Akbar-Ruqs-False Monogamy.Pt2JA Not fiction.Upd-p10,16,18,Ruqs34+35+36

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

myviewprem

@myviewprem

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#151

Is there any book where we can read the details of childhood of Salim and Khurram. Its missing in akbarnama and jehangirnama

Quote

KDR81

@KDR81

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

#152

Originally posted by: myviewprem

I think

Akbar shaved his head at Jiji anga and Hamida Bano's death not MAs

At MAs death he walked a certain distance with her body

Also Prince Salim was exiled twice once to Afghanistan and once for 3 years to Rajasthan at Salim Mahal do you know why?

Hi,
Can u give me the exact year of the exile ? I mean the Alwar exile date...😊

I am not sure of date. In summer holidays this year we went to Alwar to see tigers and to a fort in Alwar called Bala Fort. So there there is Salim Mahal, Salim Pond etc and we were told Jehangir stayed there in exile for 3 years. Babur and Akbar also stayed there sometime. The fort has 6 gates. I just asked if you have a idea. I did not check anywhere about it. Were the people just saying like that?

Hi Dear,
The fort u r talking abt is better known as Bala Qila...and was a property of Kachhwada Rajputs...and PR was better associated with it...Babur and Humayun stayed there....Not Akbar...😊..Since it was something from Salim's maternal side(Amer Kacchwada Rajputs) and from the name it appears that (most probably)it was something which had a direct link with Bharmal and hence to Heera and Salim consequently....Hope u know that Bharmal's mother's name was Bala Bai...😊 So the serial's DADISA is our Rajmata Bala Bai here...
The Salim Mahal was built for Salim to stay...during his exile...
I asked u abt the date because the guides there must have given u the approximate date ...and if I get the date I can probably tell u the reason of the 😃exile too...!!

Edited by KDR81 - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mdeshpande

@mdeshpande

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#153

Wow, Amazing work guys!! 👍🏼 👍🏼 👍🏼

👏 👏 👏 👏

Quote

Abhay

@history_geek

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

#154

Originally posted by: mdeshpande
Wow, Amazing work guys!! 👍🏼 👍🏼 👍🏼
👏 👏 👏 👏

👍🏼..

Edited by history_geek - 11 years ago

Quote

philantus01

@philantus01

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#155

Originally posted by: history_geek

well...🤣
👏

it seems, the thread is soon turning out to be the best debating place on the forum...⭐️
grt...
v all seem 2 engage each 1 here...in some sort of clarification..😆

nyways, m sure i ll b able to clear ur doubt between love and respect...
coz, d sort of findings i have till date...
r enough 2 convince me and ( other 2 geeks..😆...who already are also engaged in deep grilling..) about dere relation (i mean JA..)..

d example, which u quoted here, salima-jalal, will remain as it is,...till end..based on respect ONLY..

"
frm personal point: i myself hate a person to d core but still i respect his/her view point...
"
i hope the above lines, were not directed at me...😆

btw,
the sort of interaction between JA will change...it's too early to take conclusions..
meanwhile, v all will keep posting info here...for clarification.😊..

actually my basis for offering a tough stand to their relation (JA)...👍🏼..is not only the memoirs of Indian historians.!!..

i am taking this tough stand coz, i will also quote instances from Portuguese, British and even memoirs of German Historian..in my support...

nyways, the positive point is we are in a HEALTHY KNOWLEDGE sharing discussion which is the biggest achievement of this forum..⭐️..

thnx to ALL the people for being here..👍🏼.
and making this discussion a success...

😆😆 oh dear dat was not for u...d person i was talkin abt i know him personally...u knoe wht i love it whn i contradict wid ur views...n we always hav a healthy debate on dat n u always make sure dat u come wid new proofs n sumthing to prove me wrong...😆😆

Quote

Ananya

@ann2012

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#156

Great work people! Your dedication to this issue is incredible. 👏👏

Please keep it up! I really look forward to your posts.

You mentioned in one of the earlier comments that you tried to edit the wiki page and it was reverted back to it's original state after a few hours. When did you do the wiki edit? Trying doing it again, it is really important for unbiased info to reach the internet at large.

The wiki page has become stable-ish these days and the info is also better sourced. I don't think refrenced content will be removed now. Though I agree there seemed to be some users trying to degrade the page continuosly. They seem to have stopped recently.

Quote

Abhay

@history_geek

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

#157

Originally posted by: history_geek
hi.😊
it has not stopped..!!

regarding the palaces which akbar built for MUZ...
none of wiki******'s page mention it, except a slight reference to MUZ palace in fatehpur sikri..
that too incomplete..!!..

take example..::
from another set of pages dealing wid another fort where she stayed, her name has no reference..!!..
instead now the page reads that it belonged to nur jahan and jahangir...!!!!LOL..
also dt page now has content of just 12 lines...wid no reference to MUZ or akbar...!!!..
it has been edited 15-20 times after release of movie JA..!!!!!!Confused

all dis will be discussed in future discussions..sometime...if psbl...
wid all details of that fort..😊

all 3 of us have already commented about the sort of commercial propoganda out there...

and yes, the info we write can be verified...
we give d references.for all dat v write..!!

this "business" runs quite deep.!!!
this will never stop...Confused
atleast this forum is there, where it can be written.!!!

this story has only critics , very few followers...

Quote

myviewprem

@myviewprem

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#158

Originally posted by: KDR81

I think

Akbar shaved his head at Jiji anga and Hamida Bano's death not MAs

At MAs death he walked a certain distance with her body

Also Prince Salim was exiled twice once to Afghanistan and once for 3 years to Rajasthan at Salim Mahal do you know why?

Hi,
Can u give me the exact year of the exile ? I mean the Alwar exile date...😊

Hi Dear,
The fort u r talking abt is better known as Bala Qila...and was a property of Kachhwada Rajputs...and PRC was better associated with it...Babur and Humayun stayed there....Not Akbar...😊..Since it was something from Salim's maternal side(Amer Kacchwada Rajputs) and from the name it appears that (most probably)it was something which had a direct link with Bharmal and hence to Heera and Salim consequently....Hope u know that Bharmal's mother's name was Bala Bai...😊 So the serial's DADISA is our Rajmata Bala Bai here...
The Salim Mahal was built for Salim to stay...during his exile...
I asked u abt the date because the guides there must have given u the approximate date ...and if I get the date I can probably tell u the reason of the 😃exile too...!!

to be honest i do not remember much or bother of what they said, in those days i was not bothered about akbar and jehangir or jodha as after this serial 😆 next time i go to historical places i will give more ears to these things. who knows another historical may start and i may get curious.

Indeed this exile thing also my brother reminded me that guides told us that when we visited i had totally ignored it. Its only because of this serial i am interested in akbar-jehangir-jodha.

Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago