Does Heer loves Prem? - Page 2

Originally posted by: anushka10

no in my scene i remember when heer was crying in ambala by catching their wedding card, prem automatically got tears in his eyes as he is in canada. i agree there are lot of times prem did nt feel heer's pain, but there are also so many times that prem felt heer's pain

i am not doubting heer's love on prem. i am just remembering that creatives forget these points to include . creatives should show some heer feeling scenes that something bad is going to happen to prem, but all are happy in juneja's house. dis confused me a lot

i am just talking abt the future di. creatives forget to show that heer also feels prem's pain. i think after 1 or 2 yrs they can get heer marry easily with anyone as she is not feeling prem's pain. i thought that creatives are trying to show heer can't feel prem's pain

i don't think that i remember as prem with tears in his eyes during that wedding card scene. if i remember correctly (and i probably don't! 😆) prem had just been told about the heer angle then? while heer - who knew about prem all her life - had just been told that she was going to have to forget him and get married to someone else. i seem to remember prem as smiling here?

but as to the confusion, i agree with you about what exactly to read into the difference that the creatives maybe showing as the difference between prem's reaction and heer's reaction. maybe there is something. but maybe not?

i just have never made a difference between prem and heer when it comes to asking how much they love each other. in my mind, both of them love the other perfectly. how much ever heer loves prem, it is perfect. same for prem. just my understanding. my pov, i guess.

u're absolutely rite my frend!! the creatives shud see this...poor prem the way he was sitiing n crying was so touchy dat most of us started crying!!

Prem can easily feel heer's pain and tears even wen she is ambala and he is in canada. but why can;t heer feel a single percent of prem's pain and tears when he is in fire. wat the creatives want to show at this point that only prem loves heer a lot not heer?

I completely agree with you in this yar, even they are not showing heer is sensing something wrong is happening

--- When prem is sitting around fire and crying like a baby even i got tears and shouted at him to get out from that fire madly while watching the scene on my computer. even heer did not feel a single percent that prem is crying like a baby for help. why can't heer?
creatives forgot i think, there are showing love story, and both feels pain for each other if any one hurts. senseless track n thot.

--- where is gay3 mom ? i did not see her even in the 1st oct episode also? gay3 loves prem more than anything in the world she too even doesn't feel the pain of prem? i agree that she did not give birth to prem but she can feel his pain and console him everytime? but why not this time?
yes where is she now a days, somedays kulraj not shown and now gaya3. now she needed in this time. but she not there. atleast they have to show, gaya3 had a bad dream abt prem

--- wat are the creatives trying to show us? that heer can easily forget prem after one or two yrs and can marry anybody and start loving him. that would make any sense
then whats abt the dlgs they shown from first episode, prem for heer & heer for prem. and i will not accept if preet n heer track comes. how come lakshman marries sita, is gr88 ekta know abt ramayan or not. what abt ashlesha, are they planning to change her as villain...arey yaar..there are many villains now without a hero...
--- they completely ruined prem's image in the episode. my prem is not that type of person who can give up easily, but wen he sat around the fire and crying like a baby even i shouted at him to get up and manage to escape somehow, i also thought one thing that kul di said that prem garme bardaasht nahin kar saktha . i feel that he felt afraid of fire so he sat crying like ababy
yes they made that dlg especially for this scene. but really i dint get what's there in creatives mind.
--

HATS OFFFFFFFF TO CREATIVES THEY RUINED PREM'S IMAGE AS WELL AS HEER"S IMAGE IN YESTERDAY"S EPISODE.

I think these creatives are planning to bring heer character like parvathi agarwal character in KGGK. there parvathi married & they have children. so it luks ok. But what abt heer here, in this small age they want to show us her like a business woman or responsible widow(sorry to say this...) daughter in law. even the same happening with meher. total junejas playing with both sister life...I feel like break those creatives head.

sorry friends i am becoming much emotional, as i am not able to forget thursday episode, even i sleep its infront of me...prem crying face...makes me mad...tears are rolling...

Originally posted by: anushka10

sorry guys to post this type of question and questioning on heer's love. But belive me guys this is only question i got in my mind while watching the yesterday's episode. Due to some work i did not watch the episode yesterday , i saw it in the morning and confused with this question. I do have points to support my useless question, just check it guys

-- Prem can easily feel heer's pain and tears even wen she is ambala and he is in canada. but why can;t heer feel a single percent of prem's pain and tears when he is in fire. wat the creatives want to show at this point that only prem loves heer a lot not heer?

--- When prem is sitting around fire and crying like a baby even i got tears and shouted at him to get out from that fire madly while watching the scene on my computer. even heer did not feel a single percent that prem is crying like a baby for help. why can't heer?

--- where is gay3 mom ? i did not see her even in the 1st oct episode also? gay3 loves prem more than anything in the world she too even doesn't feel the pain of prem? i agree that she did not give birth to prem but she can feel his pain and console him everytime? but why not this time?

--- wat are the creatives trying to show us? that heer can easily forget prem after one or two yrs and can marry anybody and start loving him. that would make any sense

--- they completely ruined prem's image in the episode. my prem is not that type of person who can give up easily, but wen he sat around the fire and crying like a baby even i shouted at him to get up and manage to escape somehow, i also thought one thing that kul di said that prem garme bardaasht nahin kar saktha . i feel that he felt afraid of fire so he sat crying like ababy

-- HATS OFFFFFFFF TO CREATIVES THEY RUINED PREM'S IMAGE AS WELL AS HEER"S IMAGE IN YESTERDAY"S EPISODE.

its really disgusting on the part of creatives they are not creatives they are the destroyers
🤬
sorry guys i can't control myself

yaa i agree with u

I think that Prem and Heer's 'test of love' is 'work in progress' - does that even make sense. 😆😆😆.

Originally posted by: raksha.l

Estee...I guess I got what Anushka is trying to say here...

It is not her who thinks that Heer's love is any lesser than Prem's...She feels the creatives are trying to show Heer's love in a lesser light than Prem's and I agree with that to an extent...

And yes, Prem does have tears when Heer cries staring at that palm leaf/wedding card...

Prem literally brought back Heer from death when she flew off, remember??

And just the other day, he had premonitions about how Heer was going to get into some danger...

Creatives failed to show the same thing from Heer's side....When Prem was dying there, here Heer had little or no clue about it...absolutely no vibes whatsoever....

Me thinks the creatives are being very unfair to Heer...they always show the story from Prem's POV...hmph

hmmm... from my point of view, the creatives have a story. and that's what we see.

i didn't remember prem's tears when heer's crying at the wedding patra that her father tells her to shut off. what happens when prem gets tears in his eyes? how does he explain it/understand it?

and yes, prem never gave up on heer -- chased after her to the depths of the waters and got her back. that beautiful line of his when he's looking at her safe and sleeping afterwards: "at first, when they said you were gone, i was numb. but then, i felt my heart beating. and i knew that somewhere out there, your heart had to be beating too. else i would be dead."

i guess -- searching through my memory -- the only time that i can remember heer thinking about similar things was when she had run away from prem, and was sitting in the train station waiting for the train to take her out of prem's life. what was it that she said then? didn't she say something about living a life separate but hearts beating together? 'cause i remember it ended with "this land where my heart beats".

*sigh, sigh, sigh* all this soul-searching. on a night before a week of the show with little or no hc-as-prem. *deep sigh*

and from all the posts here, people see "heer's love" as different from prem's.

Originally posted by: maya123

I think that Prem and Heer's 'test of love' is 'work in progress' - does that even make sense.

😊 ya, it does. but this ... sensing misery thing sound like it could be fundamental. (i can't believe i'm stressing 'bout this! 😆)

i liked what you wrote that heer has always been brainwashed 'bout prem. i always thought that prem must've been brainwashed as a kid too. maybe not with all the details of who with. but for a guy to have this "i believe that each of us are made in pairs" idea, it must've come from somewhere in his past. so i always thought that he'd heard his mom talking 'bout it with heer's mom and that must've sunk in.

but it is true that heer always had the advantage of knowing that prem is .. well her prem. but prem - even before he knew that she was "his heer", was doing all kinds of things to get her/keep her/make her happy. so prem has always had the advantage of being a loftier lover from our (the audience's) pov.

so i'm with you when you say:

Originally posted by: maya123

Before she could have the chance to 'test' her feeling Prem's pain; he is 'supposedly' (fingers crossed) taken away from her.

NOW, it will be Heer's turn to feel him, sense him and seek him out; (assuming that he is alive); just like Prem did without knowing who she was.

Hopefully this is what the creatives have thought as well.

Else this is just me trying to find logic in a show which has lost everything - prem, charm and logic.

well, because - just because! - they've been so consistent in being good so far, i don't believe they've lost their sense completely!

*of course, i've never been right 'bout these shows before. the probability is that i'm wrong and this show going forward is going to be poop. it's just .... it would be such a pity to throw the magic of hc-as-prem-ag-as-heer-are-one-forever just like that. *