Hasn't Pia's character suffered most...? - Page 3

Dear Cordy,
Absolutely correct, Pia's has become one of the most non- believable character.
To display such pathological, obesessive jealousy and greed, she is the one character who is definitely suffering from a mental disorder.
because her actions vis-a-vis JW and BW are now too over the top to be the actions of any sane person.
Partly the blame may lie, as soemone else has also pointed out, with the limited range that RC is able to display. the lack is even more apparent when she is pitted against actors of RK and PD's calibre.
But the real culprits have to be the so-called creative team.
They have been unable to sustain a story shorn of its usual K-twists, K-masala and K-Vamps. and so, they have settled for the tried and the hackneyed formulas.

Armana

To tell the truth there isn't a character in this show that hasn't been hacked up into little pieces and tried to be put back together. All three of the sisters have become ridiculous; JW we won't even discuss; what happened to Sahill; even Ranveer was better being bad. Ashwini/Jigyasa leaving was a sign that things were never going to the same and that haven't been. This show is awful and the storylines border on the ridiculous. It would have been better to keep Pia with amnesia so she could start over and improve her character. JW is a wimp now, but he had everyone shaking in their boots when the show started. Ekta Kapoor has ruined this show and I sincerely hope no other Network gives her the chance to do this again. She's the worst! The absolute worst!!! 😡

Originally posted by: Arwind

Maybe you see it as unrealistic but fact of life is that there are people like her out there. Maybe her progression as to where she began and where she is right now wasn't really explored but fact is people change for varying reasons and mostly to suit themselves and when people are pretty much determined to get what they want they can and will do anything. She is psychotic because she's operating on a level where what she does, doesn't even matter to her just as long as she gets what she wants. She's pretty much unfeeling and operating on an obssessive level. In short she's sick and should be in the asylum instead of Bani.

i dont think im wrong in seeing it as unrealistic! its not a matter of her volte face not being explored properly - there is nothing to explore, there is just no reason!! and people do not just turn into baby-threatening, murderous, morally void people without some catalyst!! there is none here!

evil people are a fact of life, agreed - but ask any psychologist, there's always an underlying reason, some clue to show they are really that devoid of human feeling - and Pia's character may have been shallow and self-centred, but she was never inhuman!! 😕

Originally posted by: khrhun_sheen

Yeah Nisha,

Her character has been severedly butchered. I mean a girl who wanted the "rich" life. (But then who doesnt)She was always the clever one, getting them the ticket/seat on the train. Actually sticking up to JW. To a character who despises her sisters, is cold cruel and inhumane. It just doesnt add up!

exactly! thats what i meant! 😃 i liked that train scene - puraane din kitne suhaane the!! 😉 😆

Originally posted by: Cordelia

i dont think im wrong in seeing it as unrealistic! its not a matter of her volte face not being explored properly - there is nothing to explore, there is just no reason!! and people do not just turn into baby-threatening, murderous, morally void people without some catalyst!! there is none here!

evil people are a fact of life, agreed - but ask any psychologist, there's always an underlying reason, some clue to show they are really that devoid of human feeling - and Pia's character may have been shallow and self-centred, but she was never inhuman!! 😕

Pia does have a reason for being the way she is - she wants to covet all that her sister has. Pia's jealousy is her weakness and it has been the foundation for the way she is right now. People don't always start out being evil but somehow it has to do with the path one chooses and Pia chose hers whether we can rationalise it or not.

Originally posted by: Jojo_han

Are you kidding ....? Or your actually speaking the "Reptile's" side .... 😕

So it means your not siding with your JW... woh bhi aaj when he needs the most.... should I celebrate to that... I think yes I should.... 😆

my God no!!! Cheli no.2 aap bhi mujhe nahi samajh paaye?!! 😭

this is why i said - seperate Pia from her effects on J-B and look at her character in isolation!!

and take one look at my siggy - how could you even think i would leave his side for a second!!!! 😛 😉 😆