!Discuss Gurdeep Kholi as new Bani here! - Page 3

I'm glad that out of the three actresses mentioned (Pallavi, Nausheen and Gurdeep), they chose Gurdeep. I like her and from what little I saw of Sindoor and Bhabi, she's a good actress. Plus, she has a certain dignified look and so hope that things work out. Of course, Ekta could have brought in Pallavi Subhash as Bani if she hadn't created the character Meera. Pallavi Subhash would have been an ideal Bani!

As for bringing Prachi back, I wish that it is not compared to Smriti's comeback. Smriti has for 7 years, essayed the role of Tulsi. Prachi's Bani cannot be compared to this iconic character. Prachi as Bani did bring life to this character, but of late, with her shooting alone, her acting is suffering. Plus, 6 months down the road, if Gurdeep does a good job, is it fair to her to be replaced? And what will Prachi's commitment to KS be 6 months down the road. Plus, Kyunki is a long running show and will probably continue for years, whereas KS, being a Zee show, may run till next year only. Zee shows never run for years like Star Plus shows.

I hope that at least here at IF, everyone gives the new Bani a chance. As for acting, Gurdeep had a difficult character to enact in Sindoor. She is in no way inferior to Prachi and deserves a chance. Here's hoping for better days for KS, esp hoping that the creatives do good work!!

Gurdeep...Well good luck to her then...😊
But going to miss Prachi like hell... 😭

Originally posted by: suganthirani

I'm glad that out of the three actresses mentioned (Pallavi, Nausheen and Gurdeep), they chose Gurdeep. I like her and from what little I saw of Sindoor and Bhabi, she's a good actress. Plus, she has a certain dignified look and so hope that things work out. Of course, Ekta could have brought in Pallavi Subhash as Bani if she hadn't created the character Meera. Pallavi Subhash would have been an ideal Bani!

As for bringing Prachi back, I wish that it is not compared to Smriti's comeback. Smriti has for 7 years, essayed the role of Tulsi. Prachi's Bani cannot be compared to this iconic character. Prachi as Bani did bring life to this character, but of late, with her shooting alone, her acting is suffering. Plus, 6 months down the road, if Gurdeep does a good job, is it fair to her to be replaced? And what will Prachi's commitment to KS be 6 months down the road. Plus, Kyunki is a long running show and will probably continue for years, whereas KS, being a Zee show, may run till next year only. Zee shows never run for years like Star Plus shows.

I hope that at least here at IF, everyone gives the new Bani a chance. As for acting, Gurdeep had a difficult character to enact in Sindoor. She is in no way inferior to Prachi and deserves a chance. Here's hoping for better days for KS, esp hoping that the creatives do good work!!

😊 i totally agree with you Suganthi .

Gurdeep is not new to soaps ,she's done 2 popular soaps WELCOME Aboard Gurdeep !🤗

actually i like gurdeep but if kajol come and act as bani also i can't accept 😭 .. the one and only bani is prachi.....

Sorry well i can't give a chance to her because for me another permanent Bani or Jai replacement other than the original people is like picking a 2nd hand choice and personally i don't like it.

It is like missing Daniel Radcilff playing as Harry, meaning that i don't think Harry Potter will come out in theaters if the Daniel decided to leave the character of Harry and someone else steps in to his place (in almost all of the American movies i have watched, if the original actor is replaced for a character that he portrayed first, all those movies come out on VHS and DVDs)

anyways for me i can't accept her or any other in PD's place for permanent replacement so good luck to KS and you all! enjoy your life!

my opinion entirely

I will wait and watch but for me PD is always Bani and iconic or not, she is no less than Smriti, the non watchers of Kiyuki, I agree of late PD's acting has suffered but I can't imagine another face in PD's place..

kyunki is been still runing reason epeople knew smiriti will return mroe than it there many elad pairs are there and ahve thier own fans soo all watch soo no problem for them..... example karan nadhini laksh kt..etc...

the shwos whihs had replaced the lead character either showed to doors soon or forced to bring back the old ones exampls suhana of bhabhi... the replaced one also was verynice but the viewers wanted thier old suhana back soo after doign ehr film she came back as bhabhi when they called her back...

other shows like kksuum althoguh the replaced oen did a goood job still peoeple lvoed nausheen and was difficult to accept the enw one whcih lead to wrap the show after tryign soo hard also..

other great example is ghar ek mandir where ram went away the shwo was soon forced to wrap up... as peopele loved their chemistry .. and i know hwo much ram gauthami fans demanded ram 's return and in dhadkan due to thier demand gauthami was brought in.....

soo many other examples are there.. i cna give more....

i dont say gurdeep is bad one as i loved her character as vedika in sindoor and she was rockign and when she wa s replaced the shwo was forced to wrap up.. soo here itself a great example....

gurdeep does a good acting ... but bani... it is sooo difficult... none is stoppign her from giving her a chance but accepting and digesting the fact is toughfer one... that is my pov.
even in in kzk hiten did a good acting as anurag but people cdnt take it much althoguh hiten fans saw it and ronits fans too and prerna p2 and etc fans lvoed it... but ... still it was alsoo soon forced to wrap in a hurry manner....

soo examples are more....

soo this is what i am trying to tell it is not that i say gurdeep si abd but i saw it is difficult to accept..
if the enw bani is gauthami.. it wd have been little tough to accept it.. as we cd have atleast digest the fact that she is abni as they have thier chemistry onscreen... which is because they alrready worked together on show...

this is my pov...my intention is nto to hurt any one's feelign bus too say the dfact which happened...

davia

Moderator's Note: No Negative comments on an Actor, against IF COC