Ektanama! Akbar bana abla purush.. including prem's view- DT Nt Pg 25

ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hi folks! since we all are in happy mood reminiscing the old golden days! how i wish this would have happened after the show had finished! at least i would have rewatched the old epis and cleared my mind from the pathetic NRs that have been hogging the screen since almost a year!..i had decided not to watch and forget about it but accidently caught the glimse of it on utube..and the end result of ektanama is akbar bana jodha aur jodha bani akbar...akbar doing jodha's duties by being ultra loyal pati in spite of endless marriages and harem full of thousands of concubines..and jodha taking all political decisions and coming out of the harem which i have never heard of..addressing the awaam in the days when common people were dying to catch a glimpse of royal ladies never mind coming face to face like this as shown..how pathetic! now i am happy that this butchering! torturing! and exploitation of this great monarch will end!

i would have not minded the cvz showing some real HK achievements only if they had not killed Akbar's character! they did not even show his single achievement or give credit for his real achievements! what a shame!
and sadly i am reminded of these lines on seeing sad demise of this larger than life character..result of poor script..

chamakte chand ko toota hua tara bana dala...

PS..this thread is to take frustration out who are feeling betrayed like me, the rest please kindly stay away from this thread..thank you!

an excellent view of prem..he said it all in few lines about akbar and what this serial was all about...

Originally posted by myviewprem

This serial was never about Akbar the great or Jodha Akbar love story it was of taming a jallad by jodha and guiding him all life like a mother hand holding a small child
But viewers expected equality in relationship that Akbar will do DEA/DEK work and go to wars and Jodha take care of family, business etc that never happened. Jodha was in DEA/DEK/War everywhere

To be honest from what I read of Akbar he was a personality A type who did what he wanted. He not only commanded the empire but his family. So he approved whom his kids married or did not marry, how they were educated, what work his wives did, what his ministers did etc I mean single handed decision maker for his family especially his kids and wife and even his sisters(anyone who lived with him). The only family member who got some consession to transgress from his commands was Salim rest all just followed him to the T usually. He was the patriarch of the family who had complete control and command over his family. By no means was he ever dependent on Ruqaiah or Jodha or Salima or Hamida completely at any time of his life for any decision.
Wether it is sati, child marriage, jaziya, compensating farmers where his army marched etc it was his sole decisions based on feed back he got and the trips he took in disguise around his empire. Yes a few people majorly his navrathna's and his family be it mother, wife or sisters and kids would have given him suggestions but only if he asked them. They could not like Jodha barge in with their opinion on any matter unless asked to, they could not dare do some things that jodha did to draw his attention to issues like teerth kaar where jodha paid teerth kaar and made it a public drama against Akbar, nor would a jodha or any family dare speak against his decision like in Khyber case nor could his wives or kids dare speak out of turn in court against him like jodha and salim were shown doing. The court had a decorum to be followed by all no concessions to his son or wives. May be a Maham, Bairam Khan or Hamida could speak out of turn never a Jodha, Ruqaiah, Salim ever.
Also the missionaries at his court have written he never showed his emotions what he thought on his face.
To show such a man begging in Mathura on feet of his wife, to him drowning in tears at drop of hat, to be a putty in his wife hands who could make him dance to her tunes etc I think it was a 360 degree role reversal. That finally lead to a downfall of this show. Because what viewers expected and had read in history was in contrast to what was being shown. So every viewer had a dilemma while watching the show as all knew this could not be Akbar the great. Ruqaiah played games with him and Jodha controlled all his decisions.
Edited by ghalibmirza - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

249

Views

15.5k

Users

34

Likes

864

Frequent Posters

srilu321 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
hi galibmirza
i have no complaints about story/NR . i knew this is a serial but it touched my heart because of actors ,story ,and presentation . i dont know history and AKDHA life story.because of ABHAY blogs i got so much knowledge on history and AKDHA life story.but two things i dont like in the serial -
1)using BDs and not editing properly.
2)ending of the story . i expected they will show how/why SA revolts AK and death of jl and jo.

about actors i like all the actors and their acting too. i like RT and PS but more PS but i like more them as AKDHA. i like to see them in another serial soon but i dont think they will act together as leads.
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: srilu321

hi galibmirza

i have no complaints about story/NR . i knew this is a serial but it touched my heart because of actors ,story ,and presentation . i dont know history and AKDHA life story.because of ABHAY blogs i got so much knowledge on history and AKDHA life story.but two things i dont like in the serial -
1)using BDs and not editing properly.
2)ending of the story . i expected they will show how/why SA revolts AK and death of jl and jo.

about actors i like all the actors and their acting too. i like RT and PS but more PS but i like more them as AKDHA. i like to see them in another serial soon but i dont think they will act together as leads.



i was expecting MEA track to be shown and highlighting akbar's persona..just like prithviraj kapoor but it all went out of the window as no one wanted to watch ekta's salim..let alone that at least show the real persona of Akbar before ending?
jayaks02 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
mandy and rest of everyone - I have only one Q or point.
Is there anything at all which Akbar did on his own, without help/assistance/mentorship/contribution from Devi ma ?
I can think of only one thing - SuSu and Potty. 😆 . Rest all is attributed to Beguma, Maan Singh and her parivar

Maan Singh helped Akbar win entire Hindustan.
begum did harem, DEK, DEA, governance, external affairs, rajaneeti, spying, pei virattals( i.e sending ghosts away from possessed bodies in Tamil), FInance, Civil administration, famine control, Prison reforms(Khyber 😆), A,B and C of Justice, Thyag/sacrifice, conversion to Islam till 99% and then backing out 😕, Geo political analysis( Shah of Iran), resolution of love affairs and marital disputes.
His job is to stand in four gates and receive dignatories from Amer and its surrounding tribal areas, watch dances in DEK, comb begum's hair, sing lullaby and put her to sleep and say I lubb you in hazaar languages. 😡
Sorry - I am done with JODHA, AMeris for life. 😡
I love Rajastan and will keep rest of Rajputs away from this characterization.
Begumsa rescuing Akbar from Englishmen is blasphemous, to say the very least
Edited by hinz - 10 years ago
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: jayaks02

mandy and rest of everyone - I have only one Q or point.

Is there anything at all which Akbar did on his own, without help/assistance/mentorship/contribution from Devi ma ?
I can think of only one thing - SuSu and Potty. 😆 . Rest all is attributed to Beguma, Maan Singh and her parivar(Teapot included).
Maan Singh helped Akbar win entire Hindustan.
begum did harem, DEK, DEA, governance, external affairs, rajaneeti, spying, pei virattals( i.e sending ghosts away from possessed bodies in Tamil), FInance, Civil administration, famine control, Prison reforms(Khyber 😆), A,B and C of Justice, Thyag/sacrifice, conversion to Islam till 99% and then backing out 😕, Geo political analysis( Shah of Iran), resolution of love affairs and marital disputes.
Puppysa's job is to wag tail and stand in four gates and receive cat, dog, teapot and other dignatories from Amer and its surrounding tribal areas, watch dances in DEK, comb begum's hair, sing lullaby and put her to sleep and say I lubb you in hazaar languages. 😡
Sorry - I am done with JODHA, AMeris for life. 😡
I love Rajastan and will keep rest of Rajputs away from this characterization.
Begumsa rescuing Akbar from Englishmen is blasphemous, to say the very least



jaya cannot agree more..all akbar is doing is udaofying flies from jodha's face while she sleeps or waiting for her to finish her out door duties so that akbar can massage her feet at night! that is all they are showing! NRs ki jai..! what else can i say!..and here we fools are waiting for the real akbar to be shown!!!
srilu321 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
hi galbmirza
even i too expected the same. because they took leap for MEA only.
shilpishona thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: srilu321

hi galibmirza

i have no complaints about story/NR . i knew this is a serial but it touched my heart because of actors ,story ,and presentation . i dont know history and AKDHA life story.because of ABHAY blogs i got so much knowledge on history and AKDHA life story.but two things i dont like in the serial -
1)using BDs and not editing properly.
2)ending of the story . i expected they will show how/why SA revolts AK and death of jl and jo.

about actors i like all the actors and their acting too. i like RT and PS but more PS but i like more them as AKDHA. i like to see them in another serial soon but i dont think they will act together as leads.

hey dr, we all r in same boat, miss dem lyk hell. bt one thing we can do is demand politely to cast parijat again as a lead in a new shw, u cn commnt on Ek insta acc, all r doing same.
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: srilu321

hi galbmirza

even i too expected the same. because they took leap for MEA only.



and what a pathetic ending..glorifying one queen by degrading another..what a cheap way to show the ending and then same old gungaans by akbar for muz..same old muz ki jai..at least show something related to the real characters in a dignified way!
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jayaks02

mandy and rest of everyone - I have only one Q or point.

Is there anything at all which Akbar did on his own, without help/assistance/mentorship/contribution from Devi ma ?


I can think of only one thing - SuSu and Potty. 😆. Rest all is attributed to Beguma, Maan Singh and her parivar(Teapot included).


Maan Singh helped Akbar win entire Hindustan.


begum did harem, DEK, DEA, governance, external affairs, rajaneeti, spying, pei virattals( i.e sending ghosts away from possessed bodies in Tamil), FInance, Civil administration, famine control, Prison reforms(Khyber 😆), A,B and C of Justice, Thyag/sacrifice, conversion to Islam till 99% and then backing out 😕, Geo political analysis( Shah of Iran), resolution of love affairs and marital disputes.


Puppysa's job is to wag tail and stand in four gates and receive cat, dog, teapot and other dignatories from Amer and its surrounding tribal areas, watch dances in DEK, comb begum's hair, sing lullaby and put her to sleep and say I lubb you in hazaar languages. 😡


Sorry - I am done with JODHA, AMeris for life. 😡


I love Rajastan and will keep rest of Rajputs away from this characterization.


Begumsa rescuing Akbar from Englishmen is blasphemous, to say the very least



I strongly disagree with the majority of your post but since the show is ending soon I honestly do not see the point in debating this point so I will just zip my mouth and shutup. 😊

Devki
srilu321 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
hi mandy
if i am not wrong there is no need of NR because AK life was full of masala .
Edited by srilu321 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".