Misjudgement AGAIN

Nimmi

@msuns

Explorer

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: ashiqur123
Sorry guys, but I do think that judging is done in pretty unbiased way. Toshi is the weakest singer in JJWS now. He's got serious problems with perfect pitching and range. His voice cracks a lot. He is not very versatile. The sargam he does are almost miles away from the actual notes. Sorry to say, but Shekhar was right to point it out to Toshi that "sargam sur mein hona chahiye ". His elder brother Sharib is 100 times better singer than him.

Please don't compare between 2 brothers...i think it's a awful thing to do...they both r great...sometime Toshi sings better than Sharib...sometimes Sharid does better...but it's very unfair to compare between them...and btw..moderators forbade to compare any singer of JJWS to any other singer of other shows...

Edited by msuns - 17 years ago

Reply

Quote

Kaushal Sharma

@silverspike

Beginner

4

Posted: 17 years ago

#12

Can you guys tell me when vineet didnt sing well and got 30....I think this forum is full of abhejeet, debojeet, and toshi fans...You guys are questioning on judgement and on the show itself....If you dont like the show dont watch it yaar....
I think Vishal and shekhar are the best musical reality show judges.

Reply

Quote

arayq2

@arayq2

Explorer

6

Posted: 17 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: ashiqur123
His elder brother Sharib

Actually, Toshi is older by 3 years.

As for the judging, in my estimation, only Abhijit, Debojit and Harshit are being judged more or less fairly. They are too hard on Toshi, and too soft on Rahul and Vineet.

Reply

Quote

Nimmi

@msuns

Explorer

8

Posted: 17 years ago

#14

Clearly only Vineet fans find the judges fair..don't take it hard...it's quite obvious...if they do the things to Toshi that they do to Vineet...may be I also would think these judges are the best...so...and watch it not because of the judges...watch it for good music...wish judges wouldn't make this show irritating in some point...

btw...another thing...what Vishal did to Rahul...i really didn't find it fair...to tell him to get 10...and to create this type of mental stress...even just before singing (watched on coming up part)...that's really not a good thing to do...personally I'm not a supporter of Rahul...but yesterday I felt that to create such unnecessary pressure to a contestant is not anything wise...this kind of attitude actually make them nervous and it affects their singing too!

Reply

Quote

avijee

@avijee

Navigator

12

Posted: 17 years ago

#15

Atleast Abhijeet & Toshi should have got 30 each. 😭

Reply

Quote

sgtp111

@sgtp111

Beginner

0

Posted: 17 years ago

#16

Toshi is a good singer.. BUT he is not singing that well in this competition so far. Also he is not versatile, lets hope whatever he is good at he does it well in future.

Vineet.. comon guys ..he is too good. He gets 30 when he truly deserves.

Reply

Quote