@lashy!
Fabulous write up!👏
I agree with you that such reaction from a queen of 16th century was a bit OTT but
what I felt amusing is that Jodha is reacting to Jalal so emotionally and putting logic and to some extent, even ethics in the back burner.😉
First of all - she accused Jalal for mistreating her and not trusting her but there were times when she insulted him and formed opinions about him without knowing the exact reality.
😉
Secondly, when did she plead not guilty "repeatedly" to Shahanshah? She and her brothers decided to stand like a tree rather than screaming or pleading not guilty.
😕
Thirdly and most importantly - Why does Jodha demand that Jalal should ignore all the crucial evidence against them and would only trust her?
I mean - what has she done to win his trust? She has always clearly stated how much she hates Jalal...now when the evidence was against her it was natural for Jalal to believe in the evidence and not her.
If she would have been in Jalal's place she would have done the same...in fact she has already done that in the past.
Jalal's prompt decision to burn Jodha and her brothers was TOTALLY wrong as he was not giving them the chance to prove themselves. But he did give the chance and his decision to attack Sujanpur was not completely personal.
If the fiasco hadn't happened may be he would have warned the Sujanpur party instead of waging war so quickly, but Sujanpur had their share of flaws too.
Even then, Sujanpur folks could have saved their skin by sending messenger to Jalal and surrendering the dacoits to the Mughals. Instead they flouted all the rules of war and attacked them at night.
I just hope that Salima's approach to this situation would be more logical and objective.
Her readiness to spend time with Jalal showed that she listens to her head than her heart. She knows that at one point or the other both husband and wife have to respect each other's demands...Jalal has given her everything she wanted till date...now it's her turn.
Similarly, she would understand the root cause of Jalal's suspicion and his accusations. Like Jodha, she too had never tried to build up any relation with Jalal and in fact showed openly how she loves BK even now. It was natural for Jalal to suspect her because they do not have that bonding so as to ignore the evidence provided and trust Salima blindly.
To see a situation objectively, one needs to have intelligence and detachment from the situation or person involved which Jodha does not have. ( i am talking about detachment to the person involved, not intellect😉)
Hamida- Jodha scene - I found irritating. Hamida is constantly harping that JAlal is angry and only looked at the evidence instead of trusting Jodha's declaration - are aunty ji - why would Jalal ignore all the evidence and will blindly trust jodha? 😕Does mumma dear know her son's relationship with her fav. bahu? 🤔
Edited by doyelpakhi - 12 years ago