Please think about it......

Page

Sush

@Forthislifeonly

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Cvs...I hate you...I hate you to the core???

So.finally..U have decided to show the twin track???

WHY?????WHY?????Cvs...Was it so important??

When u are not following history in Hulk track,MC-HQ marriage track...etc. etc. track...Then was it really needed to show this TWINS TRACK???

Offcourse...Many will oppose me...by saying this that it is correct according to history...

I really respect their POV...but I want to tell them the show has proved itself far away that it's not a historical show!!!!!!It's a overloaded Natakiya Rupantar...

I want to point another thing.which most of us have discussed already...

Guys...I admit it that I don't know history much...But even also I know that never ever SHAHENSHAH AKBAR was captured by anyone...

& There we saw this war...where Akbar was imprisoned & tortured badly...so...here also the show goes against history...

& many more points...where the show has proved it again & again that the show is not following anymore...

& The biggest point is...to make AKBAR spineless & brainless...here.just here the show has crossed all the limits...

& today's episode also.where AKBAR lost all the words.after Jodha's defense...yes.her defense was good...but that doesn't mean...Jalal will react so softly...Couldn't he say atleast this...that she should atleast tell this to HB & Salima begum?????They have good relation.na????

I want to tell you...we the viewers who still are watching this...tell me...how many of will you like AKBAR crying buckets & buckets..& Whole sultanat will join him???

Undoubtfully.we, most of all are sensitive viewers...because we all like AkDha scenes...then tell me will you able to watch Jalal crying for his children??

Will your all hearts not sink in pain??

will you watch this show to pressurize yourself??

Now I want to tell you...I recently came to know...that old AKBAR serial & Jhansi ki Raani showed baby death...well old AKBAR serial---that was not so famous like this kind of serial...& that serial was really really more accurate...

& Jhansi ki rani--well there was no other choice...

But here the CVs are changing history manywhere...so I think it will not bother much if they will show this as miscarriage...atleast...born babies' death pain is much more than unborn babies...

guys...just think about it.from your heart...& don't forget...this is a NR...

please please share your views...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sush

@Forthislifeonly

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Why no comments???I really want a strong debate on it!!!!!😈😈

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Donjas

@Donjas

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

I read your post with interest. Well written. I have a contrary view.

One of the enduring images of the Akbar story that has survived the centuries is how Akbar breaks down at the failure to have a heir, how he becomes so desperate that he treks naked foot on hot baked sand to Sheikh Salim Chisti to seek his blessing. When Salim came, he was so grateful that from then on, his war cry in all the battles was 'Ya Salim". He also named his heir apparent, as Salim.

The tragedies that follow, also help to explain why the boy Salim was so cherished, to the point that he was spoiled by his parents.

For all this, we the viewers have to endure the tragedy of the twin deaths. Not only will it be riveting drama but it will take the focus away from the Mahachuchak nonsense. That is a blessing indeed, and hopefully this tragedy will bring the serial on to the right track.

Edited by Donjas - 11 years ago

Quote

Sush

@Forthislifeonly

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Thnx Donjas...for ur POV...exactly...I was wanting this...a truthful debate...

well...yes somewhere you are saying true ...that it will be useful to see why Salim was so much cherished????

But I think Miscarriage can also fulfil this demand...

I mean they can show us a leap.where the Cvs will tell us that in these years.there was child death,Miscarriages etc...then they show Akbar's darga trip & all & Salim's birth...

Actually I have no problem with this.if they just describe us about it...I mean no scenes...Here Easily the CVs can do a 7 years leap...I think that will be better from all sides...

Edited by Brishti22 - 11 years ago

Quote

Donjas

@Donjas

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Brishti22
Thnx Donjas...for ur POV...exactly...I was wanting this...a truthful debate...
well...yes somewhere you are saying true ...that it will be useful to see why Salim was so much cherished????
But I think Miscarriage can also fulfil this demand...
I mean they can show us a leap.where the Cvs will tell us that in these years.there was child death,Miscarriages etc...then they show Akbar's darga trip & all & Salim's birth...
Actually I have no problem with this.if they just describe us abou it...I mean no scenes...Here Easily the CVs can do a 7 years leap...I think that will be better from all sides...

I understand your discomfort, but a leap will not have the same emotional impact. Tragic as they are, the deaths have to be shown, the despair of Akbar, the breakdown of Jodha and how they rebuild their lives again. Then, the total joy and relief at Salim's birth.

All this will be in sequence, if the twin deaths are not shown then the subsequent events would lose their gut wrenching emotional power.

I don't think they will show the actual deaths, they will be sensitive how they show the scene.

Edited by Donjas - 11 years ago

Quote

myviewprem

@myviewprem

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

i know its very sad to watch jalal crying for his twinsss 😭😭

but necessary evil

shows why ak got desperate and walked 360 Kms to ajmer to get a child

Quote

katana

@katana

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

Good post dear with valid points 👏

Quote

Sush

@Forthislifeonly

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Prem,Donjas...I am giving my reply to you both in one comment...so.sorry...

Ok...I agree that may be the Cvs wil show this indirectly...& yes.somewhere it is really needed to show for Akbar's craving for a heir...& undoubtfully...this incident will make his wish to desperation...& yes...it also giving chance to show their unbreakable emotional bond between AkDha...

But...But...there is another side of coin...the Cvs can show us by a 2 months leap...in these leap months they will describe us about baby death...their they can show us crying AkDha...that will be somehow bearable...but directly or indirectly witness this scene will really affect the TRP...that's also a point...I am not against the track...but I am against the sequences...The Cvs can still make it tolerable by showing us a short(it may be some days or weeks..that will be enough)...leap...so..this track needs good director...sensible & intelligent screen play writer...because...this is a such a delicate track...if it will not be handled carefully...it will create a huge mess...& it may affect the post show after this track...so.this is going to be a tough exam for the Creative team...

Quote

abhi

@abhi786

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Donjas

I understand your discomfort, but a leap will not have the same emotional impact. Tragic as they are, the deaths have to be shown, the despair of Akbar, the breakdown of Jodha and how they rebuild their lives again. Then, the total joy and relief at Salim's birth.

All this will be in sequence, if the twin deaths are not shown then the subsequent events would lose their gut wrenching emotional power.

I don't think they will show the actual deaths, they will be sensitive how they show the scene.

I agree with you Dogas, directly showing Salim would n't have the impact, as both JJ cherished their twins and lost them.. They both were in emotional depression & also the pain they had suffer has to be shown, as we can see Jalaal desperation to have a child ( long living) and hJJ belief and how much prayers & pujas both they did have to be shown before Salim birth.. I think before Salim birth MA & Adham has to die...