Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

6.8k

Users

22

Likes

304

Frequent Posters

EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#31
I guess there is another side of the story too. ...no one is asking to stop ..its individual choice ofc and just like that even trenders should not attack MaNan fans just coz they are NOT trending ..wont that be FAIR ??
If I dont trend...I am not a True MaNan Fan😕

If I chose to watch season 2.. I am not a True MaNan Fan n insensitive..😕


I have always participated in the trend.. but this time I have my own reasons to not Trend...mainly coz the trend was not started for MaNan but it was started coz of a story floating that someone insulted Parth..which has no validation whatsoever . I cannot trend something which is based on a rumour even though later it got converted to we r doing it for manan..so many hashtags floating on twitter but not a single one dedicted to MaNan for whom all fans are fighting for.. yes thats make me sad and i chose to not trend..but that does not mean I am not a MaNan FAN...i watch S2 on n off coz its a habit to watch ky2 and i dont watch any other desi show ...and somewhere down the line i have hope may be I will get MaNan back coz they have not shown MaNik dead yet...if that makes me insensitve so let it be...coz end of the day i cannot go back and fix the last three weeks of season 1..

Moreover, I am actually confused by the ongoing trend..may be its a way to show anger ..well i get that...but since most of the trenders want MaNan HEA i am left wondering how r u gonna get ur HEA if there wont be any season 2 itself..or is it like we dont want S2 at all without any HEA...well whatever.
alicedsouza17 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: nneeiill

I guess there is another side of the story too. ...no one is asking to stop ..its individual choice ofc and just like that even trenders should not attack MaNan fans just coz they are NOT trending ..wont that be FAIR ??

If I dont trend...I am not a True MaNan Fan😕

If I chose to watch season 2.. I am not a True MaNan Fan n insensitive..😕


I have always participated in the trend.. but this time I have my own reasons to not Trend...mainly coz the trend was not started for MaNan but it was started coz of a story floating that someone insulted Parth..which has no validation whatsoever . I cannot trend something which is based on a rumour even though later it got converted to we r doing it for manan..so many hashtags floating on twitter but not a single one dedicted to MaNan for whom all fans are fighting for.. yes thats make me sad and i chose to not trend..but that does not mean I am not a MaNan FAN...i watch S2 on n off coz its a habit to watch ky2 and i dont watch any other desi show ...and somewhere down the line i have hope may be I will get MaNan back coz they have not shown MaNik dead yet...if that makes me insensitve so let it be...coz end of the day i cannot go back and fix the last three weeks of season 1..

Moreover, I am actually confused by the ongoing trend..may be its a way to show anger ..well i get that...but since most of the trenders want MaNan HEA i am left wondering how r u gonna get ur HEA if there wont be any season 2 itself..or is it like we dont want S2 at all without any HEA...well whatever.

Wel, i hv also been tagged as a Manan hater just becoz i did not encourage the trend with hashtag #Mtvbringparthback.. Where do u see MaNan in the trend..?? I participated in #withyouNiti instead after seeing the so called Manan fans bashing Niti & boycotting the show.. I think if they have used hashtag abt Manan then, maybe the fandom wont be this divided..
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#33
@Sam a VERY good point!

I see majority of the people trending crying about "being used". I be like "excuse me"? No one from a show can use fans until they WANT to!

Yes, Watwani asked the fans to trend for S2 aur phir palti maar li- but a writer's hands are tied if someone from the cast wants to walk away on his own. NO business unit is foolish enough to let go of their profit-making commodity- in this case, MaNan.

I see trenders practically threatening Swamy to bring Parth back- how about tagging Parth and ask HIM instead to come back?

Ohh... I forgot, he's the poor nar who has been "forced" to walk out coz villain Swamy wanted to separate MaNan in reel life and PaNi in real.

Has anyone ever stopped and thought that isn't it convenient for news of a supposed showdown happening b/w Seamy and Parth, labelling Parth as the "victim" HOURS after he posts his goodbye message on insta and receives major backlash?

And then I realised that no, no one's gonna do that. You know why? Because accepting a lie is always easier than accepting a truth that can break a delusion built for over a year- no prizes for guessing the kind of delusion I'm talking about.
jyotib24 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#34
About S2 I feel m NOT d correct person to judge as m not following it...neither I want to comment on d basis of written updates nor heard comments bout S2...

MaNan fandom consists of ppl of all age group...may it b 15 or 50...All of them have invested their one complete year appreciating MaNan...through trends...appreciating d work of respective ACTORS portraying MaNan via trends, gifts,words...
This complete one year Fans have juggled wth Mtv constantly regarding their pathetic editing (wch has become a habit though for fans ), their promotional stints, their mergers , their handling of internal mess wch was sometimes even visible onscreen...just to get a glimpse of MaNan...Fans making multiple edits of EACH and EVERY moment of MaNan...discussing , analysing every situation of theirs, writing long essays for them, showing them each of the respective ACTORS their support through social networks coz thts d only medium they have shows how much emotionally connected they were to MaNan and accepting that they have ENDED is pretty Hard...and being a MaNan fan I can't blame them for wanting a HAPPY ENDING for them...v all wanted a HAPPY ENDING at some point of time...some of them assumed whereas some are still HOPING ...after all its MaNan...


But d difference lies here wen fans can't accept that d GUY who gave us Ma of MaNan has clarified multiple times that he has QUIT ON HIS OWN and he wants to MOVE ON and grow as an actor...
Wen fans believe some kind of sources or rumors MORE than HIS OWN words...
Wen after dropping hints constantly for d last 2-3 months bout wanting to MOVE ON fans are trending to get HIM back for just a HAPPY ENDING without respecting HIS decision...
Wen this trending mentions bout just one actor portraying Manik ignoring d actual creator behind MaNan ( barring few ppl mentioning RICHA in their tweets )
Wen fans r scared of a Replacement for Manik coz they just want one actor to portray Manik...

Trust me even I feel no one else can portray Manik better than Parth...but if d trend is only bout MaNan happy ending then y all this fuss bout bringing him back and y ppl r not ready for a replacement instead ???



This couple WAS IS and WILL remain SPECIAL always...and no other couple can touch their chemistry in near future...but fans should also once think bout d FACTS !!!!!
hav6587 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: jyotib24

About S2 I feel m NOT d correct person to judge as m not following it...neither I want to comment on d basis of written updates nor heard comments bout S2...

MaNan fandom consists of ppl of all age group...may it b 15 or 50...All of them have invested their one complete year appreciating MaNan...through trends...appreciating d work of respective ACTORS portraying MaNan via trends, gifts,words...
This complete one year Fans have juggled wth Mtv constantly regarding their pathetic editing (wch has become a habit though for fans ), their promotional stints, their mergers , their handling of internal mess wch was sometimes even visible onscreen...just to get a glimpse of MaNan...Fans making multiple edits of EACH and EVERY moment of MaNan...discussing , analysing every situation of theirs, writing long essays for them, showing them each of the respective ACTORS their support through social networks coz thts d only medium they have shows how much emotionally connected they were to MaNan and accepting that they have ENDED is pretty Hard...and being a MaNan fan I can't blame them for wanting a HAPPY ENDING for them...v all wanted a HAPPY ENDING at some point of time...some of them assumed whereas some are still HOPING ...after all its MaNan...


But d difference lies here wen fans can't accept that d GUY who gave us Ma of MaNan has clarified multiple times that he has QUIT ON HIS OWN and he wants to MOVE ON and grow as an actor...
Wen fans believe some kind of sources or rumors MORE than HIS OWN words...
Wen after dropping hints constantly for d last 2-3 months bout wanting to MOVE ON fans are trending to get HIM back for just a HAPPY ENDING without respecting HIS decision...
Wen this trending mentions bout just one actor portraying Manik ignoring d actual creator behind MaNan ( barring few ppl mentioning RICHA in their tweets )
Wen fans r scared of a Replacement for Manik coz they just want one actor to portray Manik...

Trust me even I feel no one else can portray Manik better than Parth...but if d trend is only bout MaNan happy ending then y all this fuss bout bringing him back and y ppl r not ready for a replacement instead ???



This couple WAS IS and WILL remain SPECIAL always...and no other couple can touch their chemistry in near future...but fans should also once think bout d FACTS !!!!!


ExActtly that is what my point is ...i just have one question if the trend is to give Manan happy ending then why was not the topic be "givemananhea"...other side there is proud of u parth trend ...so one side bring parth back other side. Proud of u parth ...niti was nowhere here...in any situation parth is the sorry guy who is innocent rest everyone is the villain ...he himself chose to move on then why target others??
shreya31 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#36
Word to everything @jyoti..
In the end its all about CHOICE
An actor' choice to move on...
Channel's choice to continue wid the BRAND...

Its business...its just that some part of the fandom hasnt made peace with the FACTS YET!!!
Everybody who has watched season 1 is emotional about MANAN,but people have diff ways to deal wid it...some r trending wid hopes they will get HEA, some have moved to season 2 considering it a new show altogether, some have stopped after season 1 because they do not wanna tarnish the memories of MANAN, some gave a shot to season 2 but left...

Everbody is bound to have his/her own thoughts & act accordingly...its just that a portion of the fandom hasnt let the facts & reality sink in!! Hope the FACTS sink in soon, for their own peace of mind...


charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#37
@Saamya - it;s same both sides.
I made one post about Nandini and I had hate PMs telling me that I hate Nandini/Niti and How I should watch the show for the "Nan" or Niti, if I ever loved MaNan. What the hell? How does that even matter to you what and how I love Nandini or MaNan. Heck even in my post for Nandini, I was called a school/college girl because I cannot move on..what shit is that?

I should support Niti because Parth left. Huh, I never started watching this serial for either of them , for me they lived the characters and that be all.

I don't care for rumours or what/whys of Parth's decision because I am smart enough to know we will never know the complete picture. For me the story was over- Manik lived a full graph , so did Nandini..only thing left was their last ride together for which I will live with an AU fantasy.


But I don't understand this trending wars at all or even the concept . Yet , if people want to trend whatever they wish, they should. Neither them preaching to me will make me watch S2 nor can it changes the fact that I love MaNan , toh who cares. I don't need validation for the same
There is no RY to manage or understand the nuances and this is why I cannot connect or relate to this Nandini or the show.

My anger and resentment will be with Channel and the makers. I do hold them responsible for messing it up for whatever shit they did . If Parth was quitting , story was over, your crew was leaving..this audience deserved that respect and a conclusion.

I detest new creatives for using emotional manipulation , stealing my Manik and nandini to sell their story.

Like I said before, trend whatever you want to the makers, PH and whoever- your time, your energy , your thinking ..why judge anyone. For me Niti is always a rockstar and I will be grateful to Parth for giving me Manik.

What I do object is picking on both actors needlessly ..that is uncalled for but then thats the negative side of SNS.



Edited by charminggenie - 9 years ago
LIKEDMG thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#38
@genie...that is my point...when I started to watch ky2 ...I didn't know any of casts...it was story..execution...Manan which attached me the show..
I hv given s2 a chance ...but what I hv watched ...cvs selling old things wid new get up ...each n every epi old memories in 10 mins ...if ph don't hv guts to replace Parth...if cvs don't hv anything except Manan flashback n random tashan...if cvs can't think new guy except Manik attitude...then how cud they expect ppl will watch it...,fans made ky2 hit not due to its star cast ...due to its story line...
I want something at the day end which entertain me...may be it real or unreal...
What is real in s2?taking 2 months baby @ college...tashan wid random guy ...where is the bonding?
Do viewers feel their yariaan? I didn't ...
Trenders used Manan as promoting Parth ...
Cvs used Manan as promoting s2...
First cvs shud think good story ...cvs shud move on first...it will automatically hit wid out Parth or Manik if they give us something to watch nothing day to day college life ...I can't watch random soaps not for any actor...



AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: puba



At last...someone put it so beautifully...seriously...I really want to know who these people are and how they make time for all this? Frankly, it's better to be asleep than trend for someone who really is a nobody but a virtual reality! And...whether to trend or not is a completely personal choice...and I have nothing against people who choose to trend...it's just that I can't fathom why people would indulge in such unproductive ways of spending time.

To answer your question about why people don't care to do something about the millions of people striving to stay alive everyday...I believe it's much easier to put a hashtag and trend...it's much harder to actually do something meaningful!



Thank you for understanding my point :)


Sadly most ppl are busy making this a Parth v/s Niti thing again when the bottom line is actually a case of misplaced obsession for a misplaced cause. Ppl have lost all sense of self-respect...that is what I find hard to fathom too...that ppl have so much time on their hands to incite a mob mentality on SNS for a mere TV show...unfortunate levels of delusion. And even more unfortunate is ppl backing and promoting such obsessive behavior. Where is the sense of basic moral responsibility? No one wants to come forward and state a baseline for sensible behavior...wonder why ppl are so scared to call this out for what it is...instead everyone is busy doing diplomatic gol mol talk of live and let live...live and let live is fine as a general philosophy in life...not in the case of obsessive gundaraj...is that what we should say to ourselves when a mob burns down a village? That oh its their life, their choice?😕
Edited by AreYaar - 9 years ago
kany thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#40


Personally I think the trend for Parth return to kyy will accomplish nothing, unfortunately.
The trend is the last cry of some fans to re-watch Manan and most of us, it would have wanted, but the reality is different and I think it's time for everyone to accept that there is no longer Manan.

For us fans is to decide whether or not to watch S2, or some of the people to wait Parth new project and to support him in it.

Personally, I will no project of Parth support, an actor who does not care for the feelings of his fans, he did not deserve the support of the fans, this is my opinion.
We fans should have their pride and dignity, and to say stop, now we decide.

Parth abandonment kyy, is the culmination of his arrogance, but one thing is forgotten, its popularity is dependent on the fans.


Edited by kany - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".