..::Doubts & Discussions about Historical facts::.. - Page 108

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

257.3k

Users

170

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

9908331951 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
kaash we had time machine yaar. i feel it is really necessary
IshqHaiWoEhsaas thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
Lol...you girls are rocking...😆⭐️

@Jiya di and Rev... Thanks for the lovely comments...totally agree...😳 Especially that MUZ - Akbar have a love story that has redefined love. ❤️


Since all discussions are taking place here, let me quote my post here from the other thread...😆


So this has begun again...


One year since the show ended, and people are still trying to prove that the JA story was a fake! 😆



Real pen, even if what you say is right, even if Daniyal wasn't Mariam-Uz-Zamani's son, how does this prove that Jodha Akbar's story is a fake, as you have mentioned in bold in your post?


Did Shah Jahan not have children from his other wives...What then proves his love for Mumtaz Mahal? Just because he built a beautiful mausoleum for his wife, does that become a criteria to determine love?


PS : It doesn't make a big difference to my belief on the story of JA whether Daniyal was MUZ's son or not. Having children from other ladies was more like a norm those days...it doesn't change the fact that MUZ was an influential lady, and held a special place both in Akbar's personal life and the Empire. If anything, this just goes on to prove how highly Akbar held the people of Amer, since he trusted them with the responsibility of taking care of a child who wasn't their daughter's own!

There is a reason why the relation between Jodha and Akbar is still remembered and we're watching shows and films on it. Not every story needs a huge mausoleum to prove itself.

No use making threads here and wasting your and our time, this is a forum which celebrates the royal couple's anniversary! ⭐️


If the Thread Maker still hasn't understood that it's no use posting here...then I don't know...😆

And @sujaatha, Do you really think the peeps here are blind fans of the actors who are wasting their precious time just to defend the characters their loved actors played? 😲 Lol... if you think so, then...😆
jojaparijat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
As i said Akbar marrying even after his marriage to Jodha does not set the criteria to call JA's love story fake or call him Akbar a womanizer..If having many begums is d criteria to call a man a womanizer,then all kings/men in that era were a womanizer.

As a Rajput princess ,Jodha has been taught from childhood that King has d r8 to marry n have many wives..so there is no question of her stopping Akbar.

About Akbar marrying so many even after his marriage to Jodha,then most of them were political alliance n many among them Rajput princess itself so that he could have Rajputana under him through friendly alliance then going for a blood bath.

U r saying Sahjahan did not marry anyone after Mumtaaz..But i have heard stories of him having a eye on his wives sister ..Another thing is not marrying anyone after mumtaaz d only criteria to decide he is a 1 man women?..How sure r u that he was not physical with other bwgums,concubines or any other women.

Now about Salim,he not only loved Nurjahan but all of the women coming on his way during different stages of life..He fell for Maan bai,Jagat n many others ..He constructed so many monuments for each one of them.
Noorjahan came into his life very much later in his life not when he was young..He already has done everything he could by then so of him not marrying after Noorjahan does not make any difference..He was already under the influence of alchol/drugs so not in his full senses & Noorjahan was a shrewd lady,she made him a puppet.

A man forcefully having a women by killing his husband & a women who made his husband a puppet for her personal gains can not be termed as Two people greatly in love. 😆

Rest i have already made a comment above on Love in polygamy!
jojaparijat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: sujaatha


yes what your saying is right. Dont get carried away by media read ancient books to know the truth and facts instead of fighting with people who try to give facts. Media is only a tool for us to go and look back at the real history if we give history as it is in media people may not look at it so fiction is added but please the real history is still there. So please go back and read ancient real books not whats there is internet and argue and waste time . I also visited real pens blog he/she has told some facts. Why not reserach on it instead of fighting.

I hope u understand the difference between a fight & debate..In that case u r trying to fight & forcing ur point on others..I m talking about historian/reasearchers & ur talking about media. 😆
jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: jojaparijat

As i said Akbar marrying even after his marriage to Jodha does not set the criteria to call JA's love story fake or call him Akbar a womanizer..If having many begums is d criteria to call a man a womanizer,then all kings/men in that era were a womanizer.

As a Rajput princess ,Jodha has been taught from childhood that King has d r8 to marry n have many wives..so there is no question of her stopping Akbar.

About Akbar marrying so many even after his marriage to Jodha,then most of them were political alliance n many among them Rajput princess itself so that he could have Rajputana under him through friendly alliance then going for a blood bath.

U r saying Sahjahan did not marry anyone after Mumtaaz..But i have heard stories of him having a eye on his wives sister ..Another thing is not marrying anyone after mumtaaz d only criteria to decide he is a 1 man women?..How sure r u that he was not physical with other bwgums,concubines or any other women.

Now about Salim,he not only loved Nurjahan but all of the women coming on his way during different stages of life..He fell for Maan bai,Jagat n many others ..He constructed so many monuments for each one of them.
Noorjahan came into his life very much later in his life not when he was young..He already has done everything he could by then so of him not marrying after Noorjahan does not make any difference..He was already under the influence of alchol/drugs so not in his full senses & Noorjahan was a shrewd lady,she made him a puppet.

A man forcefully having a women by killing his husband & a women who made his husband a puppet for her personal gains can not be termed as Two people greatly in love. 😆

Rest i have already made a comment above on Love in polygamy!



Just wnt to add reason of shahjanha's death which i heard in discovery channel's documentary on Taj Mahal is over consumption of Viagra so as TM of this thread has more believe in media,blogs n article so wht this info by discovery make shahjanha great true lover of mumtaz or womanizer till his last breath...
P.S. like jodha akbar i believe in shahjanha mumtaz n other story of that era on the basis of authentic books i read nt wht is media said or wht info some blog or article gv...
harshu27 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: jiya.k



Just wnt to add reason of shahjanha's death which i heard in discovery channel's documentary on Taj Mahal is over consumption of Viagra so as TM of this thread has more believe in media,blogs n article so wht this info by discovery make shahjanha great true lover of mumtaz or womanizer till his last breath...
P.S. like jodha akbar i believe in shahjanha mumtaz n other story of that era on the basis of authentic books i read nt wht is media said or wht info some blog or article gv...

ppl get carried away for shahjahan mumtaz's love jst coz of d taj mahal but i feel he waited for her to die to proclaim his love by building taj mahal whereas JA silently made a love story without any materialistic approach...der was purely spiritual...😳
IshqHaiWoEhsaas thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: harshu27

ppl get carried away for shahjahan mumtaz's love jst coz of d taj mahal but i feel he waited for her to die to proclaim his love by building taj mahal whereas JA silently made a love story without any materialistic approach...der was purely spiritual...😳


Exactly di... I believe the same. If ShahJahan gave his wife a beautiful mausoleum, Akbar gave his Mariam-Uz-Zamani a beautiful life! ❤️ And that's what makes all the difference...😳
harshu27 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: -AkDha.Lover-


Exactly di... I believe the same. If ShahJahan gave his wife a beautiful mausoleum, Akbar gave his Mariam-Uz-Zamani a beautiful life! ❤️ And that's what makes all the difference...😳

dats wat is imp shagun when u r alive if u r going to get to live a beautiful life u will have a peaceful death wat else u want coz after death no one knows wat happens to d person etc...so wen d person is alive he/she has to lead a wonderful life and dat is wat JA had😳
IshqHaiWoEhsaas thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
^^^ Yup true di...and that is why I so love this story. This is the perfect love story! ❤️


In fact the only story I ever liked...I mostly find love stories really OTT...😆


But JA is something entirely different...it's the kind of love you don't get to see everyday...Spiritual love! ❤️
sujaatha thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: jojaparijat

I hope u understand the difference between a fight & debate..In that case u r trying to fight & forcing ur point on others..I m talking about historian/reasearchers & ur talking about media. 😆

yes even i am saying about history and nice your taking it as a debate read your first line did you not talk about the internet same i have written lol😆😛

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".