1

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: isranawaz
hey it was a ditto copy yaar.. so i dint njoy HC much SRK is all da way brilliant ... he made us cry.. but harshad's dialouges was justa copy so it wasnt a heart touching scene man..

Exactly the fact that it was a copy killed the impact so its really unfair to compare the two ... but yea i am glad HC did it in a totally different way and didn't try and make it look like he was copying SRK ... i wish dialogue writers had come up with different dialogues for Prem

Quote

snowwhite30

@snowwhite30

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#22

undoubtebly its my sweetheart HARSHAD...........

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ayushi

@Ayushi_78

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

#23

both were fantastic in their own way.

Quote

Aasma rai

@-raiAasma-

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#24

As many comments above I too think it's really unfair to compare harshad and srk. I always felt that harshad as srk of small screen . Both were fantastic I this scene but as srk's topic itself was touching 'maa'. Mothers are always more touching n lil close to our heart. But one thing is for sure if anybody can carry this scene on television than no doubt it will be only harshad nd harshad! Btw srk is ma fav actor!

Quote

Zahra

@Pyari_Zahra

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#25

For me SRK will always win, afterall he is such an amazing actor, that scene of his was tearjerking, so heartfelt and emotional. Since it's the original, nothing hardly beats the original. But I've got to say that HC's performance also bought tears to my eyes, and was great! Yet, overall, SRK will always get my vote first, mainly because I saw his scene first, and the only thing that overpowered HC's performance was that I kept on picking out similarities between his delivery to SRK's delivery. It is a hard choice since SRK is my favourite Bollywood actor and HC is my favourite Tellywood actor, but I will choose Shahrukh. Great post by the way! xx

Edited by Pyari_Zahra - 16 years ago

Quote

Zahra

@Pyari_Zahra

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: -Rajveer-
I agree u cannot compare an actor with a novice who's still learning basic of acting and emoting!

I find it insulting that you could call Harshad Chopra a novice!! 😲 He has been in the field of acting for years!! And it is apparant that he has come a long way- if you watch some of his older videos to what he is now you will see how much of a talented and wonderful actor he is. Have you seen 18th June 2008 episode- have you seen episodes in which HC manages to convey emotions just through his eyes??!! Then how is he just learning the basic of acting and emoting!! I find this comment of yours incredibly confusing!! 😕 xx

Quote

Suhana Ahmed

@Suhana Ahmed

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#27

SHAH RUKH KHAN was amazing... i was crying when i saw KKHH for the first time...

though Harshad was briallant... but it wasnt that impressive coz it was copied... the only difference was that it was about PAPA...

creatives shud have tried something orignal...

regards,

Suhana.

Quote

arshiya

@cute_san17

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#28

srk's speech made every one cry

and hc speech made everyone sad and unhappy

i think this is the diferrence what i found in both of them speech

Quote

Simran

@meiskan

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

#29

I dont think its fair to compare. The lines were pretty much a copy. I would say Shah Rukh because that was original and really touched my heart, but if HC's lines were different and all, I bet he could be able to pull of the same. He is an amazing actor after all 😊