Vineet's elimination

hi all

i am a member of the forum for a couple years now but never posted my views on it despite being upset or unhappy abt any comments. this time i dont know why but i do wanna convey my views abt Vineet's elimination. not only because i am upset but the kind of audience we r is very unjust.

first of all, singing is based on voice quality, ability to carry low and high notes, variety, comfort and above all connecting to the audience. it doesnt at all relate to how a person act or react on or off the stage. performance is important for such a show but that again doesnt get counted on any contestant's personal traits. Audience for such a show is supposed to judge singing and not the singer, which i think indian audience has always failed to do.

if vineet's act of being funny or entertainer r blamed to be cheap and unwanted then i think we should have never let kishore da be our most favourtie singer of all times. Kishore da despite being the best of all times was never a serious guy, always cracking jokes, being funny and entertaining everyone. Would it be treated as a negative trait if we rate him as a singer, NO coz he was a singer first for all of us. Why cant we pick the same criteria for such music shows?

vineet's version of song 'satrangi re' was ridiculed by so many viewers but did anyone try to think that he had already shown his singing skill when he sung the song first time with utmost perfection. when he got to do the song second time he is supposed to treat it a different way than first just the way a genuine budding singer would do, he did do the justice to the song but yes he didnt repeat his act as he was not intending to do that. would it make him a bad singer if he is trying to prove his own singing skills?

off the stage what he does is not part of this competition and if u think that affects the voting then i think it is not to be blamed on participants it is the audience who fails to link to the singing. in SRGMP there were many occasions when he outshined debojeet but he lost, the major factor there was regional voting. Is it not true that debojeet failed on a quiet a few songs during the competition? he is a better singer than last time, no doubt, but he still has problems singing high notes.

again the intention here is not to express my grief at vineet's elimination but a request to the audience who votes a contestant but doesnt vote the right talent.

PLEASE THINK ABOVE REGIONALISM AND CHARACTER ANALYSIS AND JUST FOCUS ON SINGING WHEN U DO WANT TO BE PART OF SUCH COMPETITIONS AS A GENUINE AUDIENCE

Originally posted by: Rajeev Ki Heer

agree yaar....
@indian doll- yaar if same thing wld have been done by Vineet then God know how much bashing he wld have faced more......but its diff now as someone else asked votes on the name of charity and that is good act by them😆 ...jo vineet kare woh sin....jo baaki karein woh punya 😆 .......

ppl blame his funny acts for his elimination bcz they have nothing else to blame...Vinit is THE SUPERSTAR

Totally agree....i hadnt watched SRGMP and didnt know either Vinit or Debo...but vinit never failed to impress me in JJWS....he is truely talented and a SUPERSTAR ....Debo on the other hand though a very good singer came across as a very manipulative person to me

Originally posted by: Sandy_bedi

hi all

i am a member of the forum for a couple years now but never posted my views on it despite being upset or unhappy abt any comments. this time i dont know why but i do wanna convey my views abt Vineet's elimination. not only because i am upset but the kind of audience we r is very unjust.

first of all, singing is based on voice quality, ability to carry low and high notes, variety, comfort and above all connecting to the audience. it doesnt at all relate to how a person act or react on or off the stage. performance is important for such a show but that again doesnt get counted on any contestant's personal traits. Audience for such a show is supposed to judge singing and not the singer, which i think indian audience has always failed to do.

if vineet's act of being funny or entertainer r blamed to be cheap and unwanted then i think we should have never let kishore da be our most favourtie singer of all times. Kishore da despite being the best of all times was never a serious guy, always cracking jokes, being funny and entertaining everyone. Would it be treated as a negative trait if we rate him as a singer, NO coz he was a singer first for all of us. Why cant we pick the same criteria for such music shows?

vineet's version of song 'satrangi re' was ridiculed by so many viewers but did anyone try to think that he had already shown his singing skill when he sung the song first time with utmost perfection. when he got to do the song second time he is supposed to treat it a different way than first just the way a genuine budding singer would do, he did do the justice to the song but yes he didnt repeat his act as he was not intending to do that. would it make him a bad singer if he is trying to prove his own singing skills?

off the stage what he does is not part of this competition and if u think that affects the voting then i think it is not to be blamed on participants it is the audience who fails to link to the singing. in SRGMP there were many occasions when he outshined debojeet but he lost, the major factor there was regional voting. Is it not true that debojeet failed on a quiet a few songs during the competition? he is a better singer than last time, no doubt, but he still has problems singing high notes.

again the intention here is not to express my grief at vineet's elimination but a request to the audience who votes a contestant but doesnt vote the right talent.

PLEASE THINK ABOVE REGIONALISM AND CHARACTER ANALYSIS AND JUST FOCUS ON SINGING WHEN U DO WANT TO BE PART OF SUCH COMPETITIONS AS A GENUINE AUDIENCE

Originally posted by: ~*indian doll*~

yes i agree with u..if ppl did vote on talent he wud still be inn😊
but sadly ppl are doin the exact oppositee for example giving
votess to actors like debo lol whuz dream iz to built charity homes
for old ppl.