Posted:
Originally posted by charminggenie
Originally posted by arathim
Genie...There was some line in a reply of yours...that he is all good too...
I was debating that here...
Manik lives in grey...not Nandhini though...atleast she has never given us a reason to think otherwise till now...
I still stick by it , he is all good , his intent is always a noble one.His defense or his greys' in his actions are part of his defense mechanism .
On Nandini she is like I always say the narrator , we don't know her enough beside her role around Manik to categorize her behavior. She has issues big red flags for me which are not good like how she takes all the burden on herself, guilt trips herself and how she takes things on face . Her issues are more subdued.
She is a regular normal girl , her this moment of confusion about Manik going to the rage as much as we debate made her commit a mistake , she took everything on face value didn't ponder , we explain it by understanding her dilemma while for Manik's anger is driven by his anger.
Nandini when drunk was laughing and mocking Navya , a sober Nandu won't have done that,that was humanizing for me , if she doesn't have a grey shade in her she won;t be real or relatable ever.
Think Manik just him, his childhood, life till now and his actions. You would see that this buy hasn't lived for himself ever. His anger, happiness has always been for others. His goodness shouldn't be a factor or be weighed in with Nandini's . Both are different yet equally profound.
She has issues big red flags for me which are not good like how she takes all the burden on herself, guilt trips herself and how she takes things on face
These might be shortcomings ...but wont constitute to not being All Good...which is about intentions...
On Nandini she is like I always say the narrator , we don't know her enough beside her role around Manik to categorize her behavior.
Arent we supposed to know the narrator the most in the story...example Bella in twilight...?
Didnt we see her actions for Shahid , Navya , Rishab etc...to categorize that she is good theough and through...
Nandini when drunk was laughing and mocking Navya , a sober Nandu won't have done that,that was humanizing for me , if she doesn't have a grey shade in her she won;t be real or relatable ever.
She might have mocked and laughed at Navya at that time. when she was Semi-conscious to know the difference between wrong and right...so cant blame her...but as you said sober Nandhu wouldnt have done it...
Why cant be through and through good people be relatable or real...we all want to be them in our Heart...in that way we relate to them...and there are people like that around us too...They are real...
Think Manik just him, his childhood, life till now and his actions. You would see that this buy hasn't lived for himself ever. His anger, happiness has always been for others. His goodness shouldn't be a factor or be weighed in with Nandini's . Both are different yet equally profound.
He might be the best person in the world for a few people ...for others he acts in Grey Territory...
Even people like Harshad will have their own reasons , traumas for their Bad behaviour...so do we discount their actions because of that...why the spl. Treatment here...?
Shiv Shakti
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
Hindi TV Shows
