Weekend Analysis Thread 11:Jalal's Reality Check - Page 2

Originally posted by: skanda12

Jalal and Jodha: where goes the relationship?

Where goes this Jodha-Jalal relationship now that it has hit its lowest point, is the million dollar question. When the Creatives gave some tweets at the start of this miscarriage twist, they are supposed to have said that the whole idea was to create this twist to take the love story of Jodha and Jalal to a new level. To me personally, the precap that appeared yesterday was the most interesting indication of how the story may - and should proceed. The background to the current relationship of Jodha and Jalal is that so far it has been based on lots of wrong assumptions on the part of both about each other. Jodha has judged Jalal by what she has heard of his barbarism, and what little she has seen of his uncontrolled bursts of anger. Jalal has judged Jodha by what he has heard of her as a covetable object, and what little he has seen of her as a hatred-fillled shrew. But yesterday in the precap the real opportunity for the beginning of a new chapter in their lives was demonstrated when Jodha broke that glass vase. In that scene Jodha says "Like this glass vase that is broken, neither reputation nor trust nor relationships can ever be joined again, and even if there is a lot of repair done, the scars will always be there". That's very true, my dear girl, but I wish - I so wish - that Jalal would now have the breadth of mind to tell her : "Jodha, my dear, that exactly why we should not attempt to either restore or repair what's broken, but we should buy a whole new and better vase". The way forward, according to me, is for both to wipe the slate completely clean, and to start looking at each other all over again. She should not look at him as the mad man who compounded her misery with the false accusation. He should not look at her as the woman whose already measly impression of him has gone from worse to worst! If Hamida has any sway over their thinking, she at least could tell them "Begin anew!" for that is the only way forward. I hope that is what the Creatives meant when they said the relationship of Jodha and Jalal will now hit a new level. I hope it is not just the old relationship in an altered "eyelocks" format, but a whole new way for both of them to see each other sans past colourings!

Such a beautiful take on jalal-jodha relationship...👏👏Mansi, hats off...🤗Awesome...@bold- I just wish jalal would say something like that with utmost sincerity...it will mark a new chapter in jalal jodha relationship..

Originally posted by: Super Kool

Originally posted by: elasingh

Skanda I totally agree with your points...

The proof against Amerians was weak and Jalal himself admits it in self talk and the investigation was weak and Jodha being proved innocent just because a dibbi has been found in Salima's room is laugable...Is this how such serious crimes were solved in Mughal empire?😃

Ruku on one hand wants Jodha to be punished and on the other hand plays detective with Hoshiyar in toe...

Jalal took Amerians to test their loyality and they passed the test...but Jalal didnot hesitate even a second to raise his sword on Jodha ? Is there no feeling of gratefulness in him?

I am fedup of watching Jalal sleeping with other women...At present I dont find a single reason for Jodha to fall in love with him...😡

Originally posted by: skanda12

2. TRPs at the cost of the story consistencies?

The narrow scoping of the characters was not the only demerit of the TRP chase that the Creatives were attempting. The storyline itself became incredible and to a large extent stagnant and inconsistent. We were told that there was this huge crisis in the Kingdom of Jalal where he had lost the waaris he so wanted. He had suspicious circumstances to contend with, and a set of ready suspects in the form of Jodha and the Amer boys. The whole length and breadth of his court, his family, his subjects were agog with the mystery of the miscarriage. And yet the Creatives forgot the simple fact that in any mystery the protagonist has to at least make some attempts at investigation to unravel the mystery? Should the principal character - Jalal - get so caught up in his anger at the turn of events, that he totally forgets to initiate any sort of enquiry or investigation? Should that investigation be reduced to a small search of the harem by his woolly-headed wife who is dithering between calling the same Jodha a suspect at some times, and exonerating her also at some other times? Does an Emperor of nearly two-thirds of the great land of Hindustan leave it to the nazarband baandhis to bring their own proof to prove their innocence, when they cannot even stir outside their custodial quarters? Does the sane Emperor then try to punish the same baandhis by insisting they wage war for him against their own sambhandis, putting himself at the mercy of these same ill-used and probably antagonistic baandhis to save him at war? At the end of the ten days, does the Emperor then say in the open Sabha that the baandhis were unable to bring proof, but he has one dibbi found by his wife in the harem that gives him the reason to let loose the same baandhis? What on earth is this storyline? Can anybody with an ounce of intelligence buy this method of showing a murder mystery in a famed and historic royal court? Does it not make everyone look like a fool of the highest order - the Emperor, the surrounding Court, the baandhis themselves, the Creatives and most of all the viewers? Just because the TRPs jumped this last week does that justify a storyline that strains all credibility? Is anything annd everything OK so long as the TRP charts justify it? If this is the storyline when TRPs are on the rise, consider how desperately ridiculous the storyline may start getting when TRPs show a small dip!

The so called investigation was a joke...I still don't know who the hell was in-charge of the investigation..??ruk had said MCs had happened in the past as well...couldn't she go and talk to all the victims...?? Couldn't she enquire abt previous MCs from Khwaja shera...?there could be a pattern or something...but, no...nothing at all...

Yesterday, ruk gives an earful and asks jodha to be mindful of people listening to their conversation...a good advice...but..if, I remember correctly...Hoshiyar was present during the 'oh so important' conversation with the dibbi-maker...she should have dismissed hoshiyar first and then should have proceeded with the conversation...practise what you preach lady!!!

Jodha didn't open her mouth once to defend herself...not once she said 'I didn't do it..'..at least in mirchi kaand her arguments had logic...but, this time she was all silent...kyu???

The characters should have some consistency..

Yippeee the show is rocking 🥳🥳🥳🥳 Its nearly no 2!! in such a short time.

Moti bai only irritates now, her role is becoming irrelevant it seems.

Hamida scene was good. Only her scenes need to add value to the story.