Originally posted by: sweet_diksha
very good take , Mansi for a big illogical episode...
and questions after yest episode r such that while watching the episode i felt CVs forgot the word logic while writing the scenes...ok...here it is..
the big question is Shehnaaz...her behavior in yest's episode was completely out of the way... first thing she recognizes her mother whom she had lost when she was just few days old... how? had she some pic of CB painted by that banndi who raised her? or after giving the baby to that baandi , CB had managed to rescue herself from MA and then met with that baandi and stayed with Shenu for few years...
else how Shenu knows she has a right over delhi takht, coz that baandi need not know this truth... she can only tell Shenu that she is Humayun's daughter, not abt right to takht... so i felt CB must have traced that baandi and her daughter and stayed with them for few years...
then one more question... if she was staying with her daughter, how she lost her mental balance, and why ran away again to be seen and captured by MA? does that mean, CB is not mad, and she was with shenu for many years... and then after few years after Jalal came to throne they made a plan to get entry in his palace and kill him and get the takht? is that's why CB pretended to be mad , but instead of getting in Jalal's life , she was seen by MA and so Shenu lost all contacts with her mother, and so she started feeling that CB must have met Jalal and asked for her rights and then Jalal held her captive sothat he wouldn't have to give any rights to shenu... and so now shenu is hell bent on her revenge with Jalal... but if this theory is to be right, then shenu must be knowing that MA once served CB , and now is serving Jalal and that too as his very khaas person... and so that may be reason for her MU that Jalal is real culprit...
see why i said CVs forgot logic... they just showed what they wanted to... and we r trying all options which can be the right theory... coz i m not sure what logic CVs applied by showing that shenu is pretending to be a bit mad... what was the need? they could have shown her entering agra palace as a baandi working for HB or Ruku... that way she could have got trust on herself... coz they have shown that she met Jo was a co-incidence... so what she was doing in mathura ashram? i don't find any logic in that ... and yest's Shenu recognizing her mother, made me think all these illogical things CVs have given us to find logic from...
now, how can she leave the palace any time she wants, if she is mentally challanged person? what guards on the gates do? nobody informs Jalal or Jo abt Shenu leaving the palace? or does she knows all 'khufiya raste' to go out of agra? and then she has fee access to all those Kufiya raste? even Jalal doesn't know all hidden places, and Shenu knows?
then, what was such need, or hurry for Jalal or Jo to gift Ruku that palna in the night when Ruku was sleeping peacefully? don't they know, a preg woman should not be disturbed of her sleep? couldn't they wait for next day to gift her?
then, Jalal tells Jo that he has decided to find out CB ASAP... but then he says that it's his promise to her that he will find CB... now what's the need for a promise here? and that too Jo , like Jo is CB's daughter and Jallu is consoling her for losing her mother?
then again in DEK , AK was ready to take out his dagger and attack Jalal. why? if he had used GK's men for attack on AkDha, where was the chance of AK's name coming out when GK has fled, and what Jallu , Atga and their detective team captured was just a dead body?
A complete blooper... and i wasted my 30 minutes in watching it 😭... why???