For Story I hope they Don't Butcher BW - Page 4

Originally posted by: kubare

I know dear, thats what we all want. The creatives to stop their non-stop thoughtless deatruction. As without a good storyline, how much can the actors do nad fro how long can they sustain viewership.

Have to give actors credit for keeping the show in top 10 and even top 5 before the advent of KBC despite the crap storyline. It slipped out of top 10 less than half a dozen times and i remeber cursing that and wanting it to tank so that creatives would take it as a sign and get Pia off our screen. Never happened. I guess too many JB depos stuck with it despite crap because of the brilliant actors and the amazing chemistry

Originally posted by: nsminerva

I totally agree with u Pri their. I Know that Jai will and I just don't want Bani to go so far in her revenge process as to be unable to forgive her self. For me here, I just want JB back together without inflicting too much pain on each other and ASAP.

But, u do have to agree that from Bani's POV he has been unbeleivably cruel and let her down when she needed him the most. The children snatching with such cruelty was so unnecessary. He could have done something being the great JW. ( And please don't get me started on lettting PIa and Co continu to stay on in the home after killing Bani)

Pri, why do u think she has not forgiven JW for his role in his mom's death. The moment she heard the truth she wanted to run back and tell him and to not to carry that weight anymore and he was innocent. She stayed back only to save his property and when she knew it was not needed, the first thing she did was to go to Dubai and assured him of his innocence and she actually said that from her mom's suicide was wrong from which she has learnt not to give up on her loved ones.

As her parents Kartoot, I don't think her father knew it was suicide. So, how can he be blamed? The mother was depressed and she jumpred before the first car she sw on road. How can we blame her?

I am not sure what u r refering to when u meant she left him to fend for him self after the ONS. Can u please clarify? From what I remember she went into shock, then had JW coming and burning up their memories, saying he slept with Bani out of pity, pia for whatever, hugging pia ( which she had witnessed several times before and she never suspected, even had JW leave in the middle of the night after getting a call from pia and also that he was in a hotel room with her; I know JW had the same faith in her but so did she)

And for the rape part, once the trust is lost and after witnessing so much, I think it sometimes takes time to build back the trust. After seeing and hearing so much, not from others but by and from JW before her own eyes, it took her time to trust him again. Especially since the betrayal is by people so close to u. U

Bani has always been portrayed as a person who lives for others. Her identity to herself has been two parts, to be a mother to her sisters and to be a wife to JW. Her fault has always been of loving too much. When she thought her sister was in pain, she could not step back. And also mainly because she had complete faith and confidence in the bond betwen JW and herself. I don't think anyone can envisage the levels pia has fallen to. I don't think she told JW bluntly, she just told him what she felt. In this case, I am not saying what she did was right. I think she was blind to her sis's character, but that is a fault of loving too much. ( I for one would have never got pia home)

Hopefully she has learnt better by now, and teaches pia a lesson she never forgets.

regards,

Raji

Well said dear👏…Have been saying this for months…but always it's Bani fault for everything…What to do…too much for being wife of JW and too much for being loving…

😉

Originally posted by: Je_aime

Well said dear👏…Have been saying this for months…but always it's Bani fault for everything…What to do…too much for being wife of JW and too much for being loving…

Meena,

Let a little bani bashing pass for old times sake. You have a munna camper writing a whole post in support of our munna's munni and don't want her to suffer 😉

Originally posted by: Je_aime

Well said dear👏…Have been saying this for months…but always it's Bani fault for everything…What to do…too much for being wife of JW and too much for being loving…

Thanks so much Je-Aime, I really appreciate the support. Feels good to know u feel the same.

Minerva,

( do have to agree that from Bani's POV he has been unbeleivably cruel and let her down when she needed him the most. )

Yes, 200%.

(why do u think she has not forgiven JW for his role in his mom's death.)

I dont get this. If JW hasn't killed her Mom, why should he require to be forgiven in the first place?

(The moment she heard the truth she wanted to run back and tell him)

Should she not also have expressed a regret for what her parents did to him?

(As her parents Kartoot, I don't think her father knew it was suicide.)

He did. he must have got the tapes at some point of time and knew that it was a suicide. And yet he failed to inform JW that he was innocent.

(The mother was depressed and she jumpred before the first car she sw on road. How can we blame her?)

Don't you think that it is a very silly and inefficient way of commiting suicide? Mt. Abu has Guru Shikhar the highest peak in the Aravallis and Nakki Tal, the second largest lake in Rajasthan. Dont you think jumping there would have been a better option. Did she ever think of the trauma that the driver would be put to?

(I am not sure what u r refering to when u meant she left him to fend for him self after the ONS. )

It is funny isn't it. Bani can remember the fact that JW used all those hateful words for her but forgets conveniently that he got shraddhed for his pains, pulled her out of the fire and the riots at Ghatkopar, that he made over all his wealth to her and accepted exile gracefully for his kartoot. And yet Bani continued calling his act a dhoka (of course it reqd another Dixit Rano to remind her of reality) and kept throwing trantrums from time to time even after knowing that he was raped.

Rgds,

Pri

Megs,

If it for old time sakes, then it's okay but still, see no Bani brigadier is bashing Munna…Btw, I don't think anyone has any problem with Munni na…I mean it's amma that you guys don't like na…😉😆😆

Raji,

Don't worry…you always have my support…I have been supporting Bani and protecting her from Munna campers for quite some time…Join the club dear…

Cheers,
Meena

Originally posted by: Je_aime

Megs,

If it for old time sakes, then it's okay but still, see no Bani brigadier is bashing Munna…Btw, I don't think anyone has any problem with Munni na…I mean it's amma that you guys don't like na…😉😆😆

Raji,

Don't worry…you always have my support…I have been supporting Bani and protecting her from Munna campers for quite some time…Join the club dear…

Cheers,
Meena

Yaar love munni. She blushes and blushes and blushes. She makes my munna so happy and happy. What's not to like? Yaar if only amma would quit her jassosi and give up on her kasam's to her mother and father. I hope now finally the two ghosts will stop haunting her 😆

(I think it would be good if he can pass the tests that Bani puts him through and is able to prove his love for her and redeem himself.)

Had no intention of getting into Bani bashing again but this was just too good a remark to allow to pass uncontested. In any case, Munna would pass each and very test that Bani would put him thru. Much as Bani has failed quite a few of the tests of her love.

Meena,

(but always it's Bani fault for everything…)

No, my dear it's all JW's fault. After all he should have never allowed Pia to blackmail him etc. Never mind that he had kicked her out of WM on two occaassions but it was St. Bani's love for a rapist which allowed Pia to get into WM, find out about the DVD and blackmail JW in the the first place.

(too much for being wife of JW and too much for being loving…)

Exactly. Only a very loving wife would inflict her hubby's rapist on him.

(Btw, I don't think anyone has any problem with Munni na…I mean it's amma that you guys don't like na…)

200%. We have never bashed Munni, only Amma. But then it was Amma who brought back rapist repto into WM, not Munni.

Rgds,

Pri

Minerva,

( do have to agree that from Bani's POV he has been unbeleivably cruel and let her down when she needed him the most. )

Yes, 200%.

(why do u think she has not forgiven JW for his role in his mom's death.)

I dont get this. If JW hasn't killed her Mom, why should he require to be forgiven in the first place?

Pri, When Bani came to know the truth, it is an accident caused by JW. At that time, Bani did forgive him but was not able to forget and for that you cant blame her…She wanted to go away from him because she cant forget that he caused her mom's death. Yes, she herself told that she cant forgive but deep down she did forgive or else, she would not have bothered to save his property, though in a absurd way. It shows that she forgave even if she was not willing to accept that fact.

(The moment she heard the truth she wanted to run back and tell him)

Should she not also have expressed a regret for what her parents did to him?

If I am not wrong, before Bani could explain a lot and when Bani wanted to talk to him, it was dear Munna who shut her up.

(As her parents Kartoot, I don't think her father knew it was suicide.)

He did. he must have got the tapes at some point of time and knew that it was a suicide. And yet he failed to inform JW that he was innocent.

It was not shown that he knew it was a suicide dear, so we can't assume…Bani got the tape from the house but if you remember Mr. Dixit was busy drinking away, so I don't think he knew it…Even if he knew it, why is it Bani's fault…Since Pia's child is of no fault, same goes for Bani isn't it? Do you want Veer to go around apologizing to Bani and JW for his mom's deeds, then why is Bani expected to do so...Well, we are talking about Bani here, so that makes a difference na…

(The mother was depressed and she jumpred before the first car she sw on road. How can we blame her?)

Don't you think that it is a very silly and inefficient way of commiting suicide? Mt. Abu has Guru Shikhar the highest peak in the Aravallis and Nakki Tal, the second largest lake in Rajasthan. Dont you think jumping there would have been a better option. Did she ever think of the trauma that the driver would be put to?

She already was in a trauma, how would be thinking about others…Kiran was not right but expecting her to be highly logical and moral when she herself was in gutters is quite not realistic…If Munna cant think logically after listening to a doctor saying that his wife went for an abortion, how can kiran think logically in her given circumstances?

(I am not sure what u r refering to when u meant she left him to fend for him self after the ONS. )

It is funny isn't it. Bani can remember the fact that JW used all those hateful words for her but forgets conveniently that he got shraddhed for his pains, pulled her out of the fire and the riots at Ghatkopar, that he made over all his wealth to her and accepted exile gracefully for his kartoot. And yet Bani continued calling his act a dhoka (of course it reqd another Dixit Rano to remind her of reality) and kept throwing trantrums from time to time even after knowing that he was raped.

Pri, Munna's shraddha was performed by Massi not Bani. Secondly, hiding the truth whatever it may be, isn't that dhoka…In fact, even after breaking her trust so much, she was the one who made first move to mend their differences. Munna did not even apologise for lying and hiding the truth so far…of course, it's munna everything is okay…

😉

Cheers,
Meena

Meena,

(but always it's Bani fault for everything…)

No, my dear it's all JW's fault. After all he should have never allowed Pia to blackmail him etc. Never mind that he had kicked her out of WM on two occaassions but it was St. Bani's love for a rapist which allowed Pia to get into WM, find out about the DVD and blackmail JW in the the first place.

Well, you want Bani to be a heartless person who does not care about anyone especially of a sister who she brought up as a child…Pri, there is something called humanity and Bani was exhibiting only that not love for her rapist sister.

(too much for being wife of JW and too much for being loving…)

Exactly. Only a very loving wife would inflict her hubby's rapist on him.

Yes, Bani was wrong in bringing Pia without asking JW but only a loving hubby would put his pregnant wife behind the bars and looney without even trying to save her but just gives in. I mean if he can set ppl to stop the wedding, how funny he cant do anything other than beg in front of his rapist na…😉😃

Cheers,

Meena