Tell me one thing, Ela. YOU say the groom's party is being absolutely honest, but
how would Jalal know that? He thinks they are lying, and let us not trot out the Rajvanshis never lie nonsense. They have lied often enough, from the days of Jaichand downwards. I cannot understand why the Rajputs protest against this serial, which glorifies them far more than history warrants.
It is not that Jalal trusts Sharifuddin blindly, whatever he might say to Jodha.
It is rather that he cannot see what he would stand to gain from such a charade, as he says to Hamida Banu. At first sight, no rational person would be able to understand WHY Sharifuddin would want to take such a risk for no visible gain. It is the same with Jalal. He is absolutely logical in what he says to his mother. In fact, I too found it very strange that he is doing it merely to take revenge on the Amer royals, plus damaging the Jalal-Jodha relationship, but at a very great risk to himself if ever he should be found out.
Secondly, the way in which Jodha handles the
saboot part in front of Jalal is a carbon copy of the rank ineptitude with which she handles the Rahim
aur dature ke ark ki dibbi affair. Drag an unprepared and frightened witness in front of the Shahenshah without any warning and expect them to tell the truth.
Next, what IS the truth to which she wants Bakhsi Banu to testify? Jodha only hears Sharifuddin say to his wife
Sab wapas aa jayega. She has NOT heard him say
Jab shaadi hi nahin hogi to which preceded it. So how does she conclude that Bakshi Banu is privy to Sharifuddin's fraud?
Finally, knowing Jalal's temper and his swiftness to punish brutally, she should have been able to guess that he would execute Sharifuddin on the spot for defrauding him in such a disgraceful manner. She should thus have anticipated that Bakshi Banu would be what is called in legal parlance a hostile witness.
But then Jodha neither has any imagination, nor the ability to put herself in the shoes of another and try to visualise that person's likely reaction. Which is why she always comes a cropper.
Shyamala
Originally posted by: elasingh
Shyamala unlike the forum , I wont give clean chit to Jallu...😆..And Jalal should behave like a Shehenshah instead of running away like coward...The groom party are being absolutely honest...In thoses days if a baarat went back without bride , then it was extremely diffficult to find another groom for Sukanya and BM will loose all respect in his clan( what ever is left)...Jalaal should understand gravity of situation...
O course the groom cann't talk to his father...these are medheival times and parents made all decision regarding marriage...
Originally posted by: sashashyam
Aha, my dearest Ela!! I KNEW you would say that.
If Jalal is convinced that Sharifuddin crooked him on this fort question, I think he will offer the fort to the Rat King. At that point, the Rat Prince may find his voice and get his father, now that their nak has been saved, to give it back.
But the question is this: how is Jalal to be convinced that Sharifuddin has lied? It is too soon for this to be exposed and Sharifuddin to be exiled. And there is no way Bakshi Banu is going to reveal the truth. Or will she?
@bold. Not so much for our Dostana duo, Adham and Sharifuddin. But I found his assertion on Friday that Sharifuddin (leaving aside his Badiammi) could not lie because he had always prayed fo Jalal's welfare quite nutty. Why not just say that he trusted him?
Shyamala
Fan Fictions
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
367