A request to the DhruNi/Dhruv fans - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

5.3k

Users

23

Likes

215

Frequent Posters

.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: annboleyn

I had actually never paid any attention to Dhruni thread but went there today. Oh dear!!!!! Maybe they are very young coz I saw a thread where some girls were threatening to quit or something! Ah the follies of youth...black and white. Experience will add more shades to their life palette. Hopefully.


I won't blame it on age, it's the perception.

Even you have seen girls as young as 16 or 17 putting across their thoughts which speaks volumes of their mental maturity!

Take us for example- all self-confessed MaNan bhakts, does that mean that we only want their scenes to be shown? Of course not! We want growth in every character, we want to see the emotional turmoil that RaghBir are going through, we want to know what made Harshad hate Maanik and Fab 5 so much- herein lies the difference, you see.


meen123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Aditi-

Nandu had a very "in awe" thing about Dhruv initially which subsequently died down because she reached a plateau with him and never wanted to seek anything more. this was because of lot of factors, their awkwardness, her sympathy for him, the curiosity regarding Manik and I guess she just finally saw him as her Friend. Her underlining word - "friends" ,has been very emphatic .

Her re-inforcing the word again and again shows that this is all she seeks from him. Right now she is drawing closer to Manik, now even if he is not in the picture her thoughts do go to him like when Navya mentioned the gay factor , she zoned out Dhruv and was focusing on Manik. The unease over his status with Alya and his dismissal of the hug as mistake. She is realizing the unsaid between them .

I really don't think she would dwell more about Dhruv, because she has him slotted already. This is Dhruv's angst. Manik-Nandu angst would come because of lot of factors, these two might be aware of whatever is between them but acting on it is disastrous and they know it. NH3 and fab5, Dhruv, Alya , Stars... there is so many unknown factors which will test their union.

Ultimately the angst would be for them to put a name or define what they feel for each other.

The love triangle was never there atleast for me. Fireflies were very conclusive. The triangle of Dhruv-Nandu-Manik for me means, how their lives are intertwined with each other and the impact of one event in someone's life affect the other two. Hence Yarriyan.



this...thank you for putting this so nicely

i'm not feeling any love triangle here and that is why i'm liking this show very much..she has always called him a friend
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#43
Amazing post, Shelly! 👏
And I agree with @diva that there is so much more to the show and in particularly, there is so much more to the characters of Dhruv and Manik than just which one of them will be the endgame with Nandu. I just knew Nandini-Manik will be the endgame since the first epi and still enjoy the scenes between DhruNi because frankly when I started I couldn't care less. I started watching in the first place due to the awesome dynamics between MaRuv and this special bond we hardly get to see in today's world. Dhruv, as a character is so much more and his development has not even started yet. With every new revelation, he becomes more interesting and his mystery is the biggest and most protected secret on the show which surrounds and connects everyone and everything. We haven't even started yet and this whole story of Manik and Dhruv is what attracted me to watch the show in the first place, everything else I started to like along the way.
All these mysteries and questions and intrigue over these two and what they are, who they are,how they came to be what they have become, how they came in each others lives, how they became whatever they are to each other, was Manik there when the accident happened? Or was he there after it? Did Manik ask for his wish the same day the accident happened? Did Manik asked for a wish from the same shooting star that did whatever it did to Dhruv? Why Manik was making wishes upon stars? Was he lonely? Were Manik and Harshad friends and Dhruv came in between them? Were Harshad and Dhruv friends and Manik came in between and did Manik help Dhruv through the same kind of attack the same day they met or were they friends before the attacks started? Why are Manik and Dhruv so close? What did Manik do to gain so much trust and faith from Dhruv? Why so much love and understanding between them? Why are they only able to be themselves with each other? Why is Dhruv only comfortable opening up and joking around with Manik? Is it because he already trusts him enough to let him see the most vulnerable side of him regularly? Why can Manik only be openly and frankly overbearingly caring and loving towards Dhruv and reverts back to being all cool and calm when it comes to others? Why does he get so hyperactive when it comes to anything Dhruv related? Was Harshad unable to help Dhruv that day but Manik was there and helped Dhruv to deal with it? Did Manik see something? Why wasn't Manik affected like Dhruv if he was there with him? What did Manik do to help Dhruv? Why can't anyone else help Dhruv to calm down? How many attacks does Dhruv get every year and just how many times did Dhruv and Manik sat there overcoming Dhruv's attacks together? Is Manik just being optimistic about the day when he says that 'the day' makes him happy? Is it because that day was the first time he met Dhruv or because that was the day he asked for a wish? So for him it is a lucky day? Why is Manik so protective and frankly Mother-like when it comes to Dhruv? Is it because of the attacks and how only he can bring Dhruv back to his senses? Is it because he feels that whatever happened to Dhruv was because of him, because he was there and couldn't do anything? or because he feels guilty for wishing for someone like Dhruv and the star literally doing something to Dhruv and bringing him to Manik and making him unable to be helped by anyone else but Manik?

😆 Sorry, loads of questions there. But seriously, these things are what made me watch the show in the first place, what made me wait for it everyday so I could get another piece of the puzzle, I came to love everything else along the way.

I would hate for their characters to be reduced to just boys fighting for love --- There is so much here to be still known about them and understand them as individuals and their relationship and its origin, its basis. After all, Manik Baba wished upon a star and got a 'Dhruv' -- the 'fixed star' -- Manik's own personal compass to show him the way. To fill him with hope, and a new purpose, giving him a new objective, something precious to care, protect from the world and shower all his love onto -- Something Manik's parents too had but did not care about, could not understand the importance of and lost.So Manik does not intend to lose his own personal star -- Dhruv is a special snowflake, Manik knows it, I know it, you know it -- so seriously, chill!

Edited by Medha.S - 10 years ago
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Zaya.priyanka

Shelly.. Wonderful post...

I just love ur sigggi..He/she soo cute and adorable... I become a ball of mush when it comes to baby animals... 😳...Ur pet???😃


Same here. 😳

Well I have a pet but the pic's not his'. I have a lab of 1-and-a-half-years old named 'Prongs'. 😆
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Aditi-

Nandu had a very "in awe" thing about Dhruv initially which subsequently died down because she reached a plateau with him and never wanted to seek anything more. this was because of lot of factors, their awkwardness, her sympathy for him, the curiosity regarding Manik and I guess she just finally saw him as her Friend. Her underlining word - "friends" ,has been very emphatic .

Her re-inforcing the word again and again shows that this is all she seeks from him. Right now she is drawing closer to Manik, now even if he is not in the picture her thoughts do go to him like when Navya mentioned the gay factor , she zoned out Dhruv and was focusing on Manik. The unease over his status with Alya and his dismissal of the hug as mistake. She is realizing the unsaid between them .

I really don't think she would dwell more about Dhruv, because she has him slotted already. This is Dhruv's angst. Manik-Nandu angst would come because of lot of factors, these two might be aware of whatever is between them but acting on it is disastrous and they know it. NH3 and fab5, Dhruv, Alya , Stars... there is so many unknown factors which will test their union.

Ultimately the angst would be for them to put a name or define what they feel for each other.

The love triangle was never there atleast for me. Fireflies were very conclusive. The triangle of Dhruv-Nandu-Manik for me means, how their lives are intertwined with each other and the impact of one event in someone's life affect the other two. Hence Yarriyan.


You never cease to amaze me with your 'way with words' genie! 👏 👏 👏
N_Niya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#46
Sabse badi baat hai...just bcoz I love Manik, I won't bash Dhruv's character...they r fictional characters...we have nothing against any of it...still some people r trying to make a mess out of it!
It's surprising how they've actually turned this into a fan-war!
I used to watch a show named Ek Mutthi Aasmaan It had a couple named Raghav Kalpana...I used to like them so much...CVs actually seperated them..I was disheartened & actually made an exit from the forum & stopped watching the show!
I suggest Manik bashers to do the same as they can't tolerate Manik being the main lead & getting importance of being it; as it is the truth, however it seems doesn't matter..
sir me dard ho to doctor dikhaana chaiye ya phir dawaa le leni chaiye...chilla chillaake dusroke sir me dard karwaane se apna dard ghatega nai! 🥱
Grow up Manik bashers!...get well soon! 🥱
Edited by N_Niya - 10 years ago
.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: nyxx

A BIG HUG to you Shelly for posting this!
It was ver much needed especially because none of us want this forum to be filled with Fan-wars. Cmon you people, we are much above that. INDEED WE ARE! Or should I say, 'we should be'? 🤔


Lets enjoy the show, and the beautiful roller-coaster it is providing us...and truly, appreciate the character-build up of each character and couple it is giving us...I am sure the writers know what they are doing - lets not trivial their minds with our bickerings. Its not worth it, you will only end up ruining the essence of this show.

JUST what I have been trying to convey- a fictional show is NOT worth your tears and heartbreaks and obsession!

and especially with the last few episodes, I dont even know how "Dhruv" or "Dhruni" fans CANNOT drool and swoon over Manik or MaNan. Er...personal tastes I guess. Let's not start on that. 😳



.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: N_Niya

Sabse badi baat hai...just bcoz I love Manik, I won't bash Dhruv's character...they r fictional characters...we have nothing against any of it...still some people r trying to make a mess out of it!

It's surprising how they've actually turned this into a fan-war!
I used to watch a show named Ek Mutthi Aasmaan It had a couple named Raghav Kalpana...I used to like them so much...CVs actually seperated them..I was disheartened & actually made an exit from the forum & stopped watching the show!
I suggest Manik bashers to do the same as they can't tolerate Manik being the main lead & getting importance of being it; as it is the truth, however it seems doesn't matter..
sir me dard ho to doctor dikhaana chaiye ya phir dawaa le leni chaiye...chilla chillaake dusroke sir me dard karwaane se apna dard ghatega nai! 🥱
Grow up Manik bashers!...get well soon! 🥱


Ohh my baby...you be REBELLIOUS. 😎 😆

But you do have a point. Even I quit watching something if it doesn't goes the way I want it to go- why waste my time and emotions to wallow over something that FICTIONAL?




SankiPagal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
Man i have been watching the precap again and again... i am not able to get over the "I will shine for you" Dialog and Manik's soft look.. Hayyyeee... Its already Monday... 6:30 come soon.. :D
N_Niya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: shelly_08


Ohh my baby...you be REBELLIOUS. 😎 😆

But you do have a point. Even I quit watching something if it doesn't goes the way I want it to go- why waste my time and emotions to wallow over something that FICTIONAL?




Show ke CVs humpe hassrahe honge...k dekho kya haal banadia humne innka...jung chhidgayi hai...na show dekhpaate hai na chhodpaate hai...ek obsessed Manik ke chakkar me Dhruv fans saare Manik bangaye!!! 😆 😆
Shreyu tu hi bata ab ye kahaka logic hai...Dhruv fans ko dhruv ki tarah silent ho jaana chaiye tha...dhruv ke fan hote hue v Manik ki tarah dusroka jeena haraam karne pe tule hue hai!!! 😆 😆
Dhruv k ideals se motivated log Manik banjaaye ye to unacceptable hai!!! 😆
Edited by N_Niya - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".