--Of Drunk Courage, Needed Revelations and Cruel Truths -- - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

3k

Users

11

Likes

57

Frequent Posters

Cat. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Medha, I honestly even doubt that the rest of the Fab5 know that Manik sent Dhruv for these rescue acts, its like Manik allows his true self to be shown only with Dhruv and now Nandini, as in his friends know that he cares for them, but they don't know that he cares for other people. Even Alya, I don't think has gotten to see this other side of Manik and I guess that is the reason for the most part for their relationship to fail, because the real Manik was never engaged in that relationship. And with Nandini's arrival into Manik's life, the real Manik does not want to live in the shadows of the Monster Manik. Nandini has made Manik want to live in the mainstream of society and not the fringes.

Edited by Catatonic_Cat - 10 years ago
13thwish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Catatonic_Cat

Medha, I honestly even doubt that the rest of the Fab5 know that Manik sent Dhruv for these rescue acts, its like Manik allows his true self to be shown only with Dhruv and now Nandini, as in his friends know that he cares for them, but they don't know that he cares for other people. Even Alya, I don't think has gotten to see this other side of Manik and I guess that is the reason for the most part for their relationship to fail, because the real Manik was never engaged in that relationship. And with Nandini's arrival into Manik's life, the real Manik does not want to live in the shadows of the Monster Manik. Nandini has made Manik want to live in the mainstream of society and not the fringes.



I'm quite sure that the rest of Fab5 do not know of these secret rescue missions of Dhruv-Manik..
In the first episode itself, when Cabir/Mukti were shooting that video of Shahid they genuinely expected him to jump and were surprised/annoyed when he was rescued by the girls.. So obviously they had no clue Dhruv was on that terrace too and that shahid would've been rescued regardless..
Also, Manik himself would never want them to know because the entire illusion of Fab5 rests on the notion of Manik's ruthlessness and invincibility and they need this to feel secure. It would defeat his entire purpose if they ever saw his true self..
As for Alya, I think she's always been attracted to Manik's projected image of strength and indomitable will.. If she ever saw the chinks in his armor it would shatter her confidence in him.. so again there was no question of him ever letting her see his vulnerable side..
Of course Manik and Nandu finding and loving each other was inevitable.. he brought out the warrior in her and she the man in him.. they found themselves only after they found each other.. Aaah.. Fates and the CVs.. Geniuses both 👏

P.S: @Medha.. lovely post.. so articulate yet detailed and descriptive.. well done!👍🏼

Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
girl you are so so good with your words. please keep writing. i might come here daily just to read your posts.
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: .AbhIyalicious.

girl you are so so good with your words. please keep writing. i might come here daily just to read your posts.

Thanks so much! 🤗 That is like an effin' big compliment! I will definitely try ...
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Catatonic_Cat

Medha, I honestly even doubt that the rest of the Fab5 know that Manik sent Dhruv for these rescue acts, its like Manik allows his true self to be shown only with Dhruv and now Nandini, as in his friends know that he cares for them, but they don't know that he cares for other people. Even Alya, I don't think has gotten to see this other side of Manik and I guess that is the reason for the most part for their relationship to fail, because the real Manik was never engaged in that relationship. And with Nandini's arrival into Manik's life, the real Manik does not want to live in the shadows of the Monster Manik. Nandini has made Manik want to live in the mainstream of society and not the fringes.

I know, yeah! Cabir looked surprised when two girls came to save him. But, seriously they don't come off as people who would be fine with having someone's blood on their hands -- Maybe at that time, when all of them apart from Dhruv were seen as heartless bullies planning to see someone kill themselves. But, just like how Manik was seen as a cruel monster, how we didn't know that Manik was not planning to see someone die and now that he cleared the confusion, same goes for all the rest of them too no! We don't know -- before Manik's revelation, there was always that stigma due to all their acts even though after some time his personality clashed with the Manik of before.It is true for Cabir,Mukti and Alya too. We just don't know -- I honestly think they knew they were not going to kill anyone.

Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: 13thwish



I'm quite sure that the rest of Fab5 do not know of these secret rescue missions of Dhruv-Manik..
In the first episode itself, when Cabir/Mukti were shooting that video of Shahid they genuinely expected him to jump and were surprised/annoyed when he was rescued by the girls.. So obviously they had no clue Dhruv was on that terrace too and that shahid would've been rescued regardless..
Also, Manik himself would never want them to know because the entire illusion of Fab5 rests on the notion of Manik's ruthlessness and invincibility and they need this to feel secure. It would defeat his entire purpose if they ever saw his true self..
As for Alya, I think she's always been attracted to Manik's projected image of strength and indomitable will.. If she ever saw the chinks in his armor it would shatter her confidence in him.. so again there was no question of him ever letting her see his vulnerable side..
Of course Manik and Nandu finding and loving each other was inevitable.. he brought out the warrior in her and she the man in him.. they found themselves only after they found each other.. Aaah.. Fates and the CVs.. Geniuses both 👏

P.S: @Medha.. lovely post.. so articulate yet detailed and descriptive.. well done!👍🏼


More like the puppy in him 😆... Ugh, I honestly don't know why people dont find him cute ... Manik Baba, You be Damn Cute!

Thanks so much, really!😳

shibz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
Hey.. I'd made a similar post..but you have elaborated it all & well put!
I also don't think Fab 5 are as cruel as to let someone die! It may have been their plan always! They know they Bully for fun..Besides to feel safe themselves.. They want to scare the world so nobody has the courage to harm them. But to let ppl die for silly reasons is so not Human!

So Cabir standing below & making a video of Shahid expressing his wish to see him suicide simply means that he wants ppl to believe that they can be so cruel!
True that the entire group do not know Manik & Dhruv the way Manik & Dhruv know eachother! But they know very well that Dhruv is the only guy who does not get involved in their pranks so he'd rather be that saving friend! Manik is still the cold, ruthless Manik to the world that Fab5 knows him as but death is something extreme & they will agree when he says they don't believe in forcing ppl to die! Whatever the world thinks of them..within them there are relationships..friendships..love..understanding..warmth.


I want to mention 2 more scenes..

1-When Rishab jumps into the pool to save the pen & Nandini cries that he doesn't know to swim..
We do see Dhruv standing there at the side & probably if Harshad hadn't come to the picture he'd jump in the pool himself to save the boy!

2-Recently when Manik trips Nandu off which leaves her head bleeding..he looks at Dhruv for help..We assumed that he probably did not like that Dhruv broke his friendship with Nandu.. but going by the new discovered truth..It will be safe to say that Manik expected Dhruv to help like always as Dhruv has been assigned that job to save ppl who Manik or the group puts in trouble😆


..Drishya.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
That was so nice a post...Please do write analysis everyday..I love reading them.You write so well..😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".