Why is this forum have Majorly MaNan lovers? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

7.3k

Users

27

Likes

166

Frequent Posters

Strikhedonia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#51
Well... I'm not a MaNan shipper nor DhruNi... I never watched the first few episode of KY2, so I don't know about the bullying and all! Honestly speaking, I don't feel connected to MaNan!

So, I can't answer your question.😛

But I want to ask you something, "If you are not a MaNan shipper, why do you write on MaNan?" I'm curious to know the answer!😳
ForeverForU thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: charminggenie

The difference between Manik and other tv characters like ASR, Asad etc is that he is a teen , he is at an age where he can get a pass for immaturity .He unlike others internalizes Nandu's perspective not just wrt to their equation but with others as well. This is his biggest plus.


He is not a grown-ass man who ridiculous a grown up adult woman .

He is not changing in a matter of seconds or because it's love. He is evolving because he is acknowledging the changing dynamics, new experiences and new emotions "age" and "growing up brings.

Similarly, fab5 need to grow up and realize that they cannot grow up to be bullies not even if they are labelled as broken kids. Hence this story.




@bold totally agree👍🏼..they all are still very young..growing up,experiencing new things...they still can make mistakes and of course learn from it
Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#53
Lol this is probably my first post in this forum 😆...I will be honest, I did not watch the show regularly from start...but yeah I am quite updated about the incidents that took place...and have seen the summaries in weekends and all 😆...now I watch this show regularly though 😆...coming to your topic...initially I did not like the Fab 5 group as a whole...what they did with Shahid, which almost drove him to the verge of committing suicide was downright cruel...and then started Manik's torture fest with Nandini...he bullied her, ragged her...even made her act like his spot...I seriously hated that Manik...but I very strongly feel that Nandini should also have protested...but I get it, she was new to this whole environment and standing up against a group of 5 was no mean feat...the first time I saw Manik's other side was when he took care of Dhruv after his attack...it showed that he really has a caring side behind this whole bullying nature...the similar attacks of Rishabh and Dhruv had brought Nandini and Manik close as it was a common ground and they could understand each other's concern regarding that...I guess that was the start of MaNan...Manik , I think is presently attracted towards Nandini, he does show his concern towards her...but its not love yet...before MaNan starts at all...he needs to really beg for forgiveness from Nandini, for all the cruelties that he had meted out to her...at first when DhruNi was shown , I actually liked it...I liked their cuteness...the way they secretly met, their friendship...discovering unknown feelings for each other...it was like a budding romance...dreamy, flowery 😆...but then Dhruv decided to end the friendship for Manik...and we started to get lesser and lesser DhruNi scenes...and now DhruNi seems to have fizzled out...so my point is...since now we are being given high doses of MaNan its very obvious more and more people are getting attracted towards them...also I feel MaNan has a very strong storyline...Manik a dark , broken "monster" who has a heart , who does care about people, but likes to keep it hidden, may be cause of his bitter childhood, may be he thinks showing concern is a weakness...and on the other hand is Nandini, a sweet girl, who is naive and innocent and also very caring...its like darkness and light meeting together...may be Nandini's nature will help Manik come out of his demonic shell...I wont say DhruNi did not have a potential story, but it would have been very ordinary...it was cute but there was no fire between them and I like a bit of passion 😉
Whom do I ship? currently I guess I am shifting towards MaNan...I am not any of the actors fan, so shipping for a character only because of the actor, is not a choice for me here...I am only thinking of shipping them cause of the potential story they have...I strongly believe no one is absolutely "white" , we all have grey shades...sometimes some people are a tad darker then the rest of us...and Manik is one of them...but there is hope of his redemption...and I can see that he is changing...do you think Dhruv is all white? even he had only come to the rescue of Nandini, but where was he when Shahid was bullied or when Navya was locked in a trash can? so his concern is also centred around Fab 5 and Nandini...I guess there are flaws in everyone of us ...and there are flaws in each of the characters of the show...but then these flaws make them special...😛
I am not here to convince you to ship Manan...after all it is personal choice...I just shared my thoughts on the matter ...no offence 😳
Edited by Wrackspurt - 10 years ago
AyaNi.CabIni thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: Wrackspurt

Lol this is probably my first post in this forum 😆...I will be honest, I did not watch the show regularly from start...but yeah I am quite updated about the incidents that took place...and have seen the summaries in weekends and all 😆...now I watch this show regularly though 😆...coming to your topic...initially I did not like the Fab 5 group as a whole...what they did with Shahid, which almost drove him to the verge of committing suicide was downright cruel...and then started Manik's torture fest with Nandini...he bullied her, ragged her...even made her act like his spot...I seriously hated that Manik...but I very strongly feel that Nandini should also have protested...but I get it, she was new to this whole environment and standing up against a group of 5 was no mean feat...the first time I saw Manik's other side was when he took care of Dhruv after his attack...it showed that he really has a caring side behind this whole bullying nature...the similar attacks of Rishabh and Dhruv had brought Nandini and Manik close as it was a common ground and they could understand each other's concern regarding that...I guess that was the start of MaNan...Manik , I think is presently attracted towards Nandini, he does show his concern towards her...but its not love yet...before MaNan starts at all...he needs to really beg for forgiveness from Nandini, for all the cruelties that he had meted out to her...at first when DhruNi was shown , I actually liked it...I liked their cuteness...the way they secretly met, their friendship...discovering unknown feelings for each other...it was like a budding romance...dreamy, flowery 😆...but then Dhruv decided to end the friendship for Manik...and we started to get lesser and lesser DhruNi scenes...and now DhruNi seems to have fizzled out...so my point is...since now we are being given high doses of MaNan its very obvious more and more people are getting attracted towards them...also I feel MaNan has a very strong storyline...Manik a dark , broken "monster" who has a heart , who does care about people, but likes to keep it hidden, may be cause of his bitter childhood, may be he thinks showing concern is a weakness...and on the other hand is Nandini, a sweet girl, who is nave and innocent and also very caring...its like darkness and light meeting together...may be Nandini's nature will help Manik come out of his demonic shell...I wont say DhruNi did not have a potential story, but it would have been very ordinary...tit was cute but there was no fire between them and I like a bit of passion 😉 Whom do I ship? currently I guess I am shifting towards MaNan...I am not any of the actors fan, so shipping for a character only because of the actor, is not a choice for me here...I am only thinking of shipping them cause of the potential story they have...I strongly believe no one is absolutely "white" , we all have grey shades...sometimes some people are a tad darker then the rest of us...and Manik is one of them...but there is hope of his redemption...and I can see that he is changing...do you think Dhruv is all white? even he had only come to the rescue of Nandini, but where was he when Shahid was bullied or when Navya was locked in a trash can? so his concern is also centred around Fab 5 and Nandini...I guess there are flaws in everyone of us ...and there are flaws in each of the characters of the show...but then these flaws make them special...😛

I am not here to convince you to ship Manan...after all it is personal choice...I just shared my thoughts on the matter ...no offence 😳



Wow. Nice post❤️. ditto for the passion part❤️
ArchRM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#55
I ❤️ Manik

Mainly because he is NOT anti-feminist...
Whatever he does it's for his dear one's happiness (either it's bullying or being harsh)
He doesn't knw the value of family, he's not aware of mothers love, there's no one to guide him & show the right path... despite of his personal problems... he love his friends... he believe them as his family... he finds his happiness in his friends...he is back-bone of Fab-5... he gave so much of love he deserves to be loved...
For outer reality he is a Monster but inside he is like a broken kid... craving for love.. craving for happiness...
He may look like a rude person but his heart is like Ice-cream it melts for true love & honesty...

diva82 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#56
I didn't ship anyone at the beginning, not even Dhruni. I was just enjoying the show.
Yes, it was hard for me to digest what Manik did to Nandu but I remember cheering for her when she punched him.
I was and still am watching just for entertainment purposes and I love how they are showing how a bully is actually a victim himself/herself.
Yes I am shipping Manan now not because of their chemistry, yes that's bonus but because how they are changing slowly and how they are growing and how it is affecting them and others around them. It's a beautiful written concept and I'm enjoying every bit of it.
Affinity thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#57
See that fact is, I don't like bullies. I actually am a person who advocates no bullying and discrimination.
So at first, I really didn't like Manik. I didn't find him that hot either.
But why I like Manik is that he isn't just a 2dimensional character. Many people hate Manik because they only see him as the popular guy/bully who only goes soft when Nandini or fab5 are around.
I'm not going to defend him and say it's alright for him to do that or that I like him due to his softer side only.
Why I like Manik, is that from a young age, he had to grow up soon. Between what Nyonika's ways as well as needing to take care of your best friend whenever he had an attack, Manik was forced to grow up. People always talk about how grown up Nandini is, but people fail to see that Manik is the parallel to that exactly (other than the just the direct parallel of them being the caretakers of the dhruv and risabh attacks). And due to those things, he has to appear confident, confident enough that no one ever takes benefit of him, or confident enough for him to protect his friends. And although he used the bully route, I think for him it was a facade. To hurt people before they can hurt you. And seeing the real him outside that facade, but also realising why he does have that facade is what attracted me to him.

Why I ship Manan is because Manik and Nandini are always the caretakers of their groups/families. When they are together, they are like children again. Fighting, being petty, helping each other under the I hate you facade. They both understand each other, albeit begrudgingly, because of their own experiences but still don't understand each other because of their opposite personalities.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".