It is AGAINST Manik's characterization!!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: angel_juhi04

In BFF, Prithvi left Sanjan leaving her heartbroken. It was later revealed by Vrun another guy dat Prithvi is in last stage of his cancer. History may repeat here wid irony dat Parth n Yuvraj were also d leads opposite Fenil. KYY going BFF way.

Originally posted by: shibz

Okay..I've been holding this back for a while now simply because I ain't watching the show and would let the viewers who're watching it decide what they want! But it's killing me from the inside and I need to say it now! No offense meant to anyone..

But, I've been saying this ever since the news of Manik's death broke out!
From what we've viewed Manik and Nandini as so far, NO WAY can death separate them! Not even Coma for that matter! It is so not in Manik's characterization to leave Nandini alone, Leave alone letting her deal with life, suffering, etc for a whole 3 months all alone! Whether in love or hatred, Manik was always around her like a shadow! And now after all that journey they've come along with together, after all the promises Manik made to Nandini, there is no way he would go missing just like that! I don't know how will writers justify this but a Death or Coma is a NO-NO!
Please don't bring the harsh realities of life into this! They're only teens and deserved to live happily, they are the example of hope, light, positivity in this otherwise bad world! They helped us escape from the reality into their beautiful world of fantasy. We don't have to learn the realities of life through fiction(There are other shows for that)! There's a reason why the show clicked for the majority, from the age of 12-60! It's MaNan! How would one be able to enjoy the journey of MaNan of one year now, keeping in mind what tragedy their story ended up with?

I thought I had made peace with my mind and wouldn't believe/accept if the writers killed Manik as MaNan get a HEA in my mind but I was wrong! I mean I still don't buy the tragic end to their story but to even read that Manik is missing and Nandini is waiting for him with hopeful eyes, hurts me SO DAMN MUCH! I'm not able to watch MaNan scenes now without thinking of what writers did to Manik! I can't stop my tears thinking of Nandini who probably lost her fairytale😭 I can't stop the pain in my heart thinking the little boy Manik who deserved to live happily ever after with Nandini, is probably killed! Doesn't matter whether I watch or no, but I want my MaNan to be safe and happy forever!

In fact I would have given the show a try had it returned after a break with a new Manik. But no! my dream had to be shattered within no time😵

In any case the Memory loss and plastic surgery or even heart transplant would make more sense than DEATH/COMA! So please bring a new face for Manik but don't kill him! Don't kill Nandini's hope, my hope, our hope😭 This is one last request, one last wish for my MaNan.

Originally posted by: shibz

Please don't bring in BFF and Prithvi repeatedly! This is KY2 and MaNan we're talking about!
MaNan are soulmates is what we've been made to believe.. they live together for many many years is all I know!

Originally posted by: mishaarshi

watever little rutu saw nd updated frm dat itz clear dey r hell bent on making our lives depressed. Cvs get this straight stop showing manan flashbacks. 😡Or give a memory loss to nandu. Just delete manan from ur season2. But don't ruin our peace of mind by showing us manik's death or nandu living in hope of manik's return. Itz suffocating to even read .
Or yes just replace manik bring any guy u want but don't ruin a fairytale. Don't make "humeshas" scary for us


shibzy🤗🤗 we shall move on frm dis crap soon...v can..v will😭

Originally posted by: ...Tanu...

Sigh!! All this. Love the post.
Yes, it is against Manik's characterisation and against the way Manan has been built.
I keep on thinking even if they wanted a S2, was it really difficult for MTV and the PH to return with a different and fresh story with the same actors?? If it would have been like this then I could have given a chance to the show.
But you see these are different creatives of the show. They have not created Manik and thus it is easier for them to kill Manik. The original maker would have never thought of killing either Manik or Nandini. We viewers know much more of Manik than these new creative people behind. Yes they dont know it is against Manik's characterisation and against the love story and thus killing characters is easy for them.
I am realising from the past few years is once a love story gets famous, it will always end badly. It is either the male lead or the female lead or both ends up getting killed. And the less famous ones always get a happy ending. Once I was lucky to get a happy ending of a couple because the channel decided to end the show because of fans. But bar bar toh yeh nahi hota. So it is up to the viewers to draw the line. And yes I have decided to draw the line. And for me the show ended after their jamming session. 😆 The channel can show whatever they want to but our mind is in our possession and we can imagine whatever we want. I have heard a lot that Manik is dead blah blah but for once I couldn't draw this idea in my mind that Manik is dead even in my nightmares. So yes Manik lives for us. Manik lives for us who has loved MaNan more than anything else in the show and even more than the show. Because like manik I cannot figure out in my mind nandini crying in absence of Manik.
Its going to be difficult to watch the earlier episodes on YT initially. Believe me even I am facing the difficulty. But time heals everything. The best way is to stay away from the current updates and live in the past memories. It will be better if you dont visit the forum but it is difficult too not to peep in here I understand. 😆 Change the genre of the show you are watching. take a break from romantic shows and romcoms and switch to sitcoms. Believe me it will help as it helped me. And then return back to watch MaNan on YT. Just give time, it will be all OK. 😊