The Marauders and James Moriarty feels - Page 2

Originally posted by: myvoiz

I think they had planned a different story...they must have changed it. This one was not very convincing [not matching KYY standards]and its placement was so abrupt..back in the jungle when Nandini had asked him I had not expected this kinda story/reason for revenge..not strong enough reason to harbour sooo much hatred against Manik. I also am feeling now the alien theory would not come up in the show. I might be wrong..but right now can't see them fitting in...let's c. Was this Harshad's entire story or there is more to it??

also I am curious as to what danger these two were facing? aliens??why doe he want to take away MANIK'S MUSIC FROM HIM? When did Cabir join them and how?

I forgot who were called Marauders? Lupin's story was..? was he a shape shifter? will have to read again.

P.S; This is the fourth time that Manik has hurt his hands, right? first in store room, then he hurt his finger, then on the stage and now this. how many times does his hands have to be wounded!

Harshad, what do I say about him? He is Manik's greatest foe. For me he's been lost ever since Musicana night, there is no redemption for him. I am still trying to understand what justifies his obsession to hurt Manik to this extent. What is exactly running through his head? What has led him to this point that he's gone beyond reasoning and absolutely cruel? For now all I've seen is blind anger which is meaningless. What are his reasons? He cannot see beyond his revenge and angst, which is all that runs in his mind. It's as if he has locked himself into a box of madness/obsession and thrown away the key. This way he can keep on living in his own delusional world. But for how long? Every limit he crosses makes him that more immune to the capability of actually seeing anything except for his need to avenge what Manik did to him. His hatred for Manik has become the pinnacle of his being.

Originally posted by: Medha.S

Ahhh, If Manik be James and Cabir be Sirius then Cabir will be Baba ka Best Man and MaNan ke child ka Godfather ... Wohoo! My friend be reading this and she went like, Sooo Harshad will be Snape? I had to whack her on the head because no insulting Snape like this,Just NO!
I already wrote a Harshad psychoanalysis on the AT. I hate Harshad ka character but he is an interesting one on the paper so can't help it.
Fab5 always gave me feels --- they are so tightly knit that Harshad might feel the need to break them up just to prove that they are no different from him and what he had with Manik. He just wants to show Manik that these people would leave him just like he did if it came to protect themselves and their benefit.Hence his frustration which lead to insanity, because hew couldn't get rid of the guilt, couldn't bring peace to himself by proving that what he did was natural and anyone would do it.

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake

Harshad as such when the show started was an interesting character, a grey character for me who leaned black. I was not too fond of his subterfuge and sneakiness back then especially since he projected the hero image to Navya and Nandini.

Harshad I believe has to have some sort of psychological issues coupled with the fact that Manik probably totally cut him out of his life post the meteor incident. We all know how Manik can be once he is mind is set and this probably made Harshad feel that he Harshad is the victim and Manik the villain.

I mentioned in the AT, that Harshad seems to have no attachment to anyone,both Navya and Nandini seem to be only pawns. chess pieces in his war against Manik and its all about Manik for him.

The two people who he is supposed to care about are Mukti and Alya and yet with Mukti, on one hand while he was ready to save her , on the other hand he seemed to have no qualms to help her over the edge. It makes you really wonder. As for Alya, while he does seem to care for her, he seems to have no qualms in hurting her friends in his quest to get Manik. Infact I would say the only attachment Harshad has is this fixation towards Manik. There has to be more to this story.

But he's become pretty irredeemable to me. I want to know his story but I have no sympathy.

The Fab5 have always been there for each other. I always found a method in their madness. They atleast really care for each other. Manik is so James to me😆, Cabir Sirius and Dhruv Lupin and Nandu Lily. I remember one of my earliest post on this forum, I called them a bunch of misfits masquerading as a pack of wolves but they are family. This is the family they have chosen,all from unstable homes finding a family in each other.