Manik and his secret passion - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

4.2k

Users

18

Likes

98

Frequent Posters

MuguetDScorpion thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#21
That song was 😳 Bathroom song and voice. 😳
-abz- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#22
are you seriously finding logic ?
Mujhe bhi kuch samjhao ...my kuch ni jaanti kya ho raha hai ...
hamara sar ghumtha hai

After listening to the song I'm soo happy ...at least I sing better ..no one will mazak uddofy me !
Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Arshalicious

I seriously didn't understand the purpose of that song

In no way was it at par with the beautiful songs Manik Malhotra sings...The ones which pierce straight into the heart

It did nothing but damage his own reputation and prove that he had time to think about song writing but not to call his own friends and girlfriend to inform that he was alive


@This one pierced the ear drum, instead.

Seems like the CVs were not only trying to damage Manik's reputation of always worrying over his friends and Nandu (if he did he would have called to let them know he is safe instead of indulging in silly song writing) but also ruin Parth's reputation as a singing star by giving him a crappy song and not supporting him with technology.


Opti thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: priakachan

No actually...to tell U the truth..I felt it was natural😆

I mean..don't bash me for this..but I personally felt that..the Manik Malhotra who was practicing all these years has not been practicing perhaps for 4 months time and he lost touch with the singing. He said he was writing a song in hospital. But he had no guitar with him to compose a music according to the lyrics. So what he wrote...he just sang in his own way in a music that he made up at the moment. He was rather putting the words into a tune..than singing a song.

A singer of the calibre of Manik cannot reduce to sounding worse than a bathroom singer, even if he hasn't practiced for 4 months. A good singer/composer does not require a guitar to compose a song. He needs to have a good understanding of rhythm and tune. He didn't seem to have both. Great singers can sing extempore without sounding out of tune and offbeat.

.sometimes we have the lyrics..but not a music to it. Perhaps..the CVs have a plan to recreate the lyrics into a fresh song. Maybe that will be a song which will be professionally recorded to be sung as Manik's song in the coming episodes. I hope that this happens.

Highly doubt this will happen.


U know...it's not that Manik Malhotra can't sing besura! I mean..if a person lacks practice..he/she loses the touch with music. Did U notice? Manik just got discharged from the hospital and he immediately rushed to meet Nandini and his Fab 5 members. So pretty natural..that when we have a lyrics...when we penned down...we may sing it out in a tune we made at the time.

Can understand this if he is an amateur singer(which Parth really is) not if one is a professional singer (which Manik is). They are supposed to be selling a fictional show not a reality show.


Regarding writing songs also..Manik was not shown as an expert. Even the song "Jaise mera tu..." was written by Nandini as shown in Season 1. So perhaps Manik is not an expert in song writing also. He just penned his feelings into random lines which he wanted to share with Nandini...But I think..to give a natural feel...he sings it randomly the way we may sing at home to our family.😆

Couldn't judge the lyrics to comment of them because the song was so distractingly offbeat and out of tune. I definitely can sing an extempore song better than that and I am not a professional singer although I learnt music.



U know...when I learnt music...I was pretty good at singing while I was practicing on a routine basis. But recently I am not making time for practice and I've almost lost touch with singing and I find myself besuri at times!😆 So I could connect with why Manik was not singing in a professional style. As stated by Manik himself..he was in hospital...away from his guitar. Regarding how he plays pretty good guitar...it's that...instrumental music is something we seldom lose touch with. But our vocal chords are an entirely different factor.


I'm sure you are not as bad even at your worst. I have learnt vocal singing and also an instrument (the violin). I can vouch for the fact that without practice, instrument playing gets worse than singing. Yes, the voice may sound scratchy and hoarse without practice, but one can't get so offbeat and out of tune.


But I feel in upcoming episodes..we'll get to see Manik singing some good songs! Hope so!😃


Hope they get a professional singer to sing the songs or play bollywood songs. Parth should concentrate on his acting career for now and take formal music lessons before he ventures in that direction.

SS4MaNan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25
Hahahahaah totally my thoughts on the song part😆😆. When he said I've written and song for you and I'm gonna sing it! I was like OMG Malhotra is gonna sing a song for his girl, he has his guitar 😳 and the moment he started singing I was ohh god nooo somebody please make that stop, stop😆 My poor eardrums.

And about the episode IDK I'm liking this carefree MaNan for a change they look their age and are behaving like college kids instead of babysitting Fab3-Navya and Aryamann😕 Though I'd love to watch them having and meaningful talk about the accident and what they went through these last four months! I'm still "hoping" that I'll get that soon😊
tanidia thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#26
People are really immature here.bcoz he was just singing fr her which was incomplete song which was not composed fully he just randomly casuallys sang.so how can people hope that it may be like parinday that was officially for concertwhich mMaddy sang.and yea some people really say abt parth self respecting why party kuchbhi kare that is their prob.when manik side hugged namdini then she looked uncomfortable after their game why people diddnt say anything .part has always fault he is not emotionally invested and loyal to the show like other cast.parth can't act only good in few types of scenes in ky2 there are so many versatile actor but part is good in only some scenes.through his people can't connect manik character NCO after his returning the show become worse.without part the initial epi were were really good but part can't act he isn't srk other actors are really good on acting its just part whose every action is pro to people.he goes to jhalak then people become insecure bcoz they get less man an so they will not vote him.show is 4 days that's is also his fault bcoz he is busy fr personal life.ky2 other actors are really talented than him so he should only do kyy. If he do other things so that is also people problem.bcoz he is not talented like other cast of kyy.but u can only few people has problem and they making this topics and some same people also part on it.part has only problem in his expression but others are really superb.really the gut has no talent only its his look how will he grow with this talent shortage.bcoz all the kyy cast has so talents excluding part and so he is insulted andcriticized more.
EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#27
the only explanation i could think of him not contacting her is he was aware uske bachne ke chances kam hai...he will die soon or something..but miracle happened and vo bach gaya aur wapas aa gaya
but we audience cant keep on assuming na LOL nandu bhi nahi poochi rehi manik se ki why he dint contact her then

and yes for god sake pls make manik sing a good song..i literally shut my ears.
vaanii078 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: tanidia

People are really immature here.bcoz he was just singing fr her which was incomplete song which was not composed fully he just randomly casuallys sang.so how can people hope that it may be like parinday that was officially for concertwhich mMaddy sang.and yea some people really say abt parth self respecting why party kuchbhi kare that is their prob.when manik side hugged namdini then she looked uncomfortable after their game why people diddnt say anything .part has always fault he is not emotionally invested and loyal to the show like other cast.parth can't act only good in few types of scenes in ky2 there are so many versatile actor but part is good in only some scenes.through his people can't connect manik character NCO after his returning the show become worse.without part the initial epi were were really good but part can't act he isn't srk other actors are really good on acting its just part whose every action is pro to people.he goes to jhalak then people become insecure bcoz they get less man an so they will not vote him.show is 4 days that's is also his fault bcoz he is busy fr personal life.ky2 other actors are really talented than him so he should only do kyy. If he do other things so that is also people problem.bcoz he is not talented like other cast of kyy.but u can only few people has problem and they making this topics and some same people also part on it.part has only problem in his expression but others are really superb.really the gut has no talent only its his look how will he grow with this talent shortage.bcoz all the kyy cast has so talents excluding part and so he is insulted andcriticized more.

girl you said every thing that I want.I really don't know why people are critisysing him for everything. through the character MANIK MALHOTRA I connected to the show connected to each and every character. and parth only one word - fabulous actor. nothing else.
dushturain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: tanidia

People are really immature here.bcoz he was just singing fr her which was incomplete song which was not composed fully he just randomly casuallys sang.so how can people hope that it may be like parinday that was officially for concertwhich mMaddy sang.and yea some people really say abt parth self respecting why party kuchbhi kare that is their prob.when manik side hugged namdini then she looked uncomfortable after their game why people diddnt say anything .part has always fault he is not emotionally invested and loyal to the show like other cast.parth can't act only good in few types of scenes in ky2 there are so many versatile actor but part is good in only some scenes.through his people can't connect manik character NCO after his returning the show become worse.without part the initial epi were were really good but part can't act he isn't srk other actors are really good on acting its just part whose every action is pro to people.he goes to jhalak then people become insecure bcoz they get less man an so they will not vote him.show is 4 days that's is also his fault bcoz he is busy fr personal life.ky2 other actors are really talented than him so he should only do kyy. If he do other things so that is also people problem.bcoz he is not talented like other cast of kyy.but u can only few people has problem and they making this topics and some same people also part on it.part has only problem in his expression but others are really superb.really the gut has no talent only its his look how will he grow with this talent shortage.bcoz all the kyy cast has so talents excluding part and so he is insulted andcriticized more.




First of all, this post is about Manik and not Parth..so please stay on topic

2nd of all, I'm not sure are you a Parth fan or his anti?? who said Parth is not a versatile actor or is not talented??? YOu are saying this which is not true...He has more potential than SRK. And the important point we dont want Parth to act like SRK or Ranbir, we want Parth to act like THE MANIK MALHOTRA which he excels at...

3rd of all, what was yr whole point?? i am confused.

if we say the song sucked ( which is true!! ) it sucked ..it was a coincident Parth sang that, I dont think its Parth's fault if the director/producer keep the song in the epi not everyone is born with looks, acting talent/ magical voice/dancing legs etc etc...

Im confused why u gave a lecture of peopple criticising Parth while you are doing the most criticism.


dushturain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: -SaaMYa-

the only explanation i could think of him not contacting her is he was aware uske bachne ke chances kam hai...he will die soon or something..but miracle happened and vo bach gaya aur wapas aa gaya

but we audience cant keep on assuming na LOL nandu bhi nahi poochi rehi manik se ki why he dint contact her then

and yes for god sake pls make manik sing a good song..i literally shut my ears.



yea thats a logical explanation...👏👏 i like it..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".