Harshad the bad guy or the catalyst?

.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Ufff yeh writing ka keera! Never seems to leave me alone!! 😆

Just the day I thought I'd spend my night flooding Niti's twitter feed, I felt like coming up with something that's SOOO not related to her- it is, in a way. Related to Nandini, more like. Okay never mind.

As the title says, it's about Harshad. Probably my first post on his character- just his character.

From the day he have saved Rishabh till today's episode, somehow, somewhere the inner workings of his mind have always been a mystery.

He has gone from being the shady, grey guy to an outright male version of Nina Sayers (Black Swan) minus the delusions.

The point of the post is, his role in the show. I don't believe he's just another 'bad guy' cause he's more than that. Much more.

I remember having fun comparing 'Harry Potter' characters with the characters of this show with Rafz. She just couldn't come up with a comparison for Harshad when I offered 'Tom Riddle' (not Voldemort).

You see the similarities, if you subtract a cold-blooded murderer, Harshad has a lot of Tom Riddle in him.

The guy who prefers solitariness to company, followers to friends, hatred to love, obsession to hard work and luck.

But once again, returning to the point- his role in the show- a catalyst.

He has been a catalyst without his knowing. Right from MaNan love story to Fab 5's new avatar.

A lot of people have wondered and guessed correctly as to why was he being so nice to both the girls. Let's just say that his major target have always been Nandini!

He must have heard from someone that this girl has dared to punch Manik in front of the college and he had immediately concluded that she could be his biggest weapon against Fab 5. What he didn't expect was Manik's obsession regarding Nandu- but it didn't take the smartass too long to guess that too- and it only came as an unexpected bonus!

He formed the band NH3 because he wanted to keep Nandu at his side- I can bet that back then he was only tolerating Navya for her sake. He wanted to use Manik's object of obsession against him. He saw her as a potential threat for Aalya and Manik's relationship and got the perfect opportunity to use it when she hid inside the storeroom and he made sure that they both end up at the same place.

His demeanour started changing from the moment intra-college competition was nearing and his personality took a 90 degree turn when Musicana came knocking at the doors. Obsession took over his rational thinking and he resorted to spying over Fab 5.

He didn't even realize what the consequences of his actions would be.

But at the end of the day, he again became the catalyst who made Fab 5 confront each other on their secrets.

Now I want to see how he'll take the loss? Will he lash out at Nandu? Or will he keep his calm and think of something bigger?

What if he comes to know that Manik and Dhruv are in love with Nandu? I'm sure he'll end up doing something that'll again make him the cupid for MaNan.



Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

4.3k

Users

13

Likes

66

Frequent Posters

Jiyagulabi_26 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
He must have heard from someone that this girl has dared to punch Manik in front of the college and he had immediately concluded that she could be his biggest weapon against Fab 5. What he didn't expect was Manik's obsession regarding Nandu- but it didn't take the smartass too long to guess that too- and it only came as an unexpected bonus!
WOW shelly 😲 I haven't thought on such notes.. I thought he is jerk n yes he is mysterious. The way he said nandini saved by manik or here is new couple nandini n manik or his expressions when store room door was opened..
I m now remembering all these
😲
Thanksss!!!!!
Edited by addictedlove - 10 years ago
mi_cheeky_me... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Yes! He might tell Dhruv about Manan.. Oops! I wrote dis line directly.. Nyways Shelly gr8 post...👏
AnamikaSJain thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
You are so right! Why didn't I think of this before?
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: addictedlove

He must have heard from someone that this girl has dared to punch Manik in front of the college and he had immediately concluded that she could be his biggest weapon against Fab 5. What he didn't expect was Manik's obsession regarding Nandu- but it didn't take the smartass too long to guess that too- and it only came as an unexpected bonus!
WOW shelly 😲 I haven't thought on such notes.. I thought he is jerk n yes he is mysterious. The way he said nandini saved by manik or here is new couple nandini n manik or his expressions when store room door was opened..
I m now remembering all these
😲
Thanksss!!!!!


This show gives a lot of scope for psychoanalysis- and Harshad's and Manik's character are two of the MOST interesting characters of this show.

Although Manik's actions makes it a bit easy for me to read him, I'm too curious about Harshad right now. The whole 'Band of brothers' history, his 'secret', his past including Mukti...*sigh*.

Harshad Saxena is mystery through and through.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Harshad is not a villian or a bad guy, yes but he makes you recoil of his certain actions.
The thing is with him he is not aware of his obsession withe destroying fab5. I do feel that it has to be because of something big but he is playing them with their rules and using innocent by-standers like Navya . He knows what he is doing is wrong, he tries making up for it but to him end justifies the means . He is overzealous and is stepping out and doing things which he in saner times will never do.

While we see fab5 , kind of on the brink of changing and maturing , he seems to be the only one hell bend on screwing himself. He just doesn't want to let it go. He is holding on to his past so much that he is not caring that his present and future are getting destroyed.

He is falling in the vortex of revenge unnecessarily. It makes it sad though but the fact that he knows what is happening to Navya and yet carrying with it, gives an impression of loathing for him. But core of him is still good , just shrinking.
BoxedIn thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Ooh good post!
Far from being a 'villain', Harshad, to me, has always been this agent of chaos who is going to be the reason the Fab-5 will step out of that self-centred cocoon of theirs and grow. His is the back-story which intrigues me the most, not the random meteor-starfish-flower sci-fi shit that they keep hinting at in the Dhruv-Rishabh story.

This guy grew up with the Fab-5, or at least MAnik and Dhruv. He knows them. He is the one who, when he's in his element, reads Manik the best. I'm dying to know the hows and the whens and the whats of the Band of Brothers. What happened between him and Mukti? Harshad's obsession with revenge has somehow always seemed to stem from a sense of being wronged- it's like he wants to break them up, isolate them, because that's what they did to him. Was it all a terrible misunderstanding? Or was it some selfless act of Manik's gone wrong? (You never know with the Baba and his idiocy, *sigh*). Does he know about Dhruv and his attacks? And I still think Harshad went soft with Cabir. He could have simply released that video without telling anyone about it, and watched the collapse happen. Instead he told Cabir: love or Fab5, choose. Didn't Mukti face the same choice with him once? & isn't Manik in the somewhat same dilemma now? Intriguing.

I always got the impression that Harshad does not enjoy the pain of others like the Fab5 did in their bullying days. On different occasions he has shown himself to be sensitive, helpful and conscientious towards others. But this veneer of civilisation simply drops when it comes to the Fab5. Now that level of hate can only arise when you believe yourself to be in the right. So, the question remains, just what had happened back then, dammit? I want to know so bad. I don't know if Harshad is going to self-destruct in this single-minded quest for revenge, but I do think he's perfectly aware of his goals and NH3, his music, even his sister, everything of his own is now only a means to this end. Which is...worrying. I quite like the guy.

Edited by BoxedIn - 10 years ago
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Harshad is not a villian or a bad guy, yes but he makes you recoil of his certain actions.

The thing is with him he is not aware of his obsession withe destroying fab5. I do feel that it has to be because of something big but he is playing them with their rules and using innocent by-standers like Navya . He knows what he is doing is wrong, he tries making up for it but to him end justifies the means . He is overzealous and is stepping out and doing things which he in saner times will never do.

While we see fab5 , kind of on the brink of changing and maturing , he seems to be the only one hell bend on screwing himself. He just doesn't want to let it go. He is holding on to his past so much that he is not caring that his present and future are getting destroyed.

He is falling in the vortex of revenge unnecessarily. It makes it sad though but the fact that he knows what is happening to Navya and yet carrying with it, gives an impression of loathing for him. But core of him is still good , just shrinking.


First and foremost- TAKE A BOW girl! 👏 👏 👏

I read your comment on @GudaKesha's post and I ABSO-F****NG-LUTELY LOVED IT!!! 🤗 🤗

Coming to your reply- agree with everything- esp the last line. His obsession with defeating Fab 5, breaking them and breaking Manik especially is what's making him cross all sorts of lines. NH3 is a band which is formed out of hatred for Fab 5 and not love for music.

He is on the same page as Mukti- clinging onto the past, taking it as a reminder so that the fire of hatred and anger would never cease.

I have always maintained that this level of bitterness and obsession is U-N-H-E-A-L-T-H-Y. But what I want to convey through my post is that, he's not just the cliched villain, he is more of a catalyst- without his knowledge. He always ends up doing something that gives a push to a situation- right from attaching crackers to Nandini's kurti to leaking Cabir's video.
fan145 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
I wish harshad end the seperation track too..bcz nw since he saw nandu and manik together ..i donno vthr he heard her ..bt he might join the dots and end in palnning somethng bigger vch vud at the end bring nandu and manik together...
BoxedIn thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Unresed on 1.
Harshad is one favourite of mine. Thank you for this. :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".