||FirefliesHavenMaNanAT#120||Digging Grave For A Ghochu - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

83.5k

Users

59

Likes

2.5k

Frequent Posters

NushIsh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#41
Completely agree KP
They always are so negligent when it comes to Nandini. No wonder people don't relate to her anymore.

When it comes to Manik we always know what is going through his mind.

We are supposed to sympathise with Nandini what she is going through but instead because we don't know what is going on inside her head we tend to criticise her.

Why can't Nandini be as well written as Manik. They used to write her well in the beginning.
white_beauty thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#42
Mtv has uploaded the episode.
Sun7shine thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#43
Hey guys :)

M so pissed! How could MaNan not win the awards
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Kostin: Why do writers give such good dialogues to Cabir and Manik? Why not Nandu? Audience need to hear what Manik described about Nandu today from her own mouth

^^^ A question , KP, I have been asking since ages- she just doesn't have anyone to play it across. No tangible bond like Manik has. CabIni is very Manik centric too.


I don't care how good Navya is to her but atleast let her be that person or invest her with Cabir. If Manik gets to air his confusion and struggle wrt his relationship with others , i don't know why it cannot be for Nandini. I don't know about monologues , I feel real conversation with others might work. This is the reason why she was so less. They couldn't expand her conflict because they needed foil -Amms and Manik. But that resulted in disconnect because they delayed those tangibles.


@Bold: Dude, first the first time, I was so annoyed that they are not giving Nandu good dialogues. Usually, I let it go, but this is her freaking track. GIVE HER GOOD DIALOGUES for God's sake.

I know Cabini is very Manik centric, but I feel like CVs can still use that bond even for Nandu. Let Nandu talk to Cabir about how she is feeling. Now that Raghav is back, Cabir needs someone to talk to - why not Cabir/Nandu? Nandu was the only person who confronted Cabir about Raghav - she had that guts. They can still use that bond.

Navya is just OTT these days. She seems to have forgotten that she is Nandu's friend and not Fab 5's. I swear - she can pretty much be considered Sexy 6 now!

I am hoping that next week will clear out all the confusion and they focus back on Nandu. She needs to talk with Ams and Manik and I really want to see her talking/confronting her own demons. DO NOT DELAY IT ANY LONGER!!!

-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: NushIsh

Completely agree KP

They always are so negligent when it comes to Nandini. No wonder people don't relate to her anymore.

When it comes to Manik we always know what is going through his mind.

We are supposed to sympathise with Nandini what she is going through but instead because we don't know what is going on inside her head we tend to criticise her.

Why can't Nandini be as well written as Manik. They used to write her well in the beginning.


@Bold: Exactly, Nush! When I saw the episode today, I was beyond pissed because the writers are able to give Manik/Cabir such good dialogues, then what happens to them when it comes to Nandu? Do they stop thinking? 😡

This is supposed to be Nandu's track and give her dialogues so that people can sympathize or relate to her - not Manik. We already know Manik is there with her .

Even though I liked the episode and think they are finally getting a handle on this track, I am just annoyed (and I rarely get this pissed).
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#46
Nah I have been annoyed at this lack of bond thing for Nandu for a long long time. Nandu last was this confused back during hospital track but then she had Abhimanyu to play off her thoughts and convo now she has noone which constricts her so much. Like Nandu pretty much in her monologue said the same thing about herself but it sounds so different when Manik shares the same thing with Cabir. Thats harms her!!
Like the ManBir convo was love but thats something that should have been Nandu's thing.

I really hope they make her work with Cabir, they both are pretty much confused, dazed and let CabIni bond over their love lives . Let it not be about Manik.

I don't care for Navya or her thing but anyone to play off Nandu please.

When you have Nandu's conflict as a main-story and then you don't give her the screen-space or the connect how will it sell?

There are few positives coming out from wed/thurs episode , i do hope they don't screw it up for other characters .


@Nush- Problem is earlier Nandini was just so conflict free, she had to be sold as the foil for Manik . I feel by not investing in her bonds outside Manik, they really shortchanged her.
I really don't get that even with Parth's vacation , why was Nandini not given enough screen-space?


Edited by charminggenie - 10 years ago
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#47
Nah I have been annoyed at this lack of bond thing for Nandu for a long long time. Nandu last was this confused back during hospital track but then she had Abhimanyu to play off her thoughts and convo now she has noone which constricts her so much. Like Nandu pretty much in her monologue said the same thing about herself but it sounds so different when Manik shares the same thing with Cabir. Thats harms her!!
Like the ManBir convo was love but thats something that should have been Nandu's thing.

I really hope they make her work with Cabir, they both are pretty much confused, dazed and let CabIni bond over their love lives . Let it not be about Manik.

I don't care for Navya or her thing but anyone to play off Nandu please.

When you have Nandu's conflict as a main-story and then you don't give her the screen-space or the connect how will it sell?

There are few positives coming out from wed/thurs episode , i do hope they don't screw it up for other characters .



@Bold: Genie! THAT'S WHAT PISSED ME OFF SO MUCH! Ughhh like this should have been coming from Nandu. I loved ManBir conversation place, but writers are really doing injustice to Nandu in all this.

I am so glad atleast she acknowledged that she likes having Manik around her. - BUT, OFCOURSE, AUDIO MESSED THAT ONE UP! 😕

@Red: Yeah, that's why I think they would be great companions for each other.

@Blue: Exactly! When you want to sell her trauma and her recovery, she needs to be onscreen for people to see that. She can't disappear and then only be brought to bicker with Manik.
That's not enough - while everyone else except Nandu is given so much screen space.
Yeah, Wed/Thurs were better - they better not mess it up again next week! 🥱
Edited by -KP- - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: -KP-




@Bold: Genie! THAT'S WHAT PISSED ME OFF SO MUCH! Ughhh like this should have been coming from Nandu. I loved ManBir conversation place, but writers are really doing injustice to Nandu in all this.
I loved their conversation but at the same time it pissed me off, this is the imbalance that has been there since ages- like when you have Manik talk about Nandu's confusion with others without her having to address it , the whole thing shortchanges Nandini. The focus shifts to how she is treating him when it shouldn;t be the case. Their relationship is secure, she needs healing/space/recovery time -but it ends up with viewers just focused on how she is treating Manik as if he is the one who went through the trauma.
The conflict is not about them but her. This should have been Nandini's dialogue with Cabir telling him about how she feels about herself.

I am so glad atleast she acknowledged that she likes having Manik around her. - BUT, OFCOURSE, AUDIO MESSED THAT ONE UP! 😕
Don't even get me started on this, such an important thing that needed good execution, they screw it up with the audio. And the whole line comes across as redundant and whiny.



@Blue: Exactly! When you want to sell her trauma and her recovery, she needs to be onscreen for people to see that. She can't disappear and then only be brought to bicker with Manik.
That's not enough - while everyone else except Nandu is given so much screen space.
Yeah, Wed/Thurs were better - they better not mess it up again next week! 🥱
They are already playing few of her conflicts through Manik to support his own guilt like the water one. But they need to be careful with the music bit because that they cannot mess. You need to consolidate it more by making Amms push her alone also. Let her make excuses, be afraid to sell that trauma. Her bickering however sensible would seem silly because in our heads we are thinking of her traumas and waiting for that big moment.
Keep all the sideys away and focus on this track please. If a character like Mukti can get so many chances , they need to invest IN NANDINI ALONE TOO.



white_beauty thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
Genie kp nush nice discussion!😳
I saw the episode. In the whole week yesterday's was the best one in terms of story and also editing. Atleast i wasnt scratching my head trying understand how on earth did we get this scene after that:P
Ohh n i am surprised mtv actually for once gave this week ka episode this week itself.

-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#50
"Let her make excuses, be afraid to sell that trauma. Her bickering however sensible would seem silly because in our heads we are thinking of her traumas and waiting for that big moment.
Keep all the sideys away and focus on this track please. If a character like Mukti can get so many chances , they need to invest IN NANDINI ALONE TOO."

@Red: Personally, I don't mind if they bicker because that's very natural in a relationship when one is having a difficult time. Arguments are bound to happen.
Nandu is having a difficult time and she is bickering because she is not ready to confront her demons. She is not ready to talk to Manik about it, so she is bickering with him.
I can see her finally reaching her breaking point with him next week - now that Manik has involved Ams as well.

@Blue: Yes, please! Invest more time in Nandu. Let this track be all about her. Don't make a khichdi out of it!

Edited by -KP- - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".