Pls CVs Show us this...

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

diva82

@diva82

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#21

@Kp, yes because before that, Nandini was fine with Manik with her, she was sounding normal, so I guess there is a fear lock up inside her and they made that scene more noticeable with the echo of Nandini's scream. I do hope the CVs are on this track, that she remembers that part and goes beyond the physical tortures of pandit.

However, Like Anu said, it does seem they are more concerned with Nandini's break down and her recovery period.

Quote

diva82

@diva82

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL yes he is being a hypocrite on this front...he claimed he can never kill for her in the IHU scene and now he's khulle-aam claiming that he will/should have killed Pandit in like every other scene😆...but no one seems interested in holding up a mirror to Manik on this front😆

Usually Nandu does that job but she is herself lost right now...and no one else understands the consequence of this kill loop b/w them other than MaNan themselves.

As we've already agreed...writers made a major khichdi of the IHU/fusion concert track somewhere in the middle😆...I think they are reluctant to revisit/close the glaringly open loopholes now...they probably want to move past this track as fast as possible and focus on Aryaman, Harshad-Nyo etc.

Well the spoiler said no separation, no angst, no psychos etc, so yes they do want to move as quickly as possible for it.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-KP-

@-KP-

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#23

@AY: absolutely; its a speculation because they never built on it; its a minor detail that could easily be looked upon, but it is something that they can build on if that's where they want to go.
However, you are right - they do need to show Nandu atleast thinking about that which they haven't done as of yet...lol not sure if they are going to either (even though I would love for her to do so)
Also it will be a lot more impactful if Manik hears it from Nandu.

Quote

MasakaliRani

@MasakaliRani

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: nneeiill

yea thats true..we keep saying casually and even now he might not have killed..but still he can introspect on this ..anyways i just want to point this out..even if its late..address kiya tho well n good ..nahi tho as usual we will move on to next track 😆

I guess they don't have to make it into a big thing or a whole track on it..it can maybe come out in a conversation...like maybe Manik talking to Cabir about Nandini...about all that has happened because of Pandit and through that he can bring it up about how he once said he could die for her but not kill for her...but seeing Nandini today he wants to kill Pandit...like aisa kuch...some self reflection...not everything has to be a track or a full episode...just a scene is enough to close the loop. But i still say I don#t want him to think he will kill someone for Nandini...just let it be said in anger...but he won't actually do it. I'm sure many have thought the same thing..

Edited by MasakaliRani - 10 years ago

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 10 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: -KP-
@AY: absolutely; its a speculation because they never built on it; its a minor detail that could easily be looked upon, but it is something that they can build on if that's where they want to go.
However, you are right - they do need to show Nandu atleast thinking about that which they haven't done as of yet...lol not sure if they are going to either (even though I would love for her to do so)
Also it will be a lot more impactful if Manik hears it from Nandu.

Exactly...Manik's reactions are usually all governed by Nandu only...for him to realize something this monumental will also have to be connected to Nandu's pain otherwise it will have no value or meaning...only Nandu can move the mountain that is Manik Malhotra into any sort of admission of regret or wrongdoing...however much time it takes...lol

And usually he needs Nandu to translate something for him to even understand it otherwise he's blissfully happy and content with how he's got everything figured out.

For this fear of Manik killing for her thing to be revisited, they'd need to start showing relevant FBs again which they have not done at all...and as Chetu said, spoilers indicate they are going to keep it Pandit related trauma-centric only and focus on Manik cheering Nandu up...regret over the kill question doesn't seem in the zone right now...

Quote

SunoNa123

@SunoNa123

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#26

Did they ever address Nandini's mangalore leaving track or make her introspect on her acts ?? 😆
There are a lot of loops open still, and they do not follow up on many.

About the kill thing, Manik says that to Nyonika too, but then he would not go and kill her also in the police station they made him keep a check on his anger, he did say i cant let my anger ruin things for her. He has tried to keep it in check.

The IHU track, was not because of kill word personally for me, he rather acknowledged to Nyonika that Nandini was saying truth and that he knows she was manipulated. He never negated the fact that she got manipulated, his disappointment was more on lack of faith and getting manipulated.
But then its just me i guess who thinks so 😆.

As it is , they are just doing round and round on tracks, i rather wish they just wind up with whatever they are showing now and move forward. 🥱

Edited by -sylph- - 10 years ago

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 10 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: -sylph-
Did they ever address Nandini's mangalore leaving track or make her introspect on her acts ?? 😆
There are a lot of loops open still, and they do not follow up on many.

About the kill thing, Manik says that to Nyonika too, but then he would not go and kill her also in the police station they made him keep a check on his anger, he did say i cant let my anger ruin things for her. He has tried to keep it in check.

The IHU track, was not because of kill word personally for me, he rather acknowledged to Nyonika that Nandini was saying truth and that he knows she was manipulated. He never negated the fact that she got manipulated, his disappointed was more on lack of faith and getting manipulated.
But then its just me i guess who thinks so 😆.

As it is , they are just doing round and round on tracks, i rather wish they just wind up with whatever they are showing now and move forward. 🥱

Yes, Manik's issue was with her trust faltering...but he did seem quite convinced then that he can't kill for her😆...he did not just say that as part of his Monster nautanki...he really meant it/believed it in that moment...that was part of his hurt...that Nandini imagined him to be a "monster" enough to KILL someone.

And the fact that there is still confusion amongst the audience about what he was saying that day shows how much "clarity" the writers wrote this IHU track with😆

Re: what he said to Nyo...his point was that he believed that Nandu was shown the video and manipulated...how does that take away from him still refusing to accept tha the can kill for her? That point still stands.

Agree on the last line...lol the tracks will keep on going round and round only...lol but it all just amuses me now...story is carrying on for the sake of it😆

Quote

filter.coffee

@filter.coffee

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#28

Even today he said i should have killed that pundit.he is not realizing tge fact he can indeed kill for nandini.he needs to realize that and know that nandu wasn't all wrong when she had that doubt

Quote

SunoNa123

@SunoNa123

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#29

Anu, hypocrites they both are 😆 . You were present in the AT when i was on a ranting spree about how they never make Nandini introspect on her trying to walking away from him part , after giving him so many lectures, she easily got away from those without any introspection.
I was told then, they will show her growth in it, make her introspect , maine bhi wait kiya , kuch nahi hua, they never went back 😆. But then, ky2 CVs have a record of not showing continuity.

I'm all for closing kill theory loop, but what value does it add to the story now?
Are they going to open the whole video thing abhi and how nyonika manipulated, again would it not be a blow to both manik and nandini, yes manik might understand he has the ability to kill, actually every human has that as per me depending as per the situation they are put into. Also, again Nandini wont she feel how she got easily played by Nyonika and her messing up the video coz clearly he did not kill soha. Wouldnt it add more to her current misery ??
Revisiting this whole soha track, will it help them in any way abhi is my question 😆.

Also, the current track, i do not want to or i am NOT trying to sound insensitive, but i would have preferred this track before the confession and before the 50 dragfest epis on nonsensical fusion concert track.
As an audience i am kind of fatigued when it comes to Manan now and have very very less patience to such rinse repeat track😆

Edited by -sylph- - 10 years ago

Quote

-KP-

@-KP-

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#30

@AY: I know they are probably not going to revisit that kill question anytime soon, but I would really like them to do so sometime in the future. That whole question started this stretched fusion concert track and they need Manik to introspect; its not fair to give him a pass. They could revisit this when MaNan are together - the perfect time would be when Soha's reality comes back or when they are tackling Nyonika together lol (clearly I have a lot of tracks stuck in my head - don't know if I am going to see any of them onscreen...lol).

Quote

1 2 3 4

Pls CVs Show us this... - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics