For Story I hope they Don't Butcher BW - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

75

Views

2.9k

Users

22

Frequent Posters

BoredNCynical thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: m3ghna

That's my hope too. JW I am still ok because than it would make good drama and him healing her might bring great scenes from the two actors. I just don't want Bani to regret hurting massi and co, because than afterwards Bani would be shattered and after all she has gone through she does nto deserve that also.

I agree Meghna and in a way, I do agree it's ok for Jai to pay a little. Remember in the airport, she said that "Is baar Sita agnipariksha nahee degi. Ab woh Agnipareeksha legi."

JW has been butchered the way he could not save his wife, still helplessly having GFNs (especially pia) living in the same house with him.

I think it would be good if he can pass the tests that Bani puts him through and is able to prove his love for her and redeem himself. I am sure it will bring them closer and give us a lot of joy in the process in watching. 😳

Edited by nsminerva - 18 years ago
majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#22
Minerva,

(I do agree it's ok for Jai to pay a little. )

Actually I am not bothered about what Bani does to JW at all from HIS POV. For the simple reason that he will happily pay whatever price Bani extracts from him. What I am worried is whether after the deed is over whether Bani is able to handle her own guilt or not.

(Is baar Sita agnipariksha nahee degi. Ab woh Agnipareeksha legi)

But what about Bani's agnipariksha? She has failed in all hers incidentally. She failed to forgive JW for his role in her Mom's dead and has to date yet to regret her parents kartoot towards him. And she too left JW to fend for himself after the ONS was out and even after finding that he was raped continued to throw an attitude. And of course bluntly informed him that he would have to tolerate his rapist in his own house becuase a kassam given to St. K was more important than her married life.

Rgds,

Pri

khrhun_sheen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Sheen,

Ranveer did get away with the whole property scam.

Yeah but she has forgiven him for it, as Bani knows it was Jigs being the leader and bechara Ranveer the puppet!😉

So him getting a bit of punishment is okay.

Ahem, nooo that wont happen, because his better half is there.. aka Rano!

Unless you think being married to leaky faucet raashi was punishment enough 😉. I really liked raashi till she foorced Ranveer to remarry. Though I am loving rano and ranveer.

But if you like Rano+Ranveer then you have to thank Raashi for that!😉 Also Ranveer and Rano didnt say yes/no when Raashi told them to get married. . They could have been firm and told her no...She was looking out for Rano, and if she didnt then Rano would've been outta the house.. Bani being Rano's sister did absolutely nothing to save her sister.. infact everyone was quiet when Jigs was blasting Rano!

kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#24

Meg darling,

Butchering characters is a vicious cycle in KS. If its not JW then it's BW, and vice versa.

Thus after JW butchering it definitely will be BW turn and then again JW turn and then BW turn, till they can't butcher our favourite characters anymore.

So we as viewers can't expect any creativity from the so called creatives or butchers, as they are good at doing only one thing and one theing only butchering JB.😡

Love

Krishan

moudeb2005 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#25

Hey Sheen,

JW did stand up for her and told off jigz for having such a low thinking anf told raashi to take rano in.

But I agree to make these dramatic scenes they always staple everyone's lips. I used to love anu for giving it to her mother in support of Rano. Also Bani never let jigz get away with hurting her sisters. I guess everyone was respecting jigz loss. Though it did not make sense.

555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: majumdar

Minerva,

(I do agree it's ok for Jai to pay a little. )

Actually I am not bothered about what Bani does to JW at all from HIS POV. For the simple reason that he will happily pay whatever price Bani extracts from him. What I am worried is whether after the deed is over whether Bani is able to handle her own guilt or not.

Pri,

After all bani has been through I don't want her to have any guilt coming out of it. I want her to kick the three witches to the curb and stop before doing any significant damage to JW that she cannot live with. I think him being okay with it will make her not feel the guilt too much. I just hope they don't butcher where things cannot be taken back.

meghna

555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: kubare

Meg darling,

Butchering characters is a vicious cycle in KS. If its not JW then it's BW, and vice versa.

Thus after JW butchering it definitely will be BW turn and then again JW turn and then BW turn, till they can't butcher our favourite characters anymore.

So we as viewers can't expect any creativity from the so called creatives or butchers, as they are good at doing only one thing and one theing only butchering JB.😡

Love

Krishan

Krishna,

For once I want the creatives to stop and think and not butcher the characters that are the brand equity of the show. There's only so much actors performances and chemistry can overcome.

cheers,

meghna

majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#28
Meg,

(I think him being okay with it will make her not feel the guilt too much. )

Yes. Besides, he will tell her that it was DDG who had wronged him and not his wife, Munni Walia. 😉

Rgds,

Pri
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Krishna,

For once I want the creatives to stop and think and not butcher the characters that are the brand equity of the show. There's only so much actors performances and chemistry can overcome.

cheers,

meghna

I know dear, thats what we all want. The creatives to stop their non-stop thoughtless deatruction. As without a good storyline, how much can the actors do nad fro how long can they sustain viewership.

BoredNCynical thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: majumdar

Minerva,

(I do agree it's ok for Jai to pay a little. )

Actually I am not bothered about what Bani does to JW at all from HIS POV. For the simple reason that he will happily pay whatever price Bani extracts from him. What I am worried is whether after the deed is over whether Bani is able to handle her own guilt or not.

I totally agree with u Pri their. I Know that Jai will and I just don't want Bani to go so far in her revenge process as to be unable to forgive her self. For me here, I just want JB back together without inflicting too much pain on each other and ASAP.

But, u do have to agree that from Bani's POV he has been unbeleivably cruel and let her down when she needed him the most. The children snatching with such cruelty was so unnecessary. He could have done something being the great JW. ( And please don't get me started on lettting PIa and Co continu to stay on in the home after killing Bani)

Originally posted by: majumdar


(Is baar Sita agnipariksha nahee degi. Ab woh Agnipareeksha legi)

But what about Bani's agnipariksha? She has failed in all hers incidentally. She failed to forgive JW for his role in her Mom's dead and has to date yet to regret her parents kartoot towards him. And she too left JW to fend for himself after the ONS was out and even after finding that he was raped continued to throw an attitude. And of course bluntly informed him that he would have to tolerate his rapist in his own house becuase a kassam given to St. K was more important than her married life.

Rgds,

Pri

Pri, why do u think she has not forgiven JW for his role in his mom's death. The moment she heard the truth she wanted to run back and tell him and to not to carry that weight anymore and he was innocent. She stayed back only to save his property and when she knew it was not needed, the first thing she did was to go to Dubai and assured him of his innocence and she actually said that from her mom's suicide was wrong from which she has learnt not to give up on her loved ones.

As her parents Kartoot, I don't think her father knew it was suicide. So, how can he be blamed? The mother was depressed and she jumpred before the first car she sw on road. How can we blame her?

I am not sure what u r refering to when u meant she left him to fend for him self after the ONS. Can u please clarify? From what I remember she went into shock, then had JW coming and burning up their memories, saying he slept with Bani out of pity, pia for whatever, hugging pia ( which she had witnessed several times before and she never suspected, even had JW leave in the middle of the night after getting a call from pia and also that he was in a hotel room with her; I know JW had the same faith in her but so did she)

And for the rape part, once the trust is lost and after witnessing so much, I think it sometimes takes time to build back the trust. After seeing and hearing so much, not from others but by and from JW before her own eyes, it took her time to trust him again. Especially since the betrayal is by people so close to u. U

Bani has always been portrayed as a person who lives for others. Her identity to herself has been two parts, to be a mother to her sisters and to be a wife to JW. Her fault has always been of loving too much. When she thought her sister was in pain, she could not step back. And also mainly because she had complete faith and confidence in the bond betwen JW and herself. I don't think anyone can envisage the levels pia has fallen to. I don't think she told JW bluntly, she just told him what she felt. In this case, I am not saying what she did was right. I think she was blind to her sis's character, but that is a fault of loving too much. ( I for one would have never got pia home)

Hopefully she has learnt better by now, and teaches pia a lesson she never forgets.

regards,

Raji

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".