Kaisi Yeh Yaariyan Episode Discussion Thread 13 - Page 76

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

90.4k

Users

35

Likes

2.4k

Frequent Posters

ZAHARA. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: MaNanFF

Alya's emotional journey is kimda confusing to mešŸ˜•. When i saw her crying for Manik i genuinely felt for her and it was pretty evident that she loved Manik but then the 1st vampire kiss happened and then Dhrulya happened.šŸ˜•


That's because DhrulYa happened too suddenly.

If I slow it down (in my head), it's like Alya wanted Manik back and to do that, she decided to help Dhruv with Nandini. But then she began falling for Dhruv even though he liked Nandini. She was unsure about her feelings esp towards Manik and Dhruv. And then even Dhruv started to feel somewhat closer to Alya, and then their hormones and feelings took over and they kissed (even though it was an accident). Dhruv prob kissed back because he'd never kissed someone before, and well, Alya... and then it started to change for them. Did Dhruv really wanted to be with Nandini? Did Alya really wanted to be with Manik? And then they just started to accept the changes happening between them.

I REALLY WISHED they slowed DhrulYa down and gave them a chance to speak out; I wanted more on THEIR feelings; their confusing between those they supposedly loved and this new feelings towards each other. Would have been amazing if DhrulYa was played alongside MaNan.

SIGH.
Rutu01 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ZAHARA.


See, that's where I'm stuck on. Manik broke up with Alya because she lied and that they hid things from him. It was the lack of trust that Manik went on. But then I guess he also realised (with his lingering feelings for Nandini) that he and Alya were not in what they called "love".

It was more like a habit, because otherwise why else would Manik fall fast for Nandini and why else would Alya fall for Dhruv if they both loved each other?


yeah for manik to realise it was just a habit nandini n Aliyas lie happened ...aliya took some time but she too moved on quickly with dhruv
-cherryblossom- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ZAHARA.


No me neither. They wouldn't have cheated but nor would they have stayed happily. Between them it was more about Fab 5's friendship than their relationship.

I guess for Manik/Alya it was great that Nandini came along when she did, because what would happen if they stayed together for more years? They stayed together out of habit and love for Fab 5. What would happen if they even got married ? And had kids? Would they have stayed together just for the sake of their kids?

I don't think Manik and Alya dating was "wrong" for us viewers, this relationship gave the characters a chance to learn about love.

In a general sense; two people shouldn't stay in a relationship just because it's a habit or just because it will mean it will break their friendship or whatever. If your heart beats for someone else, or you are growing anxious and worry about your relationship, then maybe it's time to end it?



I was thinking at this level... People in unhappy marriages will have affairs (we see a lot of things happening in front of us) at some point in their lives... it may be not be physical one but an emotional one...
Rutu01 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Zaya.priyanka


M confused here ...By 'they' do u mean 19 yr olds???

ZAHARA. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: DEVILSDESIRE


Manik Was In Relationship with Alya For Like 7 Years Bandee Ke Pass Bahut Sara Experience Hai šŸ˜†šŸ˜†šŸ˜† And Manik Is Not Who will Cheat !!


It's both/

He is sexually experienced but not emotionally experienced.

He knows how to 'do it', and he knows how to keep safe etc etc. I'm pretty sure he knows how to build up and all that stuff. But that's only with Alya. Alya and Manik would have learnt and become used to each other's bodies. But with Nandini, it's different.

She's inexperienced; and so Manik is automatically inexperienced with dealing with someone who has never had sex before. The emotional aspect for Nandini and even for Manik is something he wouldn't have experienced. He may know how to have sex, but he will have to learn about Nandini and how she feels about it.

šŸ˜›
1030053 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ZAHARA.


That's because DhrulYa happened too suddenly.

If I slow it down (in my head), it's like Alya wanted Manik back and to do that, she decided to help Dhruv with Nandini. But then she began falling for Dhruv even though he liked Nandini. She was unsure about her feelings esp towards Manik and Dhruv. And then even Dhruv started to feel somewhat closer to Alya, and then their hormones and feelings took over and they kissed (even though it was an accident). Dhruv prob kissed back because he'd never kissed someone before, and well, Alya... and then it started to change for them. Did Dhruv really wanted to be with Nandini? Did Alya really wanted to be with Manik? And then they just started to accept the changes happening between them.

I REALLY WISHED they slowed DhrulYa down and gave them a chance to speak out; I wanted more on THEIR feelings; their confusing between those they supposedly loved and this new feelings towards each other. Would have been amazing if DhrulYa was played alongside MaNan.

SIGH.

Hmm gotta agree on this.
By the time Alya and Dhruv developed feelings for each other MaNan had become the USP of the show and therefore the CVs started to sideline the other couples .
MuratHayat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
Nice discussion girls...yes if alya wudnt hv done dat gunda thing phir kya tha for manan...Cvs shud hv tried this way...coz come to think of it luks like manik was actually lukn upon a chance to utter break up ever since he got obsessed with nandušŸ˜†
ZAHARA. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Zaya.priyanka



I was thinking at this level... People in unhappy marriages will have affairs (we see a lot of things happening in front of us) at some point in their lives... it may be not be physical one but an emotional one...


Okay. I sort of understand what you're going with.

IF Manik/Alya were say, married with kids and in their 30's etc and they weren't happy. They were just being together for the sake of it, I do think they would try and find ways to relieve themselves. Maybe they may grow attached to someone else, whether it's a physical aspect or emotional, I do think they would break up. Which is why it's better than Nandini came when she did. She sort of gave Manik a direction, a sense that maybe life with Alya isn't as rosy as it first was.
Rutu01 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ZAHARA.


That's because DhrulYa happened too suddenly.

If I slow it down (in my head), it's like Alya wanted Manik back and to do that, she decided to help Dhruv with Nandini. But then she began falling for Dhruv even though he liked Nandini. She was unsure about her feelings esp towards Manik and Dhruv. And then even Dhruv started to feel somewhat closer to Alya, and then their hormones and feelings took over and they kissed (even though it was an accident). Dhruv prob kissed back because he'd never kissed someone before, and well, Alya... and then it started to change for them. Did Dhruv really wanted to be with Nandini? Did Alya really wanted to be with Manik? And then they just started to accept the changes happening between them.

I REALLY WISHED they slowed DhrulYa down and gave them a chance to speak out; I wanted more on THEIR feelings; their confusing between those they supposedly loved and this new feelings towards each other. Would have been amazing if DhrulYa was played alongside MaNan.

SIGH.


Thats the reason dhrulya are in a mess ...their hormones did the talking first rather than them ...In manan ..nandu did the smart thing - friendship phase ...she slowed it down ...made sure they got to know each other first
ZAHARA. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: mishaarshi

Nice discussion girls...yes if alya wudnt hv done dat gunda thing phir kya tha for manan...Cvs shud hv tried this way...coz come to think of it luks like manik was actually lukn upon a chance to utter break up ever since he got obsessed with nandušŸ˜†



Hehe, yeah Alya just gave Manik a chance to break up. The goons things doesn't even matter. (it's like in episode 38 Nandini tells Manik that he isn't angry with DhrulYa because Alya was the one to send the goons, but he's angry that they hid it from him). The why and how doesn't matter. Manik just wanted out, even if he didn't admit it. Deep down he knew that Alya wasn't the one.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".