ek teer aur kai nishaane! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

3.6k

Users

14

Likes

163

Frequent Posters

Susan.Dsouza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: mandyg



i too m expecting the track to end in a dignified way and there are many questions unanswered..my main question is why did atifa choose such an occasion to kill where she has no chance of escaping unless the dek was undertaken by MC'S men as per atifa but in reality they were jalal's men in disguise!


possible lets see what next happened becoz in cv case its useless to use our mind
jaljo thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
Sorry but I differ. I am not liking this teda emperor one bit!
I wanted a smart and shrewd Jalal against the enemies but not towards his loved ones. His pricking/insulting words towards his pregnant wife, all that she suffered during her pregnancy including her character getting gossiped by the awaam, her almost suicide along with her to-be kids (that could have been the end of the plan), ulemas up in arms, awaam up in arms, his khas begum like Rukaiya and Jodha getting insulted not in hojra but in front of baandhis and soldiers, revolt within the palace and outside, I mean is this how we wanted a TEDA Jalal to catch a pawn like Atifa and its mastermind. At the cost of his happiness, his beloved's happiness, his harem's happiness, his Sultanate's happiness.
I don't know what were the CVs thinking while writing this track..to get a dramatic climax or take everyone by surprise. Because they failed on both counts and very badly as the majority are not liking the way this track has been handled and both Jodha and Jalal's character has been butchered mercilessly. I have seen JA from the start with some ridiculous tracks in it. But by far this is the MOST ridiculous and senseless idea by the CVs irrespective of the reasoning they will give at the end.
As for Jodha knowing about this plan. I don't think she knows it till now. Her crying before the Kanha in yesterday's episode and also her self-talk in her hojra that what is the bhavishya of my children and what is their father doing with background dialogues shows that she is still not part of this plan. And if she is still not part of his plan then I want to know why he didn't show his trust in her to make her understand what he was going to do and why?. Don't reason out that it was for her good or protect her because when he pushed her to the edge of emotional/mental stress during critical months of her pregnancy (something he is aware of) and to the point of making her so vulnerable and alone that she could contemplate of suicide (harming herself and the kids), then I don't understand how his not sharing this plan with Jodha was beneficial.
PS: Now if this is TEDA Jalal, I want one answer. What about his self-talk in hojra that I am getting attracted to you Atifa in front of her fast-drawn painting (again by him)??? Why did he have to put on an act there?
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#13
fantastic post mandy
i hope jodha learns her lesson
not to poke her nose and interfere in everything
not to try to put only her theories in practise
not to thopofy her views on jalal always
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
Mandy... as they say the most important and crucial point of any story lies in its climax
We can dissect and trisect this till there's no tomorrow, but it all lies in how the ending is shown!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: jaljo

Sorry but I differ. I am not liking this teda emperor one bit!

I wanted a smart and shrewd Jalal against the enemies but not towards his loved ones. His pricking/insulting words towards his pregnant wife, all that she suffered during her pregnancy including her character getting gossiped by the awaam, her almost suicide along with her to-be kids (that could have been the end of the plan), ulemas up in arms, awaam up in arms, his khas begum like Rukaiya and Jodha getting insulted not in hojra but in front of baandhis and soldiers, revolt within the palace and outside, I mean is this how we wanted a TEDA Jalal to catch a pawn like Atifa and its mastermind. At the cost of his happiness, his beloved's happiness, his harem's happiness, his Sultanate's happiness.
I don't know what were the CVs thinking while writing this track..to get a dramatic climax or take everyone by surprise. Because they failed on both counts and very badly as the majority are not liking the way this track has been handled and both Jodha and Jalal's character has been butchered mercilessly. I have seen JA from the start with some ridiculous tracks in it. But by far this is the MOST ridiculous and senseless idea by the CVs irrespective of the reasoning they will give at the end.
As for Jodha knowing about this plan. I don't think she knows it till now. Her crying before the Kanha in yesterday's episode and also her self-talk in her hojra that what is the bhavishya of my children and what is their father doing with background dialogues shows that she is still not part of this plan. And if she is still not part of his plan then I want to know why he didn't show his trust in her to make her understand what he was going to do and why?. Don't reason out that it was for her good or protect her because when he pushed her to the edge of emotional/mental stress during critical months of her pregnancy (something he is aware of) and to the point of making her so vulnerable and alone that she could contemplate of suicide (harming herself and the kids), then I don't understand how his not sharing this plan with Jodha was beneficial.
PS: Now if this is TEDA Jalal, I want one answer. What about his self-talk in hojra that I am getting attracted to you Atifa in front of her fast-drawn painting (again by him)??? Why did he have to put on an act there?



its all confusing at the moment i too have many questions because the ott begums versus jalal encounter could have been mellowed down but why all this i would say is a good question..jalal ka tedapan is back but how he planned it and why he did what he did i hope is justified at the end is all i can say at the moment!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: rima4ever

fantastic post mandy

i hope jodha learns her lesson
not to poke her nose and interfere in everything
not to try to put only her theories in practise
not to thopofy her views on jalal always



she really needs to trust jalal, what she did in khyber case was foolish, i too hope she learns something!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: lashy

Mandy... as they say the most important and crucial point of any story lies in its climax

We can dissect and trisect this till there's no tomorrow, but it all lies in how the ending is shown!



lashy well said! i too am waiting for the climax till then nothing can be said!
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: mandyg



she really needs to trust jalal, what she did in khyber case was foolish, i too hope she learns something!

i too hope so 😛
nehaaa.14 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19
Lovely post!!!
During the Sujamal fiasco, Jodha knew that Jalal was hurting but she kept mum because she was vajanbandh. Here, the same goes for Jalal, he is hurting his family by saying those harsh words to them but he is only doing so to protect his family. He is just doing a dikhafa in front of Atifa.
jaljo thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20
@Red: Did I anywhere mention that this plan was for catching Atifa ONLY???
@Blue: Us 23 year old people with limited resources and limited know-how have our limitations but Jalal is not just ANY 23 year-old. He is a KING who has seen a lot since childhood both personally, in war field and knows that there are enemies within and outside his kingdom. He has been bestowed the title of AKBAR recently and hence needs to think a lot before acting something crazy like this to create an uproar everywhere. Where are his spies, his ministers? Are NONE of the ministers or people in his personal space trustworthy? Does he think he does not need guidance of any kind at this stage to act alone???
@Pink: Are you absolutely sure that he is facing 10 life-threatening issues at one go to act so crazy?
@Blue/green: Have I talked about NR or 16th century anywhere? Have I said what Jodha did was right? If you read carefully I clearly said that BOTH Jalal and Jodha's character has been mercilessly butchered by the CVs in this track. And this track could have been a lot better than what is being shown. I am pointing a finger at the CVs for showing such a ridiculous track and a TEDA Jalal, whose TEDA ness is not appreciated at all by me and hopefully a lot more.
As for assumptions and presumptions, that is what all in the forum are doing right now on why is he acting the way he is acting without a conclusive hint in hand. That can go on and on and on till we actually see it enfolding as the CLIMAX (which by the way are always different than what we assume)😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".