Manik needs to find his memory and himself too! :/

shibz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Okay, I understand Manik is suffering from PTSD, wants to forget the bad events of the past, etc. But did he also forget that the last time they performed together they had decided that would be their last performance as Dhruv & Aliya had issues sticking to it. Manik has never forced them all to stay back or perform! As much as he wanted them to stay, he has never imposed his opinions on them. He let them go. As long as he had Nandu he was a secure baccha.
Probably it's the past events that has taken a toll on his mind that he doesn't know what he's doing anymore! Manik being upset coz Mukti & Aliya don't trust the capabilities of fab5 anymore! Manik may not be completely wrong in his place but Mukti & Aliya aren't completely wrong either! They clearly aren't as interested as before! There are insecurities too with regards to their future/career/fab5(as a band). Is it right for Manik to want them to stick around for the sake of Musicana? It's bringing in so much stress! Doesn't he have a sense of responsibility towards Nandini as well? Is that reserved to fulfilling her bucket list wishes only? Just because the girl sticks around all the time, he has stopped caring for himself! As she would do that for him! Nothing wrong in that but what about her? Where is the caring, considerate Manik?

Manik doesn't even remember that Nandini has to practice too! Instead it's Mukti who reminds her about her practice! And then there comes Arya asking about her performance and mouthing those dialogues which Manik should have Manik comes then, talks about himself and his need for her and I kept waiting for him to ask about her practice!😕

If this is all a result of trauma then it's better he either takes a break(MaNan can go on a vacation) or lose his memory completely😳 At least that way he would be able to rebuild himself🤔


Besides, I don't understand what he is still doing in college when all of Fab5 and Navya are doing fine for themselves away from college. Fab5 wouldn't even have returned to college had it not been for Manik's Birthday. Dhruv too left college to do something for himself, then why not Manik too? High time all of them except Nandini leave college! I'm anyway bored of the same college corridors and rooms🥱 Instead they changed Manik's and Nandini's houses😒 Jo change karna tha wo toh nai change kiya aur jo nai karna tha wo kiya! Dumb KY2 team! But thank God for some nice outdoor locations. Otherwise it seems they don't even have money for lights anymore. They're making use of sunlight indoors as well.

P.S - If anybody knows how old is the Nalayak Harshad and what he is doing in college when his baby sister is working, let me know.

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.5k

Users

13

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

sunnymunny thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Thanku for.posting this
Exactly my pov
Totally agree
Plzz post this on twitter n make them read this

The lighting is so dull n depressing
MuratHayat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I am not able to comprehend where exactly is dis heading.. no storyline.. fine accepted.. dey r showing manik's PTSD.. well and gud..bt like u said dat doesn't mean..manik forgets what he nd his fab4 decided earlier... nd what is it with manik dat he wants to show it to the world dat fab3 r very much "there " nd gonna perform together. . Wen frm manik started caring abt what world thinks abt them... nd in all dis he is coming off as a self centered boyfriend. . "His frndz..his music..his band nd he needs nandu." Wat abt nandu in all dis...just randomly fulfilling her bucket list and oft repeating dialogues.. "im lucky to hv u" " u r spl" ...
This is not the manik v knew..definitely not if nandu is a best girlfriend. ..even manik is.. bt lately i don't c dat.. just because dey r showing rough phase in life of manik..doesn't mean Cvs just loose the balance btw manan 😡

Edited by mishaarshi - 9 years ago
shibz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: mishaarshi

nd what is it with manik dat he wants to show it to the world dat fab3 r very much "there " nd gonna perform together. . Wen frm manik started caring abt what world thinks abt them...

This!

And all this for a stupid Musicana!

Music bound them together. Fab5 was not simply a band, it was their family. But when clearly Fab5 isn't the same anymore, members have left, what is with Manik holding on to the band more than his friends? I mean what is more important to him now? The band or the sanity of ppl he loves? And why would he care about the world? He has never mentioned about proving anything to the world before.. has he?😕 Whatever he has done was for all of them collectively. But now they aren't kids. They have different opinions! In fact it's Manik who's acting like a kid! Adamant on tying them up in a chain called Fab5. If they do want to perform together in the future, they can. Why is Musicana so important for that? Their happiness will be anyway incomplete without all of Fab5.

-Nymeria- thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: shibz

If anybody knows how old is the Nalayak Harshad and what he is doing in college when his baby sister is working, let me know.


As long as Manik is in college, Harshad will also be in college. 😆

I think it's the absence of Cabir and Dhruv and the whole trauma thing that's kinda making him go all Fab5 will show everyone blah blah, but yeah, I agree with what you've said. Wish Nandini could be given more to do as well. All this suspense about whether they'll perform or not... maybe they're going to show them all (or at least Manik) perform solo? Not as part of a band? (Just speculating, haven't watched today's epi completely -- MTV website takes forever to load ).
Edited by Nickel8 - 9 years ago
1030053 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Res🤗
I'll unreserve when i get up to date with KY2 may be...🤔
..Zainab.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Basically, theres no hope for Cabir coming back then huh?
Cant they do some random thing, i mean there was always something illogical going on so why not now?

I really miss the old days.
shruti_b_b thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
shibzy i ve quit watching,so i dont know wat u r talking abt😆 bt by ur reviews dis isnt old kyy anymore! am happy with my old episodes rather than dis crap!
i ve moved on😎
Edited by shruti_b_b - 9 years ago
roops14 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I think there is nothing wrong with Manik. Now he is vulnerable and he needs care which can give only by nandini. Remember when nandini in trauma after Pundit fiasco, Manik did all for her without thinking abt anything. He also involved Fab5 in dat. So if nandini taking care of manik is absolutely necessary. I don't think anything is wrong. Also abt mukti n alya it's obvious that they r disturb because of two members of there family are leave them if manik also gives up on them it will more worse.
vaanii078 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
but for me fab3need to perform in musician a because this show is all about their life and their music journey. manik was not showing anything to this world .they are always fighters. they should be together which Alya and multi didn't understand. I want a strong fab3. Alya and mukti can do whatever they want but what wrong in giving some time to their family their band.manik is the only one always need this fab5 .others are always thinks about themselves. if manik is only think about himself then he can became a famous solo singer. I want a strong fab3.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".