This is the worst reality show till date - Page 2

i totally agree wid musicllover7
the judges were harsh on toshi . dont knw y although he is a gr8 siger n a perfomer far far far better than all n specially debojit
last friday when debo was singing jhoot nahi bolna my ears were bleeding it was so bad n his attitude was so rude but the judges gave him the perfect score specailly farah n vishal love the attitude
agr toshi ye attitude dekhaye to buri baat hai mgr wolog dekhaye to acha hai aggressive hai my foot
or jab points nai dene the to toshi ki tareef ki agr toshi ko points dene hote to sur taal sargam sabme kami nazar aati
these judges r toooooo much
mgar toshi ki himmat ko me salam karti hu bhut lightly lata tha sabko mera tiger
uski jaga deboo

hota to show chod deta or ro ro k mar jata mgr wah toshi shaab
tsohi is a trained singer not like these all stupids
toshi ki qadar nahi jante ye log
show ka format hi change kardia points pe sabkuch nirbhar kardia cheeeeee itni jaleousy ek ache singer pe aakhir q wths the reason man.koi hai jo jawab de bd k din uska dil dhukaye
meri awaz kab phunchegi star plus tak vishal shekar farah tak
toshi i love u ur the super star 4ever ur in our hearts
god bless u tumko allah buri nazar se bachaye ameen
kash ye toshi khud padh le.

Originally posted by: Destiny_mkd

bottom line: Toshi ki/ka fan hai yaar ... musiclover7 Toshi is a gr8 singer ... hum sab mante hein (no doubts) .. i go crazy when he sings ab kya soche kya hona hai ... i just love it 👏 👏 👏 ... but beleive me he doesn't deserve 2 stay only coz of his bad luck ... he cudn't give his best on JJWS (leave out 2day's fab performance) ... so ppl have to judge him on what he gave on the show ... right??

nicely said. but i do agree to some extent with the topic starter about vishal. he always says "sur theek nahin tha"! i mean sometimes he's right, i cant disagree with that, but otherwise he should comment about some different aspects of singing also. he comments more on technicality than feel/emotion or anything else, and all are equally important.

Hey guys, This is my first post here. I follow india-forum's every discussion thread, but could never take the initiative to write.I wanted to share something with you regarding a choreographer's knowledge. After seeing JJWS, I wonder if Farah Khan is a well-trained dancer at all?

You know, being a choreographer does not mean that one cannot have sense of sur and taal. Rather, its a must for a trained dancer to have knowledge of sur, tal and ragas. For example, our very famous Kathak dancer Birju Maharaj is equally adept in singing and dancing.He is not the only one example. When one takes lessons in classical dancing and then goes for exams, in the final years, one even need to write exams where he/she is tested about ragas and various aspects of singing apart from dancing skills. Its not essential for a dancer to have a good voice, but he/she needs to gather knowledge about singing.

Farah Khan could never give a constructive and in-depth comment, perhaps she is not trained thoroughly even in dancing. Her comments are very light--"pagalpaan nahi tha, enery bohot thi etc. etc.". If you are giving a score, you need to justify your score by citing what and where one went wrong.She is not capable of that.Vishal and Shekhar at least could point out the pros and cons in a more vivid way, although many-a time their comments seemed biased and also scores were so misleading.

Anyways, the best part of the show is that we got to know that our country is not short of talents and we got to hear such good songs from all the singers. Let us wish them good luck in their careers.

i know farah herself admits that she doesnt have enough knowledge of sur, and i dont think sur is even required, but taal definitely. she must be having knowledge of taal to be a choreographer, otherwise how can she make dancers dance on beat? it's probably that there hasnt ever been any big taal problem with these contestants (once in a while someone slips here or there, but not too much) and she doesnt have much musical knowledge otherwise so she comments on pagalpan, energy, and anything else a person not trained in music would comment on.

what i noticed:

Vishal: always gives technical comments e.g. sur, pitching, high/low notes ... bla bla bla coz i don't have much knowledge in music !!! 😆 😆

Farah: performance, pagalpan/madness, energy, words (clear) & so on

Shakher: feel, connection, notes (mix) 😆

but sometimes they do steel eachothers' words/comments 😆 😆 😆 & sometimes they give sooooooo general comments (kindda useless) !!

Overall i feel they r professional judges Good ones guys so y all this bad stuff about them??

toshi itni dair say kyon gaya yar yeh gana but toshi my dear jatay jatay dikha gya jadoo apna 👏 inshaallah u rock again in future 👏

show bohat hi gyatia hogya hai ab farha ager samnay hoti toi jaan say mardaita isay main saray jajues jahil aur pagal thay 😡 is post pay ok &nbs p; love u all toshi 👏

r u mad coz Toshi is out.....or r u mad at da judges 😕 😕 😕

I love this show..
but i have to agree with u about toshi..
and the judges are always biased with some contestant..

but thats how all reality shows are..and judge picks their favourite and there always favouring them..

I agree with you! I dontt hink they judging singing..
they tell someone some Debojit their sur is a little off but then they give them 10 full marks, its so dumb

Im soo mad Vinit was out he was sucha good singer, stupid debojit 😭