Take 5: Top 5 countdown for Feb 20th (Pls read update on pg 15)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#91

Originally posted by: happygolucky099
ok since there is huge discussion on the dream and soul talk part ,i want to add my point

why jallu's calmness is considered as he does not know about soul talk
infact he should have been more suprised to hear jodha's description if he was unaware of it

his calm reaction can be more interpreted as his approval of the dream rather than his unawareness of it😕

It is a very good point. The more I think of it the CVs are keeping it open ended- but I am also beginning to think Jalal knows but wanted to understand what Jodha has understood so far. Thanks for joining the discussion.

Quote

MaddyO

@MaddyO

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#92

Originally posted by: divyavm

Thanks Tamy for posting from your phone - appreciate it.

As we always seem to think alike, I cannot believe how I took a more pessimistic view of the first Akdha scene. I am beginning to think Jalal did know what she was talking about. Thanks for getting me onto the same page 😊

Divya I got caught up in the discussion and forgot to write I actually loved your vent.
I like your positivity a lot but if you just like any and everything it comes across as you refusing to see negatives.

So don't worry about vent, that after writing that you went to positives is even bigger thing.

I don't think we should hold back our views, then what is the point of writing here freely

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

staker123

@staker123

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#93

Originally posted by: divyavm

It is a very good point. The more I think of it the CVs are keeping it open ended- but I am also beginning to think Jalal knows but wanted to understand what Jodha has understood so far. Thanks for joining the discussion.

i just liked various points put by member so could not restrict myself😳

Quote

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#94

Thank you so much for the beautiful re-telling of the scene. Loved your point that in fear of rejection he is hesitating to say that what she thinks is a dream is true!

Loved the part I have underlined below!

QUOTE]

Dear.. let me tell you what cv's potrayed...

Hakim:Jodha was n her death bed n unconscious... ..thats when hakim told jalal that she is not responding to any medicines..she lost all hopes to live...so she is not fighting agianst vish..

jalal:he realised its only him who can bring her back..so he did say takliya to every one..remember...next min he said aanke koliye jodha begum...next authoritatively he repeated the same words...this is not his soul..its jalal who told jodha who is sleeping peavefully...then he said hum aapko jane nahi denge.he was hodling her hands...

Jodha's soul: jodha's soul left her body n started to go to another world...she is listening to his words..but her soul left her body..she cud listen to what jalal was saying..then her soul realised that jalal was hodling jodha's hands n not allowing her to go...with continuous pleas...then

Jodha's soul:Chod dijiye hume jane dijiye hume...

Jalal:hum apko jane nahi denge...

Jodha's soul:can hear his words..thinking its he who is stopping her not to leave him...her soul said to him u dont even want to see my face...even if i die also..leave me i hv to go n i am happy..i fulfilled all my responsiblities n vanchans...

Jalal:he was still crying that she is not responding ..out fo fear in real he did confess his feelings to unconscious jo..first he confessed to god n dargah..now jodha when she was not n her senses..

Jodha's soul:since her soul left her body hence her soul thinks thats jalal did confess n her dreams..

Jalal:later he said u gave me this life..ilo live only with u..if not il not..god save my jodha...

Jodha's soul:when she was happy with his confession n got a reason to live she came back to this world back...

Jodha(n this world):after she opens her eyes he found jalal was next to her holding her hands..she thoght what ever happened was its her dream..but in reality its jalal's confession n pleas made her to come back..

Jalal:he knows abut his confession..so todya he kept quite coz he wanted to no n c how jo feels.use kya kya yad hain..but again his bad luck she thinks it as dreams..thats y wen jo was saying about this dream he was not shocked..he was pleasent n calm n happy that its he n his love who forced her to come back..did u notice moti wen jo was syaign about this dream i cud see the pain n her face...so for jodha its a dream..for jalal its reality..what will he say no jodha begum its not dream..i did confess mmy love ..he is scared of another rejection..so he noticed her every talk ..now he is sure she is happy with his confession..but he doesnt no if she loves him or not..hence he kept quite...

I hope this gives u clarity..for jalal its not dream...for jodha its dream...one day he il accept that it was not her dream..its real..that he did confess his love to her...

Gud n8..bye...c u tmw..

Quote

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#95

Originally posted by: happygolucky099

i just liked various points put by member so could not restrict myself😳

Never restrict yourself- all are welcome to comment in this thread. Hope to see you back!

Quote

staker123

@staker123

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#96

Originally posted by: divyavm

Never restrict yourself- all are welcome to comment in this thread. Hope to see you back!

i will be here from now on 😳

Quote

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#97

Originally posted by: rima4ever
beautiful and lovely takes divya
i am very disappointed with the episode

Thanks for liking the post!

Sorry you were disappointed!

Best,

Divya

Edited by divyavm - 11 years ago

Quote

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#98

Originally posted by: surjyotapa
I was eagerly waiting for your post for some hope, feeling horrible since 8:30 pm ... cvs ruined everything. They made Jalal a liar who lied in front of 'Allah'.
Sujamal entry is good , I love this character, always feel bad for him, Bharmal is responsible for his misfortune, he ruined his life. His love for jodha is so pure, that he will sacrifice his life to save jalal. Great character.
I think this time MU will be in a different way, here sujamal is planing to attack Mughals and if Jodha meets him that will be a 'gaddari' ... probably this time Jalal will not doubt her character, he will punish her for meeting an enemy ... I am afraid 'ghamashan' is near, Maham is calm this is not a good sign either.
I hope I am wrong...everything is fine... Jalal is not using Jodha to make ruku jealous, jodha will not meet Sujamal alone...

Thanks for posting. I loved your interpretations of things I have seen on other threads- on both the tarazu and justice.

Hopefully, we have more to cheer about today!

Keep posting!

Quote

Shraddha

@lashy

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#99

I'm still trying to get my head around it all Divya... I'm seeing so many different versions.. so many different theories (some positive, many negative) in the forum, I'm confused myself!

I agree with you on the stagnation and deliberate brakes on the love story...

I mean they haven't gone back...but I'm totally confused as to what stages they are at...

While the scenes you've outlined themselves are cute.. because of these looming doubts in the background its difficult to enjoy the scenes wholeheartedly!

And Jalal confuses us (and the CVs themselves too me thinks) some times I feel they mould/shift his characterization as and when to suit the TRPs and the tracks... because in 1 track he behaves one way and in another another way and its very very unpredictable!

Surely there are no theories Akbar suffered from MPD, or were there? 😆 I have to go back to Abhay's posts to refer to that one...

Quote

divyavm

@divyavm

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#100

Originally posted by: kmmdesai
Hi Divya,

Finally able to write now. 😃
Great post as usual. 👏
Replies are inline. Check it out.

Thanks for posting!

Love
Kshithi