Jodha Akbar 160: Cat and mouse game with the ghrinit jantu - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

116

Views

12k

Users

34

Likes

360

Frequent Posters

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#41
Thank you, Meghana.

I am glad to find someone who is also not at all happy with the Jodha-getting-bitten track. Lashy and the rest have been bombarding me with counter arguments till I have had to duck for cover! I hope the eventual sorting out is less cliched and more elegant.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: meghanajain

The line below made me laugh, only you can come with such humor Shyamala. But, you are so right. Jalal understands that Jodha is one stubborn lady and does not give up easily. That look may be made him understand that even if I challenge her openly, she will continue with her mission to save him from Ben. Its good that Jalal knows that this stubbornness is not just for him only. As MS informed him in Amer, how Jodha always broke the rules and did what she wanted to do.
I am sure that glare - which she met with an unwavering butter-will-not-melt-in-my-mouth look back till he turned away

I do not want the guilty majnu Jalal either, so am praying that Jo does not get bitten. I would instead like Jalal realizing that Jodha loves her, all the running she did was only because she was very concerned about his life. Then, with his trademark smirks and flirty looks he questions Jodha in every possible way about her feelings.

Ariel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Don't fret so much, my dear, and read my comments above re: Salima and Hamida. And Jodha too, of course.

I am delighted to have you here again. Why should you apologise? I would like you to drop in whenever you have the time and the inclination, that is all.

I love your posts, the pleasure is mine actually 😳

I have not watched any of Ekta's serials except Pavitra Rishta. Jodha is like a combo of the 2 paragons there, Archana and Purvi.

No, my dear, given the way in which she got married to him,and the differences of faith, culture and upbringing between them. for Jodha to be blindly and one-sidedly in love with Jalal would not be realistic. It has to come by stages.

I agree, it will and has to come in stages but I do hope that it happens one day and that the bachao Jalal campaign is a step in that direction. But the manner in which the character of Jodha is sketched, I have my doubts. We are more about women standing up for themselves than for giving themselves up for a reason. Both are acceptable ways to be I suppose.

And yes, a man with so many responsibilities and wives can be biased towards and wrapped up one person, one of the aforesaid many wives. Dasharatha was obsessed with Kaikeyi, Jahagir with Nurjahan and Shah Jahan with Mumtaz.

I am not good at history, but I'm sure you know many emperors like Akbar. What I meant was for a ruler like Akbar it seems less plausible to me. But who knows. The kings you mentioned, I do not regard highly as rulers. They were more men who were ruled by their hearts, not Akbar I would presume who was more just. I feel for us as viewers (read me) it would be more acceptable to see Jodhas journey from a repulsed wife to loyal passionate one while Jalal remained the same good man that he always was. Anyway, I cant find the words to express what I'm trying to say here. 😔

As for why Salima falls for Jodha, it is because Jodha is a transparently good person - so instantly loving to little Rahim, which is the surest way to his mother's heart! - and not given to backbiting, plotting and scheming to do others down, or to oneupmanship. It is true that Jodha's goodness and kindness vanish when it comes to Jalal, but when his own mother, Hamida Banu, does not seem bothered about that, why would Salima be bothered an d blame Jodha for that?

I meant if she has reason to believe Jodha, she also has reason to believe Jalal. She also reason to believe Ben is good when she hasn't seen anything yet. So why suspect her? The only thing that makes sense is that she investigates every cause that may be a threat to Jalal. Not necessarily believe Jodha.

But as a mother myself I completely agree with you have said in red.It makes complete sense about why she takes to Jodha.


For Salima, who has been sheltered all her life by Bairam Khan, Jodha must seem like an oasis in the harsh desert of the harem and its squabbling inmates. No wonder she takes to Jodha.

Once again, do not let this show get so much under your skin. It is not worth it.No show is.

Shyamala Aunty

lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Thank you, Meghana.

I am glad to find someone who is also not at all happy with the Jodha-getting-bitten track. Lashy and the rest have been bombarding me with counter arguments till I have had to duck for cover! I hope the eventual sorting out is less cliched and more elegant.

kuch bhi aunty 😆
____________________________

Hmmm waise, can a man not be dignified (and not turn into a doormat) when depicting care towards for his wife and repenting for his recent mistakes... or is that much to ask for? 🤔

and cheee...NEVER will I be '' over a romeo Shehenshah who's always ''
I want a guy who's -> 😛 + 😉 + 😎 + on the outside and in the deepest darkest parts of his zehen that only lashy can read 😆
Edited by lashy - 11 years ago
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Sandhya, now this is not being tenacious, it is being pigheaded!😉

I do not remember about yesterday, for he was already seated in the DEK when they began the session, but in the one with the milk test and the awaam getting after the GJ (ghrinit jantu) there were 2 DEK sessions and each time Jalal lugged his shamsheer along, though I never understand this universal practice in those days for the aristocracy and royalty. As I remember writing to you, even my mother remarked that both tiimes, as he came in, he was carrying it in his right hand,but as soon as he was seated, he switched it to his left.

You have developed selective amnesia, my child!

Shyamala Aunty


🤣. The dunce-headedness of jalal of late is making me pigheaded in frustration.

Yes I rewatched that milk test day entry into the dek. It was there.😲

I must hereafter limit my lament to its having become a decorative addendum to his shaahi libaas like his pearls and opulent coat and nothing more than that.😕

I was shocked at salima/hb to allow continued danger to jalal so that jo will get complete credit. Of all hb's partiality to her bahu and lack of concern for her son this was the worst. The real hb must also be squirming in her grave now.

Why does jalal enjoy bickering between his wives over him? Feeling important? Silly. Even earlier he used to tell ruqaiya 'jalna chaahiye'. Yesterday he was so pleased.

Aunty, you probably didn't see my response in pg 2 or may be you didn't like it. 😕

And who is this Kamaal Khan that GJ went to meet? Has he been mentioned earlier? And how will he know how to free abul mali? And how has abul mali made arrangement for kk and gj to meet? Well in the mughal prison anything is possible though.

Edited by Sandhya.A - 11 years ago
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: lashy

kuch bhi aunty 😆
____________________________

Hmmm waise, can a man not be dignified (and not turn into a doormat) when depicting care towards for his wife and repenting for his recent mistakes... or is that much to ask for? 🤔
😆

Jalal has always cared for jo though he may not have put it in so many words just as jo is for the first time caring for jalal now and refusing to admit the bedrock truth.

And yes both of them have made mistakes.

As far as repenting and apologizing is concerned we are yet to see jodha apologize for the narnaal fiasco, 'go die anywhere except Amer' or even the recent skll and 'mh aapse achhe hain'. Agreed that public insults hurt more than insults in private. But does that mean that personal insults when unwarranted don't require to be apologized or repented? The only time jo apologized was after the fake pregnancy track.

Seeing all the apologies and repentance coming only from jalal for every mistake on his part and none from jo for her many ones does make jalal look like a doormat

(Jo is beginning to overcome her prejudices now.When both repent and apologize both make up may be 100 episodes later this epic mahaan love story will begin to start to develop.😛)

Edited by Sandhya.A - 11 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#46
Lashy dear,

@red.
Yes he can, it all lies in HOW he does it, and I do not think the CVs will opt for anything but the most unmitigated mush.

@blue
. Yes, my dear occlumens, and I was looking for your explanation of Jalal's wicked reactions to Ruqaiya chewing out Jodha. I take it that you did not give us the benefit of your views on that, but I do wish you would remember to PM me as and when you write anything.

As for me. I was in stitches watching him; he was looking at Jodha to see if she would react and assert her right to stay there. Wonder what he would have done if she had done precisely that? Got up and pushed off, I expect, leaving the two to pull each other's hair out, not literally, of course. As I wrote earlier here, Jalal loves it when women quarrel over him.

The story is sprouting unexpected shoots, like the poisoned well and Adham landing up on the GJ, I refuse to believe that it was only to drool over her (downmarket) husn, whatever Meghana might say to the contrary. Wait and watch.

And yes, I would like the coords for that modern JA love story of yours.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: lashy


Hmmm waise, can a man not be dignified (and not turn into a doormat) when depicting care towards for his wife and repenting for his recent mistakes... or is that much to ask for? 🤔

and cheee...NEVER will I be '' over a romeo Shehenshah who's always ''
I want a guy who's -> 😛 + 😉 + 😎 + on the outside and in the deepest darkest parts of his zehen that only lashy can read 😆

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Thank you, Meghana.

I am glad to find someone who is also not at all happy with the Jodha-getting-bitten track. Lashy and the rest have been bombarding me with counter arguments till I have had to duck for cover! I hope the eventual sorting out is less cliched and more elegant.

kuch bhi aunty 😆
____________________________

adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#47
Shyamala, Jodha never has claimed the position of a wife yet, while TE has given her the right of both wife and royal queen and he did it way back in Amer itself.


Jodha has been pulling rank as queen till now. The first time she accpeted TE as husband is only after she realised the danger to his life from KT. If you recall she has always called herself Begum never Patni everytime she pulled rank including the occasions you pointed out. The time she came to Ruqu to warn TE of KT being Vishkanya, again she used the term Begum and not Patni. Infact in the DEK scene where TE declares the shaadi with KT, it was Ruqu who used the term Biwi while pulling her up. TE once again protected her by using the term Begum and here he did point out that she too has used the Begum bit to pull rank and has failed as a Queen - he never has talked of her as a wife in public - even when he questioned her on that dhakozlebaazi, it was only btwn the two of them. Infact now I am truly wondering, if at any point, did TE actually insult Jodha in public???? and I am including the DEK of Ram Tanu's musical night!!! I am really really wondering!!!

Only twice has Jodha done any of the wifely stuff of her own - the tel maalish (pehli baar she did as she did not want to disappoint TE by telling him it was her and not Ruqu and here lets go of her claim as wife the minute Ruqu came and 2nd time was not on her own. TE once again made her do so by claiming his rts as a husband forcing her to do her wifely duty which she once again let go as soon as Shivani left.) and Yesterday when she brought the lep as a wife wanting to take care of her husband.

Yes I agree with you that had she stayed it would have been a catfight and hence she made an exit to maintain dignity, yet I felt that she could have made a point to TE had she been in the mood to be a wife and claim her rights which could have been done silently (maybe we need a more perceptive director perhaps).

And yes Jalal would never interfere when 2 women fight over him since as you very correctly put it 'he enjoys it' but till date it has always been Ruqu who has told everyone off by claiming her position - not as his wife but as his Chief Queen - I feel he is still waiting for the moment when someone claims HIM as a man and as a husband - has not happened yet!!!

I agree that finally she is taking the baby steps - yesterday she was upset that she was not allowed to be a wife to her husband!!!! This is progress indeed!!! Infact she is not going to claim anything now - I have a feeling the creatives are going to make her claim the position of Beloved, Lover, Wife and Queen all together.


Originally posted by: sashashyam

Very nice and elegantly expounded, Adiana. but @blue is not true.

Not only does Jodha constantly assert to others, when it suits her to claim the rank, that she is Shahenshah ki Begum, but she says that to Ruqaiya as well when she is trying to meet Jalal in Ruqaiya's room and is told by her that she is the Begum-e-Khaas. Jodha then retorts I am also his Begum.

She tells Jalal the same thing when she is helping Rahim fly a kite and Jalal comes up to them. She says then I am your begum, and I do not need any reason to meet you and talk to you. Of course that was before The Letter and The Shove.

So Jodha never hesitates to claim her position as his wife when it suits her, but backs off when it comes to fulfilling the responsibilities that go with it.

Today, I do not think she could have asserted herself vis a vis Ruqaiya without descending to an undignified catfight. I think she left gracefully, with her dignity intact, and of course Ruqaiya was appallingly rude.

Jalal would never interfere when 2 women fight over him - not that Jodha was fighting here - he enjoys it. Moreover, the anger against Jodha is still there within him, lurking in the wings.Whence the oblique barb directed at Jodha while being ostensibly meant for Ruqaiya I know that you are really worried about me, you are not just doing it for show. It registers, and there a flicker of hurt in Jodha's eyes.

The main change in Jodha of late it that no matter what Jalal does or how he behaves with her, she does not fume and rage as she used to do. She might wipe away a surreptitious tear, as she did today, but she does not flag in her single minded focus on protecting his life, and as she herself confesses today, she is never upset with him and she continues to fret about his safety.

Baby steps,but she will get there!

I found what Salima tells Hamida - that they should not interfere in the Jalal-Benazir affairs as Jodha was tackling it energetically and she should get the full credit with Jalal for striving so hard to save his life - so stupid as to take one's breath away.

Here is a vishkanya who will look for every opportunity to come close to the Shahenshah and assassinate him,, guards or no guards. Jodha is not a sarvavyapi, so how can she make sure she is around every single time the GJ (ghrinit jantu) makes yet another attempt? Instead of tackling the matter head on, and Hamida Banu is the only one who can do so by right, Salima wants her to back off so that Jodha can get all the credit for trying to protect him. Now how irresponsible and idiotic is that ?

Let us hope they at least manage to exploit the poisoned well revelation properly.

As for Adham Khan, I suspect he is going to try and encourage the GJ on to eliminate Jalal, with the promise that she can then become the Malika thru him! Or else he might ask her to kill Jalal, and offer to help free Abul Malu in return for that.

Anyhow, 2 new and promising developments. Not bad!

Shyamala

Edited by adianasr - 11 years ago

adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#48
Shyamala, I too will join you and Meghana and pray that Jodha does not get bitten!!! Would prefer both TE and Chudail IMAGINE what life would be in such a scenario - as they say Imagination can play havoc with the senses better than reality!!!

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Thank you, Meghana.

I am glad to find someone who is also not at all happy with the Jodha-getting-bitten track. Lashy and the rest have been bombarding me with counter arguments till I have had to duck for cover! I hope the eventual sorting out is less cliched and more elegant.

Shyamala

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
Sandhya, I think Lashy's drama queen habits are contagious, for now, here you are complaining that I have not replied to your comment on page 2! Exactly as Kashi (ginco) used to do earlier. And the fact is that I reply to your comments more often that to those of anyone else. What a bunch of kids you all are!😉

I usually start responding from the last page (the last one when I start) and work my way backwards.Meanwhile, more comments come in. I am now at page 4, I think,and I never have enough time to finish them all unless I do not post for 2-3 days.

Don't worry, as I am not writing anything today about No.161, I will reply to yours on page 2 this afternoon. Now I have to go give my mother her morning meal, and the painters are after me as well - the whole 10 storey building is being repainted, along with anti-pigeon netting, installation of fire retardant doors, covering of the terrace ducts and redoing the walkway behind the terrace swimming pool Of course I am Chairperson of our condominium! I was interrupted over 50 times, literally, during the 4-5 hours that I took to finish this post. No kidding!

As for Salima and Hamida last night, here is what I wrote to Adiana on page 5. You would like the rest of those comments as well.

I found what Salima tells Hamida - that they should not interfere in the Jalal-Benazir affairs as Jodha was tackling it energetically and she should get the full credit with Jalal for striving so hard to save his life - so stupid as to take one's breath away.

Here is a vishkanya who will look for every opportunity to come close to the Shahenshah and assassinate him,, guards or no guards. Jodha is not a sarvavyapi, so how can she make sure she is around every single time the GJ (ghrinit jantu) makes yet another attempt? Instead of tackling the matter head on, and Hamida Banu is the only one who can do so by right, Salima wants her to back off so that Jodha can get all the credit for trying to protect him. Now how irresponsible and idiotic is that ?

I take it that you want Jalal to swing his shamsheer around in the DEK just to make sure it is not so rusty that it has got stuck in its scabbard!😉

I was in stitches watching his wicked reactions when Ruqaiya was chewing Jodha out; he was looking at Jodha to see if she would assert her right to stay there. Wonder what he would have done if she had done precisely that? Got up and pushed off, I expect, leaving the two to pull each other's hair out, not literally, of course. As I wrote earlier here, Jalal loves it when women quarrel over him.

OK, I am off now. More later, kid.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A


🤣. The dunce-headedness of jalal of late is making me pigheaded in frustration.

Yes I rewatched that milk test day entry into the dek. It was there.😲

I must hereafter limit my lament to its having become a decorative addendum to his shaahi libaas like his pearls and opulent coat and nothing more than that.😕

I was shocked at salima/hb to allow continued danger to jalal so that jo will get complete credit. Of all hb's partiality to her bahu and lack of concern for her son this was the worst. The real hb must also be squirming in her grave now.

Why does jalal enjoy bickering between his wives over him? Feeling important? Silly. Even earlier he used to tell ruqaiya 'jalna chaahiye'. Yesterday he was so pleased.

Aunty, you probably didn't see my response in pg 2 or may be you didn't like it. 😕

And who is this Kamaal Khan that GJ went to meet? Has he been mentioned earlier? And how will he know how to free abul mali? And how has abul mali made arrangement for kk and gj to meet? Well in the mughal prison anything is possible though.

Edited by sashashyam - 11 years ago
adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#50
I agree that both TE and Chudail will be in love when the creatives make them say so!!!! Very aptly put!!!


Originally posted by: Ariel


Hi Adiana,

I love your take on this. But I'm hesitant to take it seriously. I think CVs write things and then forget about it.

He did this to Ruqs too. There was a time when he taunted her about her being jealous and when she said no I'm not jealous he said to her that she should be jealous. All that needless taunting led to nothing and we never got an explanation for it. Even at that point he seemed very much like he was urging to Ruqs to take their relationship beyond friendship. And she never got the point.

I always wondered why he pretended to not sense what Ruqs feels for him. I was hoping that was what it (i mean taunting) would lead to and him saying he regrets never giving her the love of a husband but alas that was not to be.

So I am hesitant to think that he is really giving her a third chance. He is in love when CVs say he is and the same goes for Jodha. It will be sudden, much like the bachao Jalaal campaign. 😕

Sorry if a sound like a buzzkill. I would be happy to be wrong.

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha recreated - A beautiful nostalgia 😍

Hello People.....Our Pari just posted her recreated Jodha look for a paid partnership promotion ... absolutely loved it ... she still captures...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".