The mind vs the Heart! - Thread - I need You! (Day 17); pg 28 - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

237

Views

29.6k

Users

20

Likes

434

Frequent Posters

maankigeet4ever thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: twinkle10


ughhh! So I need to rant too... like I full wrote my response too and I was so emotionally attached to it because I felt all the scenes were flashing in front of my eyes again and then boom! One slip of a finger and the keypad showed it's magical move and I ended up on a totally uninvited page. Like whyyy? :'( So then I started writing. Agian. And here it goes.

I'm glad you brought up a few points about Mukti. Honestly last night, I was too drenched in my manik's emotion that I felt the least to pay attention to any other character. But whilst we're at it... me shall drop in some things. Mukti's battle with herself was quite evident last night. She got drunk because she didn't want to fall weak. And especially not in front of her friends. If we think about it, she's never had the opportunity to take off this careless and bratty facade of hers and reveal the beauty of her true self. She did get the opportunity a few days ago, but now she has no one to show that side too. He's gone. And he's taken her true self with himself. So she's back with her mask of "I don't give a heck about this world" and has walked in again, knowing that for most people it wouldn't even make a difference because they are used to seeing her like this. Reckless and a mess. I really felt for her yesterday. When Cabir was trying to get her to spill about Abhi... it was a sad moment. She was fighting her tears and sorrow and wanted to conceal it from the whole world as if nothing had ever happened. But I still see hope somewhere. I feel this can't be the end of her story. This is not what she deserves. First her parents, then harshad and now abhi. I still hope with that unread letter than he hasn't abandoned her. He can stop fighting for himself. But he can never stop fighting for her. We saw he know her to the core. So he's bound to know the consequences his disappearance can bring in her life. So there is that teeny weeny hope but at the same time I'm scared for the both of them. I'm scared that what if it becomes too late and no letter is ever read, and no last goodbyes are ever said. I guess only time will tell what's in store though/.

Now onto the the crux of yesterday's episode. Dhruv's unleashed feelings. It really fumed me o see that he put himself on top of all his friends and just vented non-stop, not considering the criticality of yesterday's situation. Mukti needed her friends the most yesterday. Couldn't he have kept mum for her sake? I admit that Manik has nurtured dhruv like his own baby brother, but the rest of the group hasn't cared for him any less. They've always been more protective and more careful towards him than each other because they knew his vulnerability and innocence could be easily manipulated by an external cruelty. But it totally shattered me to see that not only his brotherhood, but he pained his friendship too. And there stood my manik. Completely clueless. Absolutely baffled. Speechless. What? When? Where? How? There was pain. Yes. But there was more pain because he was blaming himself. How I just wanted to hug him and console him that no. It's not your fault. It never was. But he stumbled and fumbled in the cold, dark corridors that imaged the depths of his heart at that moment. He was all alone and it was all silent.

He rejected all her requests to talk to her because he didn't want her to burn in the same fire he was writhing in. Even amidst all his pain, angst and heartbreak. He wanted to protect her. Protect her from himself. But he had forgotten that she was no separate to him. She lived right there. Within him, as her heartbeat. And when he relaised that... it was a truly beautiful moment. The way his lips stutter before finding the right words to tell her. He wanted to say so much but only silence seemed to be pouring from his inner-voice. And that one tear that just rolled down his left cheek. That marked his defeat. He had lost against himself. Lost against all his promises. And that's when he needed her the most.

uh oh... I think I got carried away again. *sigh* the effect manik has on my life lol

I seriously can't wait for tonight's episode and gosh writing on it will be like a dream.

As usual... your essay had everything that my response lacked and so twinkie says thankyou!! haha

Talk soon!
Twinkie <3

Ohhh my twinkie bear...we need to hug it out..IF has been mean..i swear i am gonna start copying every paragraph i end up typing so at least something may be saved that way.
So...while i wanted to refrain to letting more thoughts loose..after reading your response..my wheels got turning again so you know..now a girl's gotta write...lol

Umm...we haven't touched on own Cabira and if we don't talk about him...our essays shall remain incomplete. Cabir is a wonderful friend, no doubt about it and yesterday,he had to pick between two friends, both friends who needed him. He is the last and the most reluctant one to leave Manik. Deep down, he understood Manik's pain and wanted to be there for him. But he realized Mukti needed him more, to save her from making a mistake she is bound to regret. And Manik has always taken care of everyone..his friends aren't use to role reversal, they know Manik takes care of himself and that's where his friends let him down the most. Cabir assumes he will be okay: "you will be okay na, i will call you." I don't blame Cabir thou, he just had to pick the friend that needed him 'more."

Mukti too wears a mask, so glad you pointed that out. Fab 5, man they are such a broken bunch. You were absolutely right in saying that Abhi has taken her true self away. He was the one to show her who she truly is..and what a beautiful person she can be..But as he left..her true reason for smiling, she is back to the facade of drinking, hookups. You know she was prepared for him to die and leave that way where fate left them with no choice..but this way, he has willingly walked away and that's why this hurts her so much more. She wanted to burst out into tears when Cabir asked about Abhi..she wanted to throw herself and cry in her friend's arms that she has been abandoned once again but Mukti like Manik relies on anger to cope. She will be angry with Abhi so the pain dulls to numbness.I sincerely hope that Abhi has gone to try new treatment..for Mukti's sake, he has decided to fight the cancer and defeat it for their love. I have hope left for Abhi and Mukti..they deserve happiness and togetherness.

There is a point where you mention that Manik blames himself and honestly i hadn't thought of that before but it makes complete sense. Manik might eventually blame himself..thinking that he has failed as a friend and brother..that the fault lies within himself( oh this sounds so familiar) But i hope Nandini can help him understand that he isn't so. in reality, he is a wonderful friend, who gives all the love his heart has.

Oh i absolutely love your thought that even amidst all this pain and heartbreak, Manik wants and needs to protect his Nandini. He will even try to shield her from his own wrath. He know his anger is about to consume him and he would hate for her to see the Monster unleash. He would hate to be the reason for her tears. Oh yes ! you said my beautiful moment for me. When Manik comes to her after being so utterly lost, he found her, her light guiding him. Right before he says that he needs it...that struggle, the defeat, the need, the heartbreak..all wrapped up in one look he gives her ! With my emotions on the rise..i forgot about my beautful moment but you said it for me

Ummm..i think i got carried away too..opps :P

Tomorrow tomorrow...hurry the fudge sauce up..lol

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3
Edited by maankigeet4ever - 10 years ago
anotheranfan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
Going to new thread now... :) Btw you still owe me replies to my comments on Day 15 and 17 :) Will be waiting on that so please do reply whenever you can :)
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: anotheranfan

Going to new thread now... :) Btw you still owe me replies to my comments on Day 15 and 17 :) Will be waiting on that so please do reply whenever you can :)

Heya girl! Yup yup... I will surely get around to them after uni today or either tomorrow evening. You wrote me such a beautiful essay. No way I can't express my thoughts. Plus there is always something new I learn from your posts everyday so I need to obviously point out that too haha
Shall see you around soon! <3
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: simidi

I was thinking he might finds out pandit tried to keep nandu in college aswell so just to keep an eye on her he joins the class or maybe as he said he will torture her he joins the class so she cant concentrate and gets in trouble.

It can turn out to be anything I guess. After all he's THE Manik Malhotra. The unpredictable one! And as we saw in today's episode... he blamed her for coming close to him whereas he was the one who initiated the move. So one thing is for sure here... no matter how much he tries to refrain himself from her and maintain his distance, we'll see his plan back-firing quite a few times in the days to come haha
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: twinkle10

It can turn out to be anything I guess. After all he's THE Manik Malhotra. The unpredictable one! And as we saw in today's episode... he blamed her for coming close to him whereas he was the one who initiated the move. So one thing is for sure here... no matter how much he tries to refrain himself from her and maintain his distance,no matter how much he tries torture her, we'll see his plan back-firing quite a few times in the days to come haha

twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: pia.raha

after so many emotional episodes,got the perfect dose of laughter!!!! 1stly when nandini told that she is going to bake cake,tab hi mujhe laga ke aata ka koi scene to hona chahie,but never thought aaata ke sath paani bhi mil jaeygaa!!!!!! o my goshh shower sceneee,hayeee!!!!!

And then comes the times of laughing!!!! the way cabir was rofling,i was rolling on the floor seeing their reaction!!!!!😆😆 dhruv ko to puro jhatka laga,aliya was also shocked!!!!! 😆 loved mukti's reeaction too,she was trying very hard to control her laughter,and cabir besharam kahin ka,uske dialogs sunke mein aur bhi has rahi thi😆 "manik tu nandini ko bathroom tak kaise le gaya😉" totallly loved every scene of the epi!!!!

Hahaha dude you're so right!! I was soo trying to refrain my laughing out loud because my parents were asleep but oh goddd... it was a lovely treat of an episode to watch after a long time. I've missed them fighting with each other tbh... the little nok jhok is now back with a bang!! 😆
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: sonia_1

Lovely post again 😊

Manik is all heart...his love unconditional...his trust absolute. Nandini has finally realized that she needs to fix what she has broken. At some point in the near future, there should be reflection on her part as so what Manik ' gave' to get Nyonika to reverse her expulsion since she is well aware of ' give & take ' policy of Nyonika.

Manik- Pandit confrontation is going to be interesting... At loggerheads ! well put by Nyonika. Manik is a good judge of character as he is well aware of cruelty and deceit.


Thankyouu!! Much appreciated 😃 Yes revelations are definitely necessary throughout this journey. Because to some extent, they still need to open up a lot more with each other. They have to realise that fighting for each other by keeping it all to themselves to prevent the other one from experiencing any kind of worry or distress is a big no no. They need to par these hurdles together and hand in hand.

Yeh he definitely has a talent of recognising the personality and motif of a person's action by the vibes that reflect from him or her. It's certainly going to be a drama-filled confrontation.
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: maankigeet4ever


So this vicious cycle of reply to reply is so much damn fun man..lol


@ bold...Girl...you and I are sadist partners now. I actually think of scenes you probably liked while I watch the episode too.

Okay, i want to discuss Navya first so i am glad you brought her up. To be honest, her character I initally didn't like when i first started the show. She was too chirpy for my liking and she was continuously blinded by her 'love' for Harsad. I am damn face-palmed myself whenever she fell for Harshad but her character has grown leaps and bounds and Harshad's harsh betrayal has played a huge role. She has grown up in a very short span and i have come to admire her.
Cabs and Navya duo is becoming a fast favourite, These two will develop a very beautiful friendship. Cabir will become her support system through her pregnancy and like we always say, Cabir is a gem of a person.

@bold for the Manan section. I absolutely agree with you. Relationships that face hardships early on, and manage to overcome always have stronger relationships. Because they realize the person they love is worth fighting for...all the way. And that's how it is for Manan. It's one of the reasons i love this track, this track is making Manik and Nandini into Manan..in every sense, mind, body, soul and heart. Nyo was able to break Manan because right now, their relationship is vulnerable, there are cracks in it that Manan must fill such as trust and abandonment issues. And once they acknowledge it and work on their relationship, they will together become invincible.
Also Nandini's idea of becoming friends was the right one at that time and despite Manik's initial reluctance, he agreed with her. Because lovers that are friends have the most long lasting relationship. Friendship in any relationship is really a cementing element and Manik and Nandini should become the best of friends for the utmost strength in their relationship. And plus, reseacrh shows that marriages between friends last the longest..lol.I couldn't help it. I had to add this.

You know me too well already Twinkie. That look was pure love

I love our essay form of discussion cause we both never get tired of discussing Manan so yeah..keep the essays coming.
Okies, now i gotta get my gluteus maximus off IF and lock it down and study for a few hours. If you see on IF, please scold me..lol.

Edited: I forgot something again..lol. I have been thinking about the Soha dead but not being dead. Why is being left hanging that way ? I hope Nandini chooses to investigate and gets to the bottom of this. Soha being dead or not doesn't factor into how 'Nandini betrayed his trust' but being left hanging like this doesn't work for me. Last night, i was thinking how it was the miscommunication between Manan about Soha that caused all the problems. Manik chose not to tell Nandini about Soha being psychotic and Nandini kept him in the dark about leaving. I hope eventually they will get around to the NEED to communicate in a relationship. Okay now i am done.

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3

p.s love the new dp..The minion is so so cuteee <3

Alrightey so here I am again!!! Aah the bliss of writng an essay for you is the joy that nothing else provdes hahah
Anywho... so first thing first. Dudeee people probably hate us right now for being the massive sadists and tragedy queens that we are. I mean we like happy endings but the emotions of pain, hurt and agony that our Manan experience is what makes us love them. Maybe it's because it brings out the best in the both of them and their passion and need for each other seems to escalate to a brand new level. It's probably also because we both know that after they surpass this sea of fire, there is only "forever" destined in their lives.

Man how I love reading the repetitive lines of ours that express how Manan's bond is bound to get stronger and unbreakable after this track. The thought "whatever happens, is for the best" seems to have been only written for them. Because no matter how many times they face misunderstandings or difficult times , destiny always manages to bind them together in a knot which compels them to work together and find the solution of the situation.

Hahah you are a little nerd I must say ;)

And I agree 100% with you on the bond that Cabir and Navya will share amongst each other in the coming future. They will truly be the missile of friendship where I know for a fact that this life-longing friendship of theirs will also help the both of them in the healing process of their love-wounded hearts. They will eventually be the biggest support system for each other! :D

I sincerely hope you got through much of your uni workload and feel a little de-stressed now! :)

Aaah god job partner! I brought up a similar point in one of replies to another writer on this thread. Manan need to learn from their mistake of the lack of miscommunication here. Whilst they do it out of goodwill to save the other person from worrying too much about circumstance, but it is important they understand that when the're alone, they are 2 and when they join they become 11. Half their problems wouldn't even arise if they learned to open up more with each other and share their worries, because after all they are just two halves of the same heart. They need to become each other's strengths not each other's weaknesses.

Okies so now I'm done! Feel kind of bad thought I took so long to reply to you :( but I hope you know this just the start of our endeavor together of analyzing every second of Manan's life! haha

Oh and thankyouuu for liking my minions! Absolutely love them :D

Loads of love...
Twinkie <3
Edited by twinkle10 - 10 years ago
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: AARMAY1

👍🏼 lovely analysis ...

Thankyou! 😛

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".