Who is the 3rd person? Discussion HERE! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.3k

Users

40

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

Riya.pk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#11
Lol they brought in another mystery on top of the, is Gaurav Prem mystery. But by now we're already convinced that he is Prem because if he wasn't then no one would bother to watch the show.

I think the third person is Heer because lately we've been noticing a change in her behavior, all of sudden she's all chirpy and talkative which is really unlike her. The way she jumped onto the plane today and began questioning Prem, it seemed like she knew that she was foiling Gaurav's attempt to leave Ludhiana.

Another big thing, Prem and Heer have a mutual bond where they know eachother and udnerstand one another very well. So by now Heer would have seen through Gaurav and realized that he isn't behaving like Prem. If Heer hasn't realized that Prem is not himself then that would go against everything we have learned about Prem and Heer until now, so by now Heer DEFINITLEY knows that Prem isn't Prem (at the moment). So that third person can't be anyone else but Heer.

I really hope that it is her and that the creatives arn't going to introduce some new character because that would be stupid.

And along with Heer I think Preet is in on the secret too because he was at the airport that night that Gaurav was supposed to leave for Mumbai, so he must have seen something. And in yesterday's episode I think it was probably Preet who told Gaytri mom that Heer and Prem arn't living as husband wife. By telling her this, they would be able to get Heer and Prem to live in one room and that way Heer would be able to keep a better eye on Gaurav. I don't know I just hope the creatives actually have a creative enough mind to produce a track where there isn't unrealistic things happening like a new third person being introduced into the show.

In conclusion if Heer is the third person it would explain her change in behavior (her chirpyness), it would also explain how she found Prem sitting in the plane and how she found the tickets. It would also explain how she has already realized that Gaurav is pretending to be Prem.

Let's just keep our fingers crossed that this track doesn't get anymore ridiculous as it already is

-Riya
luckyluv thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#12
I think it is Prem
He is playing double game wid RR
He is showing as if RR is annoying him by doing this
But its actually he himself
eternal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Riya.pk

Lol they brought in another mystery on top of the, is Gaurav Prem mystery. But by now we're already convinced that he is Prem because if he wasn't then no one would bother to watch the show.

I think the third person is Heer because lately we've been noticing a change in her behavior, all of sudden she's all chirpy and talkative which is really unlike her. The way she jumped onto the plane today and began questioning Prem, it seemed like she knew that she was foiling Gaurav's attempt to leave Ludhiana.

Another big thing, Prem and Heer have a mutual bond where they know eachother and udnerstand one another very well. So by now Heer would have seen through Gaurav and realized that he isn't behaving like Prem. If Heer hasn't realized that Prem is not himself then that would go against everything we have learned about Prem and Heer until now, so by now Heer DEFINITLEY knows that Prem isn't Prem (at the moment). So that third person can't be anyone else but Heer.

I really hope that it is her and that the creatives arn't going to introduce some new character because that would be stupid.

And along with Heer I think Preet is in on the secret too because he was at the airport that night that Gaurav was supposed to leave for Mumbai, so he must have seen something. And in yesterday's episode I think it was probably Preet who told Gaytri mom that Heer and Prem arn't living as husband wife. By telling her this, they would be able to get Heer and Prem to live in one room and that way Heer would be able to keep a better eye on Gaurav. I don't know I just hope the creatives actually have a creative enough mind to produce a track where there isn't unrealistic things happening like a new third person being introduced into the show.

In conclusion if Heer is the third person it would explain her change in behavior (her chirpyness), it would also explain how she found Prem sitting in the plane and how she found the tickets. It would also explain how she has already realized that Gaurav is pretending to be Prem.

Let's just keep our fingers crossed that this track doesn't get anymore ridiculous as it already is

-Riya

I couldnt agree more, it definitely has to be Heer. or why else would someone shy like her, start being so talkative and randomly pop up where Gaurav is? Preet and Heer have both noticed changes and are tryin to fully understand Gaurav/Prem's motive behind doing all this. and lets hope the creatives get a bit unpredictable....and realistic too.
sonam_s thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#14

It's definitely Heer. Her angry reaction when she said "Tum Mere Prem Ho Hi Nahi Sakte" and then suddenly changing it proves that she has found out about his identity. Plus, the parantha incident added to her realisation.

She wants him in the house mainly because of Gayatri. She has been improving and if she leaves, her condition will become worse.
sonu0511 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#15
i have a list of people here.......
1)its prem/gaurav himself-the way he speaks to rr shows how much he hates him
2)heer-her character has changed completely
3)gayatri:in these bt shows people shown not doin anythin are actually doing a lot........
4)veera-she was the 1st one who was suspicious thinkin how come her bro din support her
5)harman-bharat gettin ram back
n the list continues..........................
May1902 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#16
Its pretty confusing to figure it out, cos they might not be a third person at all, the creatives want to create suspense. Though the first thing that came to my mind that its Preet and heer together on this. I think he realised that this isn't his PB, from Gaurav's weird behaviour.

Though another very unlikely possibility that it could be Sanjana, sound crazy but in ekta serials for some weird reason sometimes the characters who are sick or bedridden are the ones end up being the saviours then seem to turn negative.

May
fantastic21 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#17
I think it gaurav best friend...i forgot what her name was. But there was interview where she said she had to take time off because she was hurt...so now I think they are bringing her back.
-svetalana- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#18
I Think that its
Prem: How the person is sooo same like prem remembering everything about himself and all of sudden when he meets RR his attitude is changed.I mean he was paid to become prem not to reveal himself as Gaurav.From past two days he was trying to tell everyone that he is not Prem.IF he is gaurav he had got training of each and every aspects of prem so he cannot show off himself that he is not prem.I am sure he is doing it purposely making all sorts of mistakes so that he is recognised as Gaurav first in the eyes of Heer then infront of family during breakfast.
something is fishy with his character.He was frustrated with heer's behaviour when she said you are my prem.He wanted her to say that you are not my prem.
2.Heer may be the 3rd person.She is also behaving bit weird specially with Prem.she is normal with everyone in the house except prem.How can this be possible.
3.Simran: may be the the third person as she tried to stop gaurav from going to mumbai when first time he was leaving.
4.Can be DJ,veera,nihal , preet, gy3 mom , Ash or lallu.
5.Creatives themselves.Biggest Suspect IPSHITA DEB as she is brainless so she may have introduced 3rd person angle only to confuse more to confused people like us.She had shown up so many things till now but hardly any thing is revealed.
Ayesha24 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Innocent02

well...I think it's Heer


Ya even i think its heer she is not telling anu1 bcoz she want gaya3 to be fine
samanmirza thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#20
nice guesses, as long as it is not a third person altogether, some new character...
it cud b sanjana if she has risen from her sleep,
that girl sam,
heer,
the real prem (how many luk alikes can u have?)
or it cud b a bluff on rr's part.
god yeh love story hai ya detective story!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".