To the Creatives!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: Ribelle_IshRa

Oh! Yeah, I forgot to mention that😆

Exactly! It seems as though Nandini is so perfect at the art of playing a veena that she doesn't need to be corrected😆 Good joke!

But Aliya, me thinks they are on their way to showing that...whether they read this or not...(the correction, that is)

Maybe then the movements will be better...(for now, they can't give us bad music na...to show how she plays when wrong.)

no Belle,i disagree with you,if a teacher can start his first class about punctuality(on time),second class on her knowledge about music,third class on discipline then how can he yet not noticed her misholding the instrument at least on second day itself???

Supreme disappointment...👎🏼

Quote

Not Available

@Ribelle

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: Nxt_rockstar

Partner! You did bring another good point here! I am learning guitar these days and honestly I know how a few things are wrong with guitar playing too! Strap wasn't needed! Poor guitar does give you liberty to abuse it as its how rock music is reflected on audiences!
Manik's instrument isn't electric guitar first of all! Chalo, it's fine as it can be something which he can play! Second, in song 'Ye Dooriyaan', I couldn't find sound of electric guitar! These small little flaws do matter when you are dealing with an art!

And about Veena, that toh needs full attention! 😆

Good points there again!! 😕

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Aditi

@NxtRockstar..

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: Ribelle_IshRa
I agree with you...thanks for the post!
Such negligence makes the scene abhorrently distracting...the music is so pure but the movements don't justify it. A big thumbs down to that...

Also, as Saamya pointed out, the Veena isn't held that way...most would know that... :$

a little off topic, but Niti needs to correct her lip sync too...she doesn't make it believable at all...not when you have a perfect lip sync job going on just beside her...(we know how good Parth is at it)

This is a completely neutral and polite opinion/request. The CVs and Niti Taylor should take it that way...hopefully. We're here for constructive feeback...and the Concert is coming up.

p.s.: yeah, the guitar strap wasn't necessary...dunno why that was put in!

Hey Bella

I would say here work is needed to be done but at ground level first! It is so clear that even director or CVs aren't well acquainted with knowledge needed. Later it comes to actor's level! She may or may not do research and I don't know how much it would help if she does. I am trained at classical vocal music and YT can't help much! She can watch it, do it and then forget it next time as no one is pointing it out because they themselves aren't paying any heed towards execution!

About lip sync part, I have different opinion here! 😆 Niti under-does it! Parth over-does it! He puts too much force some times. Now these are the things where actors can work upon!

Quote

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#24

One more addition Belle,if you remember panditji was correcting (or tightening or loosing) the strings of Veena while she was answering his answers about her knowledge on music in the second day of their training...so how can he postponed to correct the basic thing of holding the instrument at least...😲

Edited by Aliyagogoi - 10 years ago

Quote

Not Available

@Ribelle

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi

no Belle,i disagree with you,if a teacher can start his first class about punctuality(on time),second class on her knowledge about music,third class on discipline then how can he yet not noticed her misholding the instrument at least on second day itself???

Supreme disappointment...👎🏼

Yeah Aliya yyou're right! But what I mean is I'm looking at it from their negligent point of view...😆

Quote

Aditi

@NxtRockstar..

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#26

Artist to artist 😆

Show does lack a lot when it comes to justifying music in every department! I find Ayaz best in handling his drums or even lip sync! Who can forget "Manjha"!!

For rock music, it's all forgiven because it's all about expressing first! It kinda forgive it all! But classical music, now this isn't something which should be done with half heart or half knowledge.

If their concept is about how perfect Manik or Nandini are as artists, they gotta justify it! 😳

Edited by Nxt_rockstar - 10 years ago

Quote

Not Available

@Ribelle

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#27

Yes...He sometimes over-does it😆 But I just like to ignore that and think that's him singing with passion and love...I'm biased😆what can i say?

Edited by Ribelle_IshRa - 10 years ago

Quote

Aditi

@NxtRockstar..

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: Ribelle_IshRa

Yes...He sometimes over-does it😆 But I just like to ignore that and think that's him singing with passion and love...I'm biased😆what can i say?

That can be overlooked because message is clear! Emotions and feelings are conveyed! Lip-sync isn't a big deal unless they are totally not getting it as in forgetting lyrics or juggling words! 😳

Quote

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: Ribelle_IshRa

Yeah Aliya yyou're right! But what I mean is I'm looking at it from their negligent point of view...😆

but these things making the two classical musicians looked so disappointing...

if you can remember,when first time Nandini was playing with veena when manik saw her through glass of door(after hospital track),she hold it almost correctly when no teacher was there...but now when TK is there i can't take this disappointing things...

Quote

Not Available

@Ribelle

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#30

You are trained in classical music? That's great!! I know it must be a difficult thing for a layman to get it right just by watching YT...she can't do it without support...which is why you are asking the creatives, aren't you?😊

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 7

To the Creatives! - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics