Take 5: Top 5 countdown for April 30th; note on pg 2 DT Note PG 12 - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

93

Views

7.3k

Users

23

Likes

247

Frequent Posters

divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#71

Sandhya, well said on all your points- especially the one on Ruqs (underlined above)!
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: durgarvv

i am feeling like some how they are degrading the jodha charecter. is she same jodha cried by knowing jalal going to spend night with ruks. even though Jalal is in that much broken state and remembering jodha but Jodha is thinking about abhiman and charithra only. at least CV's should show like she feels hurting or sense something as he is in broken state as her heart is with him.

some how from few episodes if we look at jodhas expressions not showing up any love only guroor or angry.


Absolutely agree with the point in underlined - Jodha is entitled to be hurt... But why is that hurt not being shown?
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: mandyg

i kinda liked the episode..i do not like crying jalal but i guess it was necessary for him to vent it out..i loved when SB said that he is the king and should act like one..it reminded me of krishan's gyan to arjun before the war against his own brothers..jalal too was shaken by one bombardment after the other but salima's gyan was much needed at this point..on the other hand jodha was getting gyan from shaguni bai but how much it will seep into her grey matter is hard to tell

ashwini stole the show again by her mesmerizing performance..i am gonna miss her badly!


I liked what Salima Begum said ... Except where did that gyan go when it was about Jodha Begum, so it felt a little shallow ...

We will all miss Ashwini but not MA! Too bad Ekta already wasted her duplicate 😉
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: luvbarun4ever


grey matter 😆..LOL
Along with Ashwini, Rajat did an awesome performance. omg...JUST OUTSTANDING. I almost had tears..I also like Lavina's and adham's acting...I kind of like all the villains now more than Jodha..which is so weird. I am gone crazy...😕


We all are feeling like are we crazy ... I watch Jodha's scenes a few times to make sure I am not missing something.
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon



Divyaa I actually Liked Salimas advise..One thing to remember is it is always very easy to sympatheize with people who repent and right now we all are doing that with Jalal. But what is the point if he makes the same mistakes again and again.Totally agree that Jodha was equally wrong not to tell Jalal about Sujamal. But Jalal trusted the wrong people. Some times I too get frustrated because I want to see Akdha together but in reality If I was to be in Jodhas shoes, I would be doing what she is doing right now. No doubts in that. It takes time to forget all the traumas u have gone through. It takes time to rebuild that trust...



Thanks Sindhu- while I am not sure I agree that Jalal makes the same mistakes again and again, I absolutely agree Jodha can be in trauma and hurt- but why are the CVs not even focusing on that?
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: aashyagh

Divya, good take.
Jalal needs someone to be with him, he is missing his love (she is seriously not worth it), but we all know, he will be happy with her only, and we want him to be happy.
Ruq- she really proved that, she loves/cares for Jalal more than anything else in her life.
MA- her acting was superb again, she never expected that, Jalal will break his relationship with her, she expected him to take the powers, she knows, without the relationship, the power he has given will not be same, as it holds no value or authority without relationship. The relationship gave her an edge.
HB- yes, I agree that, she should have gone to Jalal, but that would have made him feel that, another mother whom he trusted/loved more than his own mother had hurt him, and at that moment HB going to him would pinch him, look at the end, your own mother is the one you need. Whatever, she does injustice with him in regard to Jodha, but she is a sensible and matured woman and behaves like a Mallika, and that's how they used to be then,no matter what in such positions you can't behave like an ordinary person. If Jalal goes to her, she will definitely console him.
Jodha- no comments, she is not worth any comments.



Thanks Ash. Yes, we all want Jodha back in Agra for Jalal more than anything else.

Good points on HB- let's see how she reacts today.
luvbarun4ever thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: divyavm


We all are feeling like are we crazy ... I watch Jodha's scenes a few times to make sure I am not missing something.


I know we always blame CV's for showing Jodha's character in such a way. But it is the same CV's that gives excellent episodes for Jalal and others..almost every other character makes sense in the show. It's the actors that need to carry the scene on their Shoulders. I am not sure if CV's have to write that Jodha needs to show some pain and hurt in her face or during her dialogue delivery. It is actor's job to understand it and directors to get that from their actor. Since Pari has probe with the director, whomever is shooting her scenes can only say ACTION and CUT i guess...and she just does what she feels like doing. Paridhi is director's actor, she is disappointing me BIG time. I will blame this 80% on her and the rest on her director. She needs to re watch her performance. God sake she is the LEAD.
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: alapi

luvly take😊...

btw fr ur qn i realy doubt the CVs dat will they evr make jo realize dat she ws nt their fr her love when he needed her the most...
bt i realy liked they restored some dignity of Ruqu's character coz she is nt bad at heart its nly her past life nd the situation dat made her luk wat we can see her 2day...nd it ws nly her realisation dat how much pain she has caused to jalal made her apologize nd Lavina portrayed it vry well...
personally i didnt like HB nd SB both...
nd evn if jo wud hv been here she wudnt have been the jo he needed ryt nw so its gud she is nt here...
i realy feel bad fr ja dat he really is a loner😭i mean common ws dat the way her mother shud hv behavedinstead of SB she herslf wud hv made her way 2 ja coz he jst lost her mother nd ryt nw he needed her selfless mother's care nd support to stand upright nd b the Sehenshah nd nt any SB who till nw has been shown as a substitute of BIRBAL😆
nd abt jo's return,i really got a hint of her return fr shivani's wedding as sagunibai said dat kali maa wud decide the timing😡nd if it realy happens then i realy doubt will i b able accept dat jo in Agra😕bt den CVS will realy need a big changeover to b made wid jodha's charactersketch otherwise the charm will b lost nd so our hopes too...coz this way she cant b the SOUL REASON of jalal being Akbar the great...



Thanks so much!

Liked your pun on soul/sole reason in the end- her character needs more soul.

Yes, Jodha needs new SWs for sure.

Jalal is indeed lonely today.
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: banuprasa

Hi Divya,

Nice Take 5👏

I loved Salima today & good that Ruk admit her mistake on her own.

Let see when Jodha return to agra.



Thanks!
divyavm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: lashy

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">The CVs are ruining the flavour of an epic story by portraying Jodha so rigid and Jalal doing all the pining. I was under the impression that Jodha will grow more and more desperate, but the Shaguni Bai scene was the nail in the coffin for me. Just because she SAYS mohabbat bad gayee, what does it achieve when her actions/words are not clear?) the rest of it was superlative</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">
RT and Jalal were both amazing today! His heart is being broken and broken more and broken even more
I felt a lump in my throat when I heard him say 'I feel like I have no identity of my own anymore!' 'I feel like I've been sacrificed now'

MA falling down in the DEK after Jalal left was amazing ...her expressions literally read 'Oh My God! So consumed was I by temporary spells of insanity and power hunger than I realized not what I had done'

He gave her the most fitting punishment - for now - after all, she wanted only power and not the son...so he's taken away her son from her letting her have her power. Now, let's see how she fills up the void after Jalal's departure with Adham! (Though I think in tomorrow's scene, he takes away her power too - what with SB and HB asking him to mete the proper form of justice)
I never expected Ruqaiyya's truth to come out so soon - another blow to Jalal.
For some reason, I liked and yet did not like Saleema's advice. No one's being a 'human' to him in this time of need. A hug, a shoulder to cry on, take his hand in yours - a mother, a wife - no...everyone's being Mariam Makani or Khaas Begum! Only if the 'human' in him is well, can the 'Shehenshah' in him prosper
Ruqaiyya could have fulfilled the void had she not given in to such mistakes and earned his wrath...

Nevertheless, another episode - Jalal, Jalal and Jalal all the way!👏

I don't understand if MA is suffering from amnesia - ek gunaah? You've literally left the Sultanat without an heir, you've hit Jalal at all spots where you know it'd hurt him most (dhakka), you've let the Sultanat (that you so pride yourself on) be humiliated by the Shivaani kaand and now you expect him to show leniency and gratitude when you've shown him none? The MC kaand had nothing to do with Jodha... so, let's not try and bury all your misdeeds in the cloak of possessiveness/jealousy!

At this moment, I'm disappointed with the sketching of all the female characters in the show😕</font>



As always, great take on the episode ... Loved your points on Jalal and your new hammer emoticon

I would say MA does not have amnesia but always had this dual personality from her MC track days- it is not an inconsistency- she is kinda crazy.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".