What Do these Judges Want - Page 4

Originally posted by: sagar1601

I am a newbie on this forum but have been reading people's comments here for quite some time. What I have observed that there are only few contestents who are really popular here for different reasons. Some people say they are best singer while the others like them for because they feel they are hot. Then there are others who just like a contestent for particular reasons.

Now coming to my point here, Toshi seems to have quite a fan base for good or bad reasons. It seems to me that everyone likes to talk about him and make comments whether they are good or bad. The only conclusion I come up with is that it is good for him and his growing popularity. As for his his song on Friday, I still haven't seen it because I am in Toronto and the show doesn't come until 10:30 at night.

As for Toshi as a singer, even people who don't him as a singer or maybe for another reason would agree that he is a damn good singer and probably one of the singers who could possibly win this thing. One thing I do agree with is judges are biased towards some contestents and unfair towards some and unfortunately Toshi has always been on their bad sides. There have been so many times that other contestents who are obvious judges favourite have sung badly and got bad remarks too but judges gave them good marks. So there is insonsistency between their marks and remarks. .

Well said..

@ the bolded part: Oh!! Toshi is the talk of the town..:-)

Originally posted by: sagar1601

I am a newbie on this forum but have been reading people's comments here for quite some time. What I have observed that there are only few contestents who are really popular here for different reasons. Some people say they are best singer while the others like them for because they feel they are hot. Then there are others who just like a contestent for particular reasons.

Now coming to my point here, Toshi seems to have quite a fan base for good or bad reasons. It seems to me that everyone likes to talk about him and make comments whether they are good or bad. The only conclusion I come up with is that it is good for him and his growing popularity. As for his his song on Friday, I still haven't seen it because I am in Toronto and the show doesn't come until 10:30 at night.

As for Toshi as a singer, even people who don't him as a singer or maybe for another reason would agree that he is a damn good singer and probably one of the singers who could possibly win this thing. One thing I do agree with is judges are biased towards some contestents and unfair towards some and unfortunately Toshi has always been on their bad sides. There have been so many times that other contestents who are obvious judges favourite have sung badly and got bad remarks too but judges gave them good marks. So there is insonsistency between their marks and remarks. As for their credibility, these judges are still young (Vishal and Shekhar) and they themselves have a long way to go. As for Farah, she simply doesn't qualify as judge on this show specialy when it has contestents this good. Not to say I am a music maestro but at least I can say that safely that Star could have chosen better judges for a show like this which has contestents of this caliber.

Agreed with most points 👏👏👏

Loved one point that Farah is not suitable for the judges chair..........

Originally posted by: koolgal_anisha

oh pleez juss bcuz VS r young dsnt mean dat theya rent fit to judge as a matter of fact dey r more sensible than many other jufges around whu r way elder to thm i dun wanna name any1 but ya thats d way it is

n i proudly maintain dat VS are undoubtedly thebest judges on d block currently alongside wid pritam n shnker..!!!

That's your opinion and I completely respect that. You think they are most sensible and I think they are a little amaturish. It's just a difference of opinion.

Originally posted by: L.A.M.B

Atleast they were sensible And they would never say something like " jub rehman ne gaya tub bhi sur klii bohut kami thi" I mean what type of a person says something like that about Ar Rehman Who has films Like RDB,Guru,Kisna,Roja,Dil se,Taal,Zubeida,Lagaan,Elizabeth The Golden Age..And the list goes on and on he has probably composed more music than VS..He has received more awards than them and is one of the Worlds top 25 top selling recording artist.the only Asian to be included alongside another forgot the name......And AR has also received the Padma Shri..........

Vishal a being a music director must worship some one like AR but instead he critcized him...........This shows what calibre of singers he prefer and definatly shows his knowledge of music!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by: koolgal_anisha

LOL ye rytt...!! n they shudve also had Ismail darbar so dat he wudve given toshi a full 10 even fr his amateurish performance!!!😆😆😆

Ah now i understand what you people want you want judges who are not classically trained and you want a choreographer who sees nothing besides how cute some contestant is!!!!!and you people want hiphoppers like VS............ Who are actually treating this show like a joke!!!!!!

lolss letss just sayy toshi needs to traain more,, he sings REALL bad these days , no offence, like his "jag soona soona laage" wass hurting my ears, i HAD to go listen to the original after i heard his performance

loll andd about the judges, FARAH AND VS RULLEEEE 😃

Originally posted by: King Anu

unlike one person's supposedly meritous judge, rehman comes up with original music

Agree with the bold part.

Originally posted by: King Anu

unlike one person's supposedly meritous judge, rehman comes up with original music