Ruq-Jalal-Jodha: The Royal Triangle - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

6k

Users

17

Likes

215

Frequent Posters

Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: albakry


She is jealous of loosing Jalal because Jalal is power, it has nothing to do with love.

Why did she place Jalal's unborn child above her MUZ audha once? Why is that reaction always forgotten or ignored?
ShadeOfWhite thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Kshithi how I love your posts darling!!🤗
wonderful and once again insightful...u have captured the true essence of their characters...agree to every bit!❤️
Ruqaiyyah is no kid..like you said she has her own brain, she can very very well differentiate b/w right and wrong..but she chose to walk on the wrong path in her greed of power..once Ruqaiyyah used to read MA and her ploys... and this is the same Ruqaiyyah falling in her traps! sad...really sad...but its her fault..I will blame her only...where Jalal can prefer goodness over badness, why cant she?
ayushimehra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: kmmdesai

Hellooo my friends,

I am back. 🤗 Missed you guys...

So, here is my new post.

The last few episodes are mainly for Ruq and Jodha and Jalal caught up in between. Here is my few thoughts on them.

Ruq and Jalal were too similar earlier when JA started. So, to some extent we can excuse her behavior and the way of thinking to her upbringing and her childhood circumstances. She got married very early and hence became chief queen during her growing up years. Just like Jalal, she did not have any one aiding to her personal growth. Many people, including Jalal were kowtowing to her every whims and fancies because she was the queen and in Jalal's case, she was his friend. She grew up pampered and spoilt as a result. Jalal and co. is equally responsible for this as Ruq is. Ruq is ambitious and hence craves power over everything just like how Jalal was. She and Jalal grew up to be similar persons and goals.

But, there comes a point in time in everyone's life that they have to own up their actions, come out of the past influences and be self aware. Simply, they just have to grow up. Jalal did and he always had it in him. Jodha was the catalyst to this change. Child Ruq, if misbehaves, can be excused, but not adult Ruq. She now has the intelligence and a mind of her own to adapt and change herself. She can now think and see where she is going wrong and not. If Jalal can do it, she can too. Where Jalal changed, Ruq is still stuck in the past where Jalal was so much like her and she was the center if his universe.

Now, I find that while Ruq and Jodha are different in many ways, they are also similar in others.

Ruq and Jodha both got married to Jalal without free will. Ruq got married when she was young and Jodha for political reasons. Both are pampered princesses (I will not discount the influence of HB, GB, Salima etc on Ruq here). Both married to a person who is always angry and has lot of baggage. He is power hungry and ruthless, and most importantly without a heart or so he claims.

The difference is in the way both deal with Jalal or has delt with Jalal till now. I think the biggest disadvantage Ruq has is that she grew up with Jalal. In order to deal with him, and also because they were friends Ruq became another Jalal. She grew power hungry and audha-obsessed. Hence, without an objective view and an outsider's perspective, she did not realize that instead of becoming her own person and individual, she became exactly like Jalal. Since Jalal claims he is heartless, she became heartless herself. Since Jalal like power and she stared craving power as well and so on.

On the other hand, Jodha is an outsider and hence can see the flaws in Jalal. And moreover, she is her own person, not an extension of Jalal. Hence, she calls spade a spade and hence completely different from Jalal.

Ruq finds it easier to agree to everything Jalal says than facing his anger while correcting him or maybe because she is too similar to him; whereas Jodha always tell the truth, even if he becomes angry. Ruq did not dig in deeper to find out if Jalal actually has no heart or not, she did not try to understand him or understand that he simply keeps everything buried. She understands Jalal at surface value and that is enough for her. Jodha, on the other hand, always tried understanding him, his actions and reactions. Ruq never forced Jalal towards softer emotions. Jodha did, especially during BB case. The list can go on.

Most importantly, for Ruq, spending time with Jalal means playing something, like kids. They are basically play dates. She expects things from Jalal. She is still stuck in past and now that Jalal has moved on; she does not know what to become of her. She is still searching for the past Jalal and still clinging to older days when he is always available to play with her. Unless she grows up and be wise, she will always be alone. But, for Jodha, spending time with Jalal means meaningful talk, discussions and basically adult conversations. Jodha does not expect anything from Jalal, other than the pleasure of his company. She stimulates his thinking and intelligent brain, his softer side and shares his vision for future kingdom.

Jalal once pondered as to why Jodha allowed a third person like Ben to come between them. The same applies to Ruq too. Why did she allow other women or in this case Jodha to become important to him? Why Ruq could not become his soul mate? Does she really love Jalal or love the idea of controlling Jalal? When did power become so important to her than Jalal?

As far as Jalal is concerned, he only knew one way of the husband and wife relationship that is between him and Ruq. But now with Jodha, he realizes that the relationship can mean something else, something caring and something tender. He has now realized what was missing in his life. And what he was expecting from Ruq is something which he got from Jodha. It feels nice to be in a give and take relationship of tenderness and caring, instead of one way road.

Love

Kshithi

PS: Sorry, I can not write small posts...😳


GOOD POST.

RUK where standing way is now her own hands. you not blame jodha or jalal for this
as jodha said in previous episode, jalal is not a kid. so Ruk is also not a kid. that time kings
do many marriages. in harem of ruk has so power, nobody will able to get that poistion which
ruk got. so she has habit of dominating, as a husband or as a friend jalal fulfiiled that.
but ruk forget, everthing not get, harshness which she doing these days.(her beahviour to
dassies) her energy is focused how to distanced jalal &jodha. her energy should be focused how
her realtion will become better everyone because she is BK. wife of King &she is maturing
now , she is not a Kid.
How many times jalal has forgiven her.
HE not good in jodha, but he good with Ruk, he punished BB. Murti behaviour of Ruk
he avoid this matter. if she is feeling inscure she should talk, not choose wrong methods
which is harming her. she knows about Maham, why she is listening her, why she is not using her brain.other side jalal is a learning man. A person who wants to learn,learns everything,
everytalk. jalal(akbar)has many examples. jodha has many qualties. Humen nature quality
always attracts learner people. so both are learning.ruk should learn from them.
jalal when talked to Ruk about Murtikand is Ruk not understand she is doing wrong .
why she is hiding Maham &ADAM beahvior from JALAL. ?
Edited by ayushimehra - 11 years ago
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A


<div><font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">

Why did she place Jalal's unborn child above her MUZaudha once? Why is that reaction always forgotten or ignored?
</font>


sandhya, whenever I hear Ruq loves her power more dan jalal , dis point comes to my mind first..why she never did sumthing dangerous at dat time??She said I don't knw yeh gum ki aasoo hai ya khushi ki..I wil b always in pain becoz I can't b amother..but I'm happy for jalal , he got the happiness of being a father through jodha..ofcouse she loves power..but when it comes jalal or power, she prefer jalal only..
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
very good analysis..u potrayed the characters very beautifully..I think we can't blame Rukku completely being under the influence of MA...she is very cunning lady..yes, jalal is changing, but his faith in MA is like dat only..MA's influence on jalal's life is decreasing, but stil she is very important..All dis ben track, MA introduced benz to jalal first..Aftr dis track, he didn't show any distrust on her..If she can misguide a cunning, intelligent person like jalal, den Rukku kya cheez hai??
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A


There is one more difference kshithi. Jalal has a wide exposure while ruqaiya was stuck to the crazy harem all her life. It is experience that helps you grow as a person. Even if jodha had married suryabhaan her outlook would have been limited. She would have continued to hate the mughals and her sense of righteousness would have been narrow. She has grown due to jalal and his loving efforts though there is no denying that she is a learner.

Ruqaiya is not a cheapo or ak or ma ( well as of now, there is no telling how she might be twisted ). As a husband jalal made jodha look at things with a different nazariya. As a friend he also ought to make his friend who has been with him in his lowest moments of his life, to grow and understand. Else he looks flawed. Even the worst truants change themselves when somebody makes sincere efforts. Ruqaiya is only a spoilt rude brat, and she is extremely loyal to jalal and the sultanate.



Everybody is on fire this weekend. We have got super posts which have started vigorous discussions. Mandyg, Adrinasr and now Kshithi

Kshiti missed you and will write reply to you asap but first I want to comment on very good point made by Sandhya,

Sandhya very right about the influences shaping life, Jalal has got very wide one and Jodha would have hated Mugals all her life if she had married Suryabhan. I think her hatred was not about Jalal but about what his empire can do to her Amer.

Jodha equated him with his empire which at that time was looting her temples and harming her country.

Jodha has evolved and changed for and DUE to Jalal, similarly Jalal has CHANGED due to Jodha.

Rukayy also has influence of HB, GB and especially SB. Why she could not be closer to SB?

Rukayya should have grown up faster than Jalal because firstly she is a woman, they grow faster than men emotionally. Secondly she has suffered MC and was devastated at the nature of it.

Rukayya who had brains to not trust MA earlier - why has she stopped using her brains?

Who should be most important to her Jalal or MA? Why is Ruk not listening to Jalal but MA. People graviate towards what attracts them. Why is Ruk not attracted to thoughts of SB or HB or Jalal, why only MA makes sense to her?

Jalal is very passionate and at his worst also he was always honest. Jodha is also passionate and their feelings will never be lukewarm, they hated intensely and will love intensely passionately.

Rukayya is shallow because she feels SHE HAS NO NEED TO GROW no need to learn no need to change herself. Nobody else can change you only you yourself can.

I shared this beautiful saying on another post

By Ratan Tata
"None can destroy iron, but its own rust can! Likewise none can destroy a person, but his own mindset can"
Rukayya as a person is rusting because she is not willing to change.



MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: kmmdesai

Hellooo my friends,

I am back. 🤗 Missed you guys...

So, here is my new post.

The last few episodes are mainly for Ruq and Jodha and Jalal caught up in between. Here is my few thoughts on them.

Ruq and Jalal were too similar earlier when JA started. So, to some extent we can excuse her behavior and the way of thinking to her upbringing and her childhood circumstances. She got married very early and hence became chief queen during her growing up years. Just like Jalal, she did not have any one aiding to her personal growth. Many people, including Jalal were kowtowing to her every whims and fancies because she was the queen and in Jalal's case, she was his friend. She grew up pampered and spoilt as a result. Jalal and co. is equally responsible for this as Ruq is. Ruq is ambitious and hence craves power over everything just like how Jalal was. She and Jalal grew up to be similar persons and goals.

But, there comes a point in time in everyone's life that they have to own up their actions, come out of the past influences and be self aware. Simply, they just have to grow up. Jalal did and he always had it in him. Jodha was the catalyst to this change. Child Ruq, if misbehaves, can be excused, but not adult Ruq. She now has the intelligence and a mind of her own to adapt and change herself. She can now think and see where she is going wrong and not. If Jalal can do it, she can too. Where Jalal changed, Ruq is still stuck in the past where Jalal was so much like her and she was the center if his universe.

Now, I find that while Ruq and Jodha are different in many ways, they are also similar in others.

Ruq and Jodha both got married to Jalal without free will. Ruq got married when she was young and Jodha for political reasons. Both are pampered princesses (I will not discount the influence of HB, GB, Salima etc on Ruq here). Both married to a person who is always angry and has lot of baggage. He is power hungry and ruthless, and most importantly without a heart or so he claims.

The difference is in the way both deal with Jalal or has delt with Jalal till now. I think the biggest disadvantage Ruq has is that she grew up with Jalal. In order to deal with him, and also because they were friends Ruq became another Jalal. She grew power hungry and audha-obsessed. Hence, without an objective view and an outsider's perspective, she did not realize that instead of becoming her own person and individual, she became exactly like Jalal. Since Jalal claims he is heartless, she became heartless herself. Since Jalal like power and she stared craving power as well and so on.

On the other hand, Jodha is an outsider and hence can see the flaws in Jalal. And moreover, she is her own person, not an extension of Jalal. Hence, she calls spade a spade and hence completely different from Jalal.

Ruq finds it easier to agree to everything Jalal says than facing his anger while correcting him or maybe because she is too similar to him; whereas Jodha always tell the truth, even if he becomes angry. Ruq did not dig in deeper to find out if Jalal actually has no heart or not, she did not try to understand him or understand that he simply keeps everything buried. She understands Jalal at surface value and that is enough for her. Jodha, on the other hand, always tried understanding him, his actions and reactions. Ruq never forced Jalal towards softer emotions. Jodha did, especially during BB case. The list can go on.

Most importantly, for Ruq, spending time with Jalal means playing something, like kids. They are basically play dates. She expects things from Jalal. She is still stuck in past and now that Jalal has moved on; she does not know what to become of her. She is still searching for the past Jalal and still clinging to older days when he is always available to play with her. Unless she grows up and be wise, she will always be alone. But, for Jodha, spending time with Jalal means meaningful talk, discussions and basically adult conversations. Jodha does not expect anything from Jalal, other than the pleasure of his company. She stimulates his thinking and intelligent brain, his softer side and shares his vision for future kingdom.

Jalal once pondered as to why Jodha allowed a third person like Ben to come between them. The same applies to Ruq too. Why did she allow other women or in this case Jodha to become important to him? Why Ruq could not become his soul mate? Does she really love Jalal or love the idea of controlling Jalal? When did power become so important to her than Jalal?

As far as Jalal is concerned, he only knew one way of the husband and wife relationship that is between him and Ruq. But now with Jodha, he realizes that the relationship can mean something else, something caring and something tender. He has now realized what was missing in his life. And what he was expecting from Ruq is something which he got from Jodha. It feels nice to be in a give and take relationship of tenderness and caring, instead of one way road.

Love

Kshithi

PS: Sorry, I can not write small posts...😳




Kshithi missed you too 🤗
Hope you had super housewarming and are busy having fun decorating😃

Lovely post and why should you write short ones? Asking that of you would be a crime😆

I loved the point you made about Rukayya, she only wants play dates with Jalal!

Shouldn't Rukayya have grown more emotionally than Jalal no matter her exposure cos she is a woman. She faced a MC which was devastating.

Rukayya is shallow so she only SEES what she sees at surface. She decides opinion about a person and then forms her reaction to the event - especially recently.

Rukayya was so willing to believe the worst of Jodha in fake pregnancy track. Rukayya got pampered childhood and was spoilt but then so would most princesess and queens! Why would that be a JUSTIFIED reason to insult or demean others.

There are both kinds of influences in the world, Rukayya had too HB, GB, SB and now MA. Rukayya is not lacking brain so it is HER CHOICE that she is choosing to follow MA.

Of all people in Agra the ONE PERSON who should know MA is Rukayya, not even Jalal so how can she let herself be used by MA?

Loving Jalal should have come naturally to her, what stopped Rukayya from being tender and gentle with him? He trusts her so why would he not have accepted her feelings? She did not want to offer them because she was happy in her audha and being a Queen, that mattered to her more than being Jalal's wife.

Even in Ben kand, Rukayya did not try to help Jalal, she used his hurt ego and pain about the Dhakka - tried to use his feelings to drive him apart from Jodha, not to heal his pain!

Love
Maddy



Edited by MaddyO - 11 years ago
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: MaddyO



Everybody is on fire this weekend. We have got super posts which have started vigorous discussions. Mandyg, Adrinasr and now Kshithi

Kshiti missed you and will write reply to you asap but first I want to comment on very good point made by Sandhya,

Sandhya very right about the influences shaping life, Jalal has got very wide one and Jodha would have hated Mugals all her life if she had married Suryabhan. I think her hatred was not about Jalal but about what his empire can do to her Amer.

Jodha equated him with his empire which at that time was looting her temples and harming her country.

Jodha has evolved and changed for and DUE to Jalal, similarly Jalal has CHANGED due to Jodha.

Rukayy also has influence of HB, GB and especially SB. Why she could not be closer to SB?

Rukayya should have grown up faster than Jalal because firstly she is a woman, they grow faster than men emotionally. Secondly she has suffered MC and was devastated at the nature of it.

Rukayya who had brains to not trust MA earlier - why has she stopped using her brains?

Who should be most important to her Jalal or MA? Why is Ruk not listening to Jalal but MA. People graviate towards what attracts them. Why is Ruk not attracted to thoughts of SB or HB or Jalal, why only MA makes sense to her?

Jalal is very passionate and at his worst also he was always honest. Jodha is also passionate and their feelings will never be lukewarm, they hated intensely and will love intensely passionately.

Rukayya is shallow because she feels SHE HAS NO NEED TO GROW no need to learn no need to change herself. Nobody else can change you only you yourself can.

I shared this beautiful saying on another post

By Ratan Tata
"None can destroy iron, but its own rust can! Likewise none can destroy a person, but his own mindset can"
Rukayya as a person is rusting because she is not willing to change.



@ blue ... Exactly...this is because MA talks to her and Jalal doesn't nowadays. This is the exact reason why I want Jalal to speak to her...atleast one sensible heart-felt conversation...don't ask me what...I gave a half-page imaginary convo in adi's thread. 😊
MA apart from being an expert-letter-chor is also an expert-brain-washer. Remember after the dhakka, when Jo wanted to apologise to Jalal how cunningly, the lady manipulated her. Now Ruqaiya is in one of her worst grips...
@green...the wisest and best people err. The finest example is Yudhishtir of Mahabharata. The epitome of dharma did everything against dharma. Ruqaiya is neither the wisest nor the best. As I said she is only a spoilt brat.😔
@red : Ruqaiya in not rusting, but drowning. Incidentally the drowning can't save themselves. They need someone's support to get on the shore. Help from whom? who else but a best friend?
@pink : the discussions will end by this week as Ruqaiya is going to be made to descend to worse depths. Even the few who are still hanging on to the fascinating Smiley version of Ruqaiya will have nothing to defend her. 😆
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

@ blue ... Exactly...this is because MA talks to her and Jalal doesn't nowadays. This is the exact reason why I want Jalal to speak to her...atleast one sensible heart-felt conversation...don't ask me what...I gave a half-page imaginary convo in adi's thread. 😊

MA apart from being an expert-letter-chor is also an expert-brain-washer. Remember after the dhakka, when Jo wanted to apologise to Jalal how cunningly, the lady manipulated her. Now Ruqaiya is in one of her worst grips...
@green...the wisest and best people err. The finest example is Yudhishtir of Mahabharata. The epitome of dharma did everything against dharma. Ruqaiya is neither the wisest nor the best. As I said she is only a spoilt brat.😔
@red : Ruqaiya in not rusting, but drowning. Incidentally the drowning can't save themselves. They need someone's support to get on the shore. Help from whom? who else but a best friend?
@pink : the discussions will end by this week as Ruqaiya is going to be made to descend to worse depths. Even the few who are still hanging on to the fascinating Smiley version of Ruqaiya will have nothing to defend her. 😆



Sandhya if ANYBODY should know the truth about MA in entire Agra, it should be Rukayya. She never trusted her before, why is she now? Rukayya at one time used to caution Jalal against MA.
Rukayya then started playing her own brand of politics esp when she took MA's side against BK even going against HB then. Later she told MA she did it to cut his influence on Jalal.

So this Rukayya was very aware of MA's chals and how she operated. Even at the start of Ben kand when MA went to her, Rukayya told her do what you want but do not involve me!

If there is ONE thing Jalal does not like and that more than anybody Rukayya should KNOW is pettiness - He always praises her when she does something like when she refused his gift and made him give it to SB after the Ben kand. So when she knows Jalal this much why does she not do what he likes but do only what MA tells her to?

Somebody last weekend had made great post - that Rukayya had all the time in the world 10 years but she could not give Jalal what he wanted, so I do not agree about blaming Jalal.

I do not think Jalal needs to tell Rukayya about his feelings for Jodha. You would not expect Jalal to talk about him and Rukayya with Jodha!

Just being the 1st wife does not mean she gets to behave atrociously and dictate to him how he should behave, or that he needs her ok or permission to love anybody.

Jodha and Jalal started with extreme hate but found each other's love and respect.

Rukayya when she had all of Jalal's trust, faith, support and friendship - why did she come to this stage. Blaming Jalal is not done, it is her own fault, she was more interested in taking from him than giving him

Jodha did not ask Jalal to change, she did not expect him to, she did not want anything from him, it is Jalal who did it of his own free will
Similarly Rukayya should change of her own free will, not by Jalal telling her.

jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#30
gud post kshithi u described difference b/w ruku n jodha very beautifully...

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

7 months ago

Jodha recreated - A beautiful nostalgia 😍

Hello People.....Our Pari just posted her recreated Jodha look for a paid partnership promotion ... absolutely loved it ... she still captures...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".