Shahenshah/Father duties - Page 2

Originally posted by: tamy267

hmm I agree...lets see if he does it or not...I admit Jalal is right at his place...phir bhi giving such punishment to Salim was harsh...Salim is mere a kid and what happened was just an accident! I know Salim running away and lying at DEA angered Jalal the most...house arrest would have been fine as punishment and also giving royal treatment to Qadir till he recovers would have made his Dadi happy...making Salim staying in the house till Qadir recovers is something I am not liking...may be I am biased towards Salim...but I really wish Jalal say all these u mentioned..it will comfort Salim and also he will take it as a lesson.

having said that, Jalal is also a father..as much as we r upset, he is also upset and sad for this, in fact much much more than any of us...after all it was him who had to take such strict decision...he must have thought this step will make Salim stronger and teach him a lesson of life along witnessing a true picture of how commoners lead their lives.

agree tamy. Of course Jalal will be hurt and will be suffering as he loves Salim more than himself. But the problem is Salim cannot figure this out nah..He is young and too early to understand everything. One good thing about going to that commoner house is that Ruks cannot drug him. what a relief.

We all know Jalal started at very young and became an emperor at 13. But his circumstances were like that where as with Salim its totally different. He has not yet gone through what Jalal has gone through, so how Salim takes and views it will be different from Jalal.

I have always seen Kids born to very Smart but very very controlling parents lack confidence in them. Its the pressure. This I am talking in General not from Jalal's POV..

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

agree tamy. Of course Jalal will be hurt and will be suffering as he loves Salim more than himself. But the problem is Salim cannot figure this out nah..He is young and too early to understand everything. One good thing about going to that commoner house is that Ruks cannot drug him. what a relief.

We all know Jalal started at very young and became an emperor at 13. But his circumstances were like that where as with Salim its totally different. He has not yet gone through what Jalal has gone through, so how Salim takes and views it will be different from Jalal.

I have always seen Kids born to very Smart but very very controlling parents lack confidence in them. Its the pressure. This I am talking in General not from Jalal's POV..

Originally posted by: tamy267

exactly Sindhu..what Jalal had to face was his majboori not his choice..he lost his father at a tender age of 11...toh majboori mein he had to sit on throne at 13! he had his Khan Baba and Maham Anga to train him...Salim has no such majboori and he has his parents for guiding him...so he doesnt need to be put on experiments at every drop of hat...he will learn gradually but definitely not everything at a time!!!!

all JJ need is to make him sit and tell him where he went wrong and what he supposed to do if such situation arises again and advice him...only punishment se bacche darr jate hai seekhte nahi..Salim ko bitha ke sikhana hai, batana hai kyu usse sazaa di jarahi hai naaki galti ki aur sazaa di aur bhool gaye! I am sure Salim still didnt get what he is punished for.

agree with you totally...

Originally posted by: tamy267

exactly Sindhu..what Jalal had to face was his majboori not his choice..he lost his father at a tender age of 11...toh majboori mein he had to sit on throne at 13! he had his Khan Baba and Maham Anga to train him...Salim has no such majboori and he has his parents for guiding him...so he doesnt need to be put on experiments at every drop of hat...he will learn gradually but definitely not everything at a time!!!!

all JJ need is to make him sit and tell him where he went wrong and what he supposed to do if such situation arises again and advice him...only punishment se bacche darr jate hai seekhte nahi..Salim ko bitha ke sikhana hai, batana hai kyu usse sazaa di jarahi hai naaki galti ki aur sazaa di aur bhool gaye! I am sure Salim still didnt get what he is punished for.