Why Only Harshad Goes To Jail!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

5.2k

Users

10

Likes

76

Frequent Posters

-cherryblossom- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Manik did get everything covered..:

When Navya was in the dumpster, remember Cabir had camera installed inside the dumpster and was keeping close watch on her.. if she was suffocating dhruv would have saved her...

When shayad was ready to commit suicide dhruv was there to stop him before he jumped..

I am not justifying Fab5 actions but they knew when and where to draw the line.. They might push people to the edge but never went overboard...

But harshad did not even think twice before cutting the harness wire.. he never had a back up plan.. His intention was to kill or hurt manik... When he bought goons to beat up Cabir and Raghav, his intention was to hurt them to such an extend that they are left to die or remain handicapped rest of their lives... even 2 episodes back Harshad was gloating that he should have pushed Manik harder when they were kids during the meteor shower ...

Even with Navya.. he clearly does not love her... The only reason he slept with her is to make himself feel like a man... He only played nice with Nandini is cos she stood up against fab5 especially Manik and dared to punch him... the minute he came to know she is with Fab5 he dint waste a minute to plan to bash her head ... That to hurt her and bring serious damage... He was aiming at her head with a cricket bat..

There is no way I can feel sorry for Harshad ..He deserves to be in jail... He threatened everyone in front of the police... Fab5 actions are just worthy of suspension from college for few days its not jail worthy
miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: SHRADDHA2102

whatever manik o fab 5 use to do it was planned n not just to kill someone tht was nt their intenstion... n in our india if u wann to be prove guilty than enough proofs are needed... in case of harshad d proof were there... but not wen manik or fab 5 hd attacked navya o nandini... wt harshad did was totally murder wheater it us cabir or manik however by cleaver way manik saved himself but wat abt cabir... he was hospitalise...


U mean to say since there are no proofs for what Fab5 did..Its only Harshad going to jail?..Are u listening to yourself yaar?
miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: queenoftimbaktu

I have another question. Rather silly. If the police didn't come, then how and why did Harshad go to jail? He just simply and happily agreed to sit on Navya's lap and landed up there? 😛


😃 It was Fab5 who took the proof to police station and got him prisoned..😊

Police did not reach there at the end of climax😉
miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: -bharti-

Harshad should have been jailed the day he beat cabir n raghav black n blue mercilessly without an iota of remorse. That one act of harshad displayed his criminal mind. His another biggest blunder is using nandini and navya as pawns especially navya. He will certainly ditch her and that is unpardonable. Imagine navya,s state now if she is pregnant. Harshad used her literally 😡 its a sick mind. He will be booked under multiple sections of the criminal act for these two acts.

He has been harbouring hatred for a long time with regards fab5 n manik. What about his ditching Mukti??? What about him spiking another girl,s drink at a party where cabir thankfully changed it.
Yes i agree with you on one point, alya sending goons to nandu was and could have turned dangerous if dhruv hadnt intervened. She paid the price, lost manik.
Coming to Fab5,s bullying acts, it is deplorable n condemnable but i dont think they intended to kill anyone. Navya was in the dustbin n dhruv was keeping a watch, why would he sit in the park alone? He was also present at the sight watching shahid. Manik had a timer set to torture harshad n he returns to the place but before that nandu had helped harshad.
Coming to Maniks threatening nandu to dig her grave, how can you point that? he apologises immediately n promises not to hurt her. When has harshad apologised or even been remorseful of his acts??? In any criminal act the motive n the intent is paramout.




If intending to kill is a crime,then ragging does not mean any better..

Remember? Manik did things to Nandini real bad than just ragging..


miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: -MKB-

I am sorry For me Harshad was gone the day he spiked that drink

Okay Cabir switched it but what if Cabir would not have been there
Then Harshad would have taken her advantage ? He behaves with a girl like that even when he has a sister!
Harshad is using Navya for his own revenge so much for respecting a girl
So what Nandhini betrayed Harshad does that mean he will hit her with a bat?
And when he pushed him when they were considered i can still consider that he was scared so he reacted like that but the to gloat about it?
Is that correct?


You guys think only intention to kill costs jail?..Its a No..There are other crimes eveteasing,ragging.voyeuring etc etc..Our Manik baba tops the scoreboard in these and so many other stuffs too..

If Harshad is going to jail for one reason..Fab5 has lot more reasons to be jailed too..
miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Another crime for which Harshad should be in jail - DATE RAPE.




Okay..I m gonna repeat myself..Not Jus Killing or Intention to kill does not take u to jail..

Im not saying Harshad is a saint and did not do anything bad at all..He definetely did his share of crimes..

But did Fab5 get punishments for what they did? Or are u still gonna defend Fab5?

And trust me Im a LGBT supporter..Im sorry to say this but the hate crime u r talking about is not even legal in India..So if harshad booked for hitting a guy to death..then Cabir and Raghav should be booked too for other whole set of reasons...

miyova thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Zaya.priyanka

Manik did get everything covered..:


When Navya was in the dumpster, remember Cabir had camera installed inside the dumpster and was keeping close watch on her.. if she was suffocating dhruv would have saved her...

When shayad was ready to commit suicide dhruv was there to stop him before he jumped..

I am not justifying Fab5 actions but they knew when and where to draw the line.. They might push people to the edge but never went overboard...

But harshad did not even think twice before cutting the harness wire.. he never had a back up plan.. His intention was to kill or hurt manik... When he bought goons to beat up Cabir and Raghav, his intention was to hurt them to such an extend that they are left to die or remain handicapped rest of their lives... even 2 episodes back Harshad was gloating that he should have pushed Manik harder when they were kids during the meteor shower ...

Even with Navya.. he clearly does not love her... The only reason he slept with her is to make himself feel like a man... He only played nice with Nandini is cos she stood up against fab5 especially Manik and dared to punch him... the minute he came to know she is with Fab5 he dint waste a minute to plan to bash her head ... That to hurt her and bring serious damage... He was aiming at her head with a cricket bat..

There is no way I can feel sorry for Harshad ..He deserves to be in jail... He threatened everyone in front of the police... Fab5 actions are just worthy of suspension from college for few days its not jail worthy


They would not have let Navya died..?? So they did not get punished?

They were not even suspended..For Alya sending goons..Nandini was the one to be expelled..

Jail/No jail..No one of Fab5 got punished legally..
-bharti- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: miyova



If intending to kill is a crime,then ragging does not mean any better..

Remember? Manik did things to Nandini real bad than just ragging..


Miyova i uderstand your frustrations, fab5,s ragging or bullying was never acceptable but no one pursued legally against the bullying of fab 5. Its important to stand up in your own defence. These days in India laws have been changed n ragging is taken extremely seriously. Students can be rusticated n universities will be penalised for tolerating it. Its upto the CVs to give an explanation.
But the larger point is Harshad,s criminal actions n intentions are far far dangerous than all the fab5 acts put together. For me he doesnt show any remorse to any of his acts which is irredeemable.
TheFaerieQueen thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: miyova



Dont u think Manik has got a psycological problem? He tried to kill Harshad too..

And please dont say that Harshad used Navya..The reality is Navya is getting used..She willingly walks into his trap..As i said earlier Its consensual..

Manik was the one who came inside the drama room in search of Harshad..remember? So technically he forgot the restraining order first..

And about Fab5 evolving..yes..its a good thing..But earlier Dhruv would not be part of any bad things Fab5 did nor tried to stop them..however bad they may be..But now he seems to evolving too..😉

My point is that noone is Mahaan except Nandini..They are equals in their crime rates..So why send only one side to jail?



We aren't very sure here about the intent of Manik, he had a timer clicking away and he came back to check. And Manik did this as a reaction to what Harshad did (I am not justify the step, we are talking about intentions here).

When I said Harshad is using Navya, I was not talking about "The" act..it was consensual Yes. I am talking about the way he is leading Navya on. He is letting her live in a illusion that He is in love with her just so that he can use her. This is not consensual.

Manik didn't go to look for harshad and beat him up. He went in because he was worried for Nandini's safety. Their plan was not to beat up harshad, but to make him gloat and confess.

I still don't get who else needs to go to jail along with Harshad.
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
Harshad should be in jail for the date rape drugs, for beating up Raghav and Cabir with a whole group of other guys with hockey sticks -- So thank god he is locked up. I don't want someone using those drugs so casually to be roaming free on the street ..

Shahid wasn't going to die even without Navya and Nandini -- They all should be punished for bullying, yes.

And most importantly, Harshad is in jail for breaching the restrain order ...
Harshad should be in a mental asylum -- he cannot let go of his obsession and will keep ruining himself.

Unlike, fab5 who are showing development constantly and don't go out of their way to try to kill and maim others without being provoked with threat and danger to the people they care about.




Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".