Predictions: Reasons behind faking drowning death

Hey everyone, I was thinking while trying to fall asleep yesterday (after Jan 3rd episode aired) what the raz could be behind the "great" deception about Sudha and Miu being dead.

Perhaps the scenario went something like this:

Panchaat ruling that Mithvi relationship turn into one of marriage (this could have something to do with Prithvi being left on steps of mundir and the family he is from (perhaps Pandit ji actually knows who's son he is) or perhaps because Ramu might have been insisting after taking him from there that he thinks of Prithvi being his son and going to be raised as such and they(panchaat) wanted to ensure this so they say he must make him a son by marriage (hence Mithvi's childhood marriage). Perhaps he agreed to this ruling without letting Sudha know and perhaps that is why she was upset about it being an educated girl from Delhi, (apparantely that's where they met and fell in love) she did not believe nor support childhood marriages. They had an argument about the panchaat ruling and and he said he has given his word which means everything to him and and he can't go back on it but she says she will never accept the ruling , yatta yatta...more fighting and perhaps the only resolution to this that Ramu could come up with while still saving face was to make up the great lie that Sudha and Miu were dead (this would explain why she took Miu with her). Perhaps they planned on enacting a fight so others could hear (namely Bhabi and elders of the family as Lakhu would have been to young) so that she could run away in front of everyone and "pretend" to drown in the river.

OR perhaps Ramu's older brother was Sarpanch or something at the time and he had arranged the wedding between Mithvi after some ruling by Panchaat and somehow Ramu couldn't go against his brother/family as it was about their family izzit etc. Perhaps the thought that Miu and Sudha died because of his decision played heavy on his heart and mind which left him paralyzed. To keep the family izzit perhaps that is why Ramu and Sudha still faked the drowning which could be why Kalki blames Miu for the whole thing (her hubby being paralyzed and perhaps her losing her status of the wife of the goan's Sarpanch). That's just what was going thru my head as I couldn't sleep last night. What do you guys think?



Edited to add:

Well I watched the epi (thanks to online videos😆) and the only difference I have to add to above now is was it Sudha that did not agree to the ruling of the Panchaat. Does this mean that the wedding didn't happen or does this mean she tried to absolve the childhood wedding after it had already taken place after the Panchaat ruling? Then if this is the case then why is Miu to blame for everything? Why is Ramu's older brother paralyzed and Kalki blames Miu for it? Why would everyone hate Sudha for that? Just for going against the ruling of the panchaat, they would still hate her 20 years later, even after they think she is dead? I just don't get it...

The only thing that has cleared up so far is that Miu is in fact Ramu's daughter and now everyone knows this and the fact that Sudha and Miu are both alive and kicking. What was also cleared was that Ramu was aware of this fact and not something he was blind to. So we still have so many questions left unanswered...



Edited again to add this:

Here are just a sampling of some questions still left unanswered:

-Why does Kalki blame them (Sudha and Miu) for everything?
-How did the bellman (Kalki bhabi's hubby) become paralyzed?
-How is this paralysis related to what happened 20 years ago?
-Why didn't Sudha just leave the village with Miu if she didn't agree to the childhood marriage?
-Why stage their deaths instead?
-What else is behind what happened 20 years ago, or was it only because of Mithvi's marriage?
-Did Ramu lie to save/protect Miu and Sudha because he loved them?
-Or did he lie about their deaths to save his own image or that of his families?
-Did they not tell Miu about it because it was for her own protection? (I mean apparently Sudha was supposedly dying when Miu went on this quest to bring her mom's hubby back so shouldn't she have said something to her about her dad?)
-Did Ramu do it because he choose duty over family happiness and love or in fact because of love and the need to protect them? (I have always said since the beginning that Ramu knows they are alive and that he is not acknowledging Miu as his daughter because he is protecting her and Sudha from something - is this still true? - i question it because he said he choose his duty as Sarpanch over his family but is this true or is he still covering up?
-Why if he choose his duty over his family is Sudha still in love with him - (I can understand (not really but that's what a lot of these shows depict😆) that she does KC for him still as it it is their duty but wanting to be with him again as a family even for a short while shows she still loves him so I still believe they both made a big sacrifice and somehow I think Ramu made more of a sacrifice because he not only had to give up his wife but his daughter too, and pretend that they were dead all this time and have to get re-married to someone he doesn't love - at least she still had Miu and got to start her life over again without having to pretend in front of all those people)
Why, why, why?...😛



So what do you all think is the reason behind this lie? Do you think more of it will be revealed soon (ie upcoming week)?

Maybe Sudha sis not want that childhood marriage so left the village. Ramdhari loves her so much that told everyone that she is dead but knows that she is alive. That's why Meera has no clue about her marriage

Originally posted by: mariyakamran

Maybe Sudha sis not want that childhood marriage so left the village. Ramdhari loves her so much that told everyone that she is dead but knows that she is alive. That's why Meera has no clue about her marriage

Agreed this is the reason and I've thought from the beginning that Ramu has been lying to protect the 2 of them but why? And after today he said he said that he choose his duty as a Sarpanch over his family so if that is the case then was it for his own reasons he did this (to save face) or did he lie out of love for his wife and daughter and perhaps the need to protect them?

PS. I edited my original post again so please check it out (the dark green part that has heading "edited again to add...😆😉)

Originally posted by: -Yuks-

I was thinking along the same lines.
That when Prithvi was found the patriarchs said that they can't raise a stranger boy around Meera and the only way that Ramdhari could keep Prithvi with him was to get Meera and and Prithvi married.

Ramdhari, out of love of Prithvi agreed, but Sudha, thinking of Meera, didn't.

Im sure that the elder bhabhi has something to do with this. She doesn't seem too fond of Sudha and I'm sure she has some hand in her being shamed and escaping.

That would be an interesting angle for the reason why the panchaat would want them married too (about raising a non-relative boy in the same house as a girl but I personally wouldn't think that would be an issue but then again I didn't think such things as child marriages still took place so who knows what their thinking/reasoning would be for wanting the marriage) but that could also be a possible reason as well.

As for bhabi, I'm positive she had a hand in it especially if her hubby was not the sarpanch at the time and Ramu being the younger brother was. Jealousy could have been a possible motive as she would not have had the same status as Sudha as a Sarpanch's wife likewise her hubby also would not have had the same status in the village as Ramu (if he was not the sarpanch). Also, another motive could have been that others liked Sudha better than her because she could have been nicer to the villagers (we've seen how much she cares for those she sees at not at her status -ie no one is allowed to do puja in mundir at the same time as her etc), or perhaps because Sudha was more educated (she is a professor or something in the university/college that Aakash went to wasn't she?) then her or perhaps because she was childless, maybe she resents Sudha because she had a "love" marriage (any # of reasons could be behind why she would be interested in seeing Sudha's character besmirched and for everyone to despise her).

Anyway, I've started rambling again so I'll stop here😆

MY VIEW:
1. mithvi were only engaged not married.
2. Ramu is trying 2 protect miu 4rm childhood marriage.
3. Ramu was also involved with sudha in that fake drawning accident. Ramu was behind all that.
4. Confusion hi confusion he!:)

Omg kitna bada post,kitne saare sawal and kitne saare perhaps.

Originally posted by: foram.

Omg kitna bada post,kitne saare sawal and kitne saare perhaps.

What😲😳😆😉 Didn't I say I was rambling in my 2nd post😆. Sorry couldn't help it. It's probably as long as my WU's😆.

Anyway, yes there are so many what if's and maybe's in this show. Although we've cleared some facts like Ramu being aware of Sudha and Miu being alive, Prabha most likely Kalki's sister and maybe (haven't confirmed this) that Sunheri is not his biological daughter the rest are just questions after questions still...although it's fun guessing I'd love some more answers too😊

Originally posted by: luvsati

MY VIEW:
1. mithvi were only engaged not married.
2. Ramu is trying 2 protect miu 4rm childhood marriage.
3. Ramu was also involved with sudha in that fake drawning accident. Ramu was behind all that.
4. Confusion hi confusion he!:)

@1. I also used to think that but when Pundit found out about Miu's engagement to Aakash he took it more to heart of being an impossible thing so I figured perhaps he thought this way because Miu was already married as a child. Otherwise what would be the big deal about an engagement? They can and are broken all the time, especially one that happened so long ago... I still think there is something bigger than just the engagement considering how much everyone is going on about the "black" day from 20 years ago to the point that it paralyzed Ramu's older brother and left everyone hating Sudha and blaming Miu.

@2: I have always believed Ramu has been trying to protect both Sudha and Miu which is why he pretending they were dead. I wavered for a bit when Prabha and Sunheri were introduced but it looks like that marriage was in name only (and chances are Sunheri is not his biological daughter which I am assuming is the case from convo between Kalki and Prabha when Prabha says even though he doesn't love me at least he gives Sunheri the love of a daughter, why else would she say this if she was his biological daughter) and probably done because he had no excuse not to marry, especially considering older brother and Kalki seem childless and his one and only child had apparently died and Lakhu still would have been to young to marry to carry on the family name (not that a daughter does that but I guess they still need an heir). Then I wavered a bit again today when he said that he put his duty as Sarpanch over his duty to his family but perhaps again he is saying this to be diplomatic and also could still be trying to protect them...

@3: Yeah, I think it was all staged and both of them (Ramu and Sudha) were in on it

@4: lots and lots of it still, even after such a great epi and the fact that he has accepted in front of everyone that she is his daughter, his blood and he has known that they have been alive all this time

guess we have to wait longer for the whole truth 😕

Hi Parm 😊