Epi Discussions #2: 4th - 8th May

First Previous

Page

116

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Aanandaa

@Aanandaa

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#91

Sids...that's exactly what I said na....🤔

Lemme repeat in English...meri kharab hindi pe mat jana....lol

He said at last the insan goes to whom he was married to, in the first place....

But my point is....Prem NEVER really cared for any worldy relations with Heer...His love was always beyond all this.....So what did he mean by he wont be able to love Ash even after marriage???See my point?

My whole point is that that the dialog itself is absurd and contradicts with his earlier stand when he was getting married to Ash......

Edited by -athena- - 16 years ago

Quote

OGX2010

@OGX2010

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#92

With Ash, he did promise to fulfill his responsibilities and thats what he must have done...like they say, when you marry, your spouse is your first responsibility...He could never stop loving Heer even then...haila GOD FORBID..aisa kabhi nahi hona chahiye tha..why r we even going there...

I thought, here he was giving hope to Heer indirectly, that irrespective of everything, he WILL always belong to her, that all this is temporary...coz notice the brief pause in the convo tht follows immediately after it and Heer reading into what he meant....

Agreed about everything else though...He is running away from Heer's tears instead of wiping them away..I dont like it .

Edited by -sidrah- - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Aanandaa

@Aanandaa

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#93

I did notice all the nuances...but it sounds really hollow to me even if I go by your POV....So to him the relation with Heer ultimately boils down to something of a mere responsibility or something which HAS to be because they were bound by a worldly relation?😔

EDIT1: I don't doubt the emotion he carries for Heer...I am merely pointing at the dialog and what a misfit it was...

EDIT2😆: What do you mean by 'aisa kabhi nahi hona chahiye'???Him NOT loving her???😲...bhala who is he to decide that....Its too late now....hahaha

Edited by -athena- - 16 years ago

Quote

OGX2010

@OGX2010

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#94

Aree...why?...would he mean that ONLY..we know better than that..he knows better than that...it wouldnt make sense, no if he would do all that he did for Heer or would out of sheer respo, ??..Heer was his responsibility always..even when they were in the chawl, remember he told Nihaal...meri kuch zimmedariyan hain but that shouldnt outlaw his love for her...i thought they both go hand in hand.

Quote

Aanandaa

@Aanandaa

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#95

I edited my post...check it again....

Quote

Aanandaa

@Aanandaa

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#96

Originally posted by: -athena-
I did notice all the nuances...but it sounds really hollow to me even if I go by your POV....So to him the relation with Heer ultimately boils down to something of a mere responsibility or something which HAS to be because they were bound by a worldly relation?😔

EDIT1: I don't doubt the emotion he carries for Heer...I am merely pointing at the dialog and what a misfit it was...

EDIT2😆: What do you mean by 'aisa kabhi nahi hona chahiye'???Him NOT loving her???😲...bhala who is he to decide that....Its too late now....hahaha

Quote

OGX2010

@OGX2010

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#97

hahahaha u r crazy 🤣..maybe its wid the way u interpreted the dialogue...i never thot abt it tht way...😳😆

Btw does Heer know about Prem being asked to choose..I am still confoosed

Quote

OGX2010

@OGX2010

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#98

No No..I meant Prem marrying that Ash only in the first plx..🤢

Quote

Aanandaa

@Aanandaa

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#99

Originally posted by: -sidrah-
hahahaha u r crazy 🤣..maybe its wid the way u interpreted the dialogue...i never thot abt it tht way...😳😆

Btw does Heer know about Prem being asked to choose..I am still confoosed

I thought She was clearly aware of it...going by her 'kisi ek ko chunna...' dialog...

Yaar our Heeriye is antaryami...and Prem is another arrived soul....and we are the mere mortals who keep pulling our hair out trying to fathom the cryptic stuff they throw at eachother....😆

Quote

OGX2010

@OGX2010

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#100

hahahah

I could decrypt Prem today but couldnt quiet get Heer...If she knew about Prem being left with an ultimatum by G mom, she should have understood his predicament no?...and be with him in that decision of his...i still think, she doesnt have a complete picture of the whole situation.

Quote

1 ... 8 9 10 11 12 ... 116

Epi Discussions #2: 4th - 8th May - Page 10

Related Topics

Explore Topics